Concept
Defaulting Buyers of Goods
Restitution for the party in breach
Defaulting Buyers of Goods
The common-law starting point was forfeiture. In the labor contract that Britton v. Turner confronted, the party who "voluntarily fails to fulfill the contract by performing the whole labor contracted for" recovered nothing for the work he had done, "however much he may have done towards the performance," and that was "considered the settled rule of law."1 The court objected to what the rule produced. An owner who had kept nine and a half months of labor worth $95 to him would, if the defense succeeded, receive nearly five-sixths of a year's labor, a gain "utterly disproportionate" to any damage the early departure could have caused.2 A defaulting buyer of goods is spared that result. UCC § 2-718 permits restitution in his favor and charges him a modest penalty for the breach.3
The Code and the Restatement divide the territory by subject matter. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 374(1) states the general rule for a breacher's claim. When the other party justifiably refuses to perform because the breach discharged his remaining duties, the party in breach recovers the benefit he conferred by part performance or reliance, to the extent it exceeds the loss his breach caused.4 That rule fixes no deduction in advance, so the seller's protection is whatever loss it can show. A deposit on a delivery truck falls under the Code instead. A deposit on a house or a payment under a construction contract does not, and jurisdictions split on whether the defaulting party may recover anything. Some allow quasi-contractual relief less damages for breach, and others refuse it.5
The statute works in two stages, and the contract comes first. If the parties wrote a valid liquidated-damages clause, meaning a sum they fixed in advance as the seller's damages for breach, the buyer recovers payments to the extent they exceed the amount the clause lets the seller keep.6 Only when the contract has no such clause does the statutory formula apply. The seller's share is then the smaller of $500 or 20 percent of the price, and the buyer recovers payments above that figure.7
The restitution figure is a ceiling, not a guarantee. The buyer's claim is subject to a further offset for the seller's actual damages and for the value of any benefits the buyer received as a result of the contract.8 The seller's right to set off its Article 2 damages is part of the statute itself.9 A seller who proves substantial harm can shrink the buyer's recovery, perhaps to nothing, and a seller who proves none leaves the buyer with the formula result.
The arithmetic is simple. A buyer agrees to pay $2,100 for furniture, pays $700, repudiates, and sues for the down payment. Twenty percent of the price is $420, which is less than $500, so $420 is the deduction, and the buyer recovers $700 less $420, or $280, before any offset for the seller's damages or benefits received.10 Twenty percent is the smaller figure only when the price is below $2,500. Above that price the $500 figure controls, and the deduction stops growing. A buyer who pays $30,000 on a $100,000 purchase, under a contract with no clause, faces a $500 deduction, because 20 percent of the price is $20,000. His claim is $29,500 before offsets, and the seller's chief way to cut it is to prove its own damages.
A clause controls only if it is valid. Section 2-718(1) asks whether the amount is reasonable in light of the anticipated or actual harm caused by the breach, the difficulties of proving loss, and the inconvenience or nonfeasibility of otherwise obtaining an adequate remedy.11 The statute speaks only of validly agreed damages, so a clause that fails that test gives the seller no protected sum.12
Set beside § 374(1), the Code trades the Restatement's case-by-case measure for a fixed deduction. Under the Restatement the buyer's recovery shrinks only by the loss his breach caused, so a seller who suffers no loss leaves him the full benefit he conferred.13 Under the Code the seller keeps the statutory amount as a penalty on the breaching buyer, apart from any damages it proves, and the offset for those damages can reduce the recovery further.14 Because the deduction is described as modest, even a deliberate defaulter keeps most of a large payment unless the seller proves its own loss.
Motive does not change the result. The Code permits restitution to a breaching buyer whether or not the breach was willful, and the same deduction falls on every defaulting buyer.15 Outside the Code, courts remain divided on whether a willful breach should prevent restitution at all.16 For goods the question is settled. The deliberate defaulter pays the penalty and recovers the rest, less the seller's proven damages.
The fifth step is where the Code and the Restatement meet, because both end by subtracting what the breach cost the seller.