Concept
Suspension of the Original Duty
Remedies when the obligee breaches an accord
Suspension of the Original Duty
An accord that has been made but not yet performed leaves the original duty in a middle state: the duty is suspended. Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281(2), the original duty stays suspended until the accord is performed, unless the obligor breaches the accord seriously enough to discharge the obligee's new duty to accept the substitute performance. If that kind of breach occurs, the obligee may enforce either the original duty or any duty under the accord.1
"Suspended" does not mean "discharged." A discharged duty is extinguished and does not come back. A suspended duty still exists and still belongs to the obligee, who simply cannot enforce it for the time being. The very term executory accord makes the point: it underscores that the accord itself does not discharge the duty.2 Suspension describes the status of the original duty in the interval between the accord and its performance.
The law could have chosen a different rule, and the alternatives show why suspension is the right one. An obligee would not trade an existing right to $450 for a bare promise of $425; the right is given up only for actual payment.3 If the accord discharged the original duty the moment it was made, Brandt would be left holding only a promise, and a default by Okafor would leave her worse off than before the deal. If the accord had no effect on the original duty, Brandt could ignore the agreement and sue on the $450 while Okafor stood ready to deliver the substitute, and her promise to accept it would be worthless to him. Older law took something close to this second view, treating an unperformed accord as no defense to an action on the underlying duty, and that view is now generally rejected.4 Suspension keeps the original claim in reserve as security for the obligee and bars the obligee from enforcing it while the obligor is performing as agreed.
Performance changes the duty's fate. Change the facts so that Okafor delivers the $425 check on August 1 and Brandt cashes it. The executory accord ripens into an accord and satisfaction, and it is then too late for Brandt to change her mind and recover the additional $25; the accord and satisfaction is a defense to that claim.5 Compare the two failed suits. The July 15 suit failed because the debt could not yet be enforced. A suit for the extra $25 after August 1 fails because the debt no longer exists.
In practice, the performance that completes an accord is often just a creditor cashing a check tendered as full payment. Section 1-308(b) of the Uniform Commercial Code clarifies that cashing a full-payment check, even with a reservation of rights, still constitutes an accord and satisfaction. The creditor is then barred from collecting the unpaid balance unless the creditor can establish a ground for avoiding the accord and satisfaction, such as duress.6
Students usually go wrong in one of two directions. Treating the executory accord as discharging the debt on signing leads to the conclusion that the obligee can never sue on the $450, even if the obligor never pays. Treating the accord as irrelevant until performance leads to the conclusion that the obligee may sue on the $450 while the obligor is ready to pay. The correct position lies between them: the debt is suspended, which defeats an early suit but leaves the claim alive.
Section 281(2) states one exception, and it comes from the obligor's side. Suppose Okafor tells Brandt before August 1 that he will pay nothing. If that breach is serious enough to discharge Brandt's duty to accept the $425, the suspension ends and Brandt may enforce either the original duty or the accord.7 The sections that follow take up a breach by the obligee, and the suspension rule is the baseline against which both kinds of breach are measured.