Concept
Cancellation
Aggrieved seller's remedies when the buyer breaches
Cancellation
A seller whose buyer has stopped performing needs two things: a way out of the deal and a way to be paid for the deal that failed. Section 2-703(f) of the Uniform Commercial Code supplies the first by closing the seller's remedy menu with a single word: after a qualifying buyer breach, the aggrieved seller may "cancel."1 Like every other item on the menu, cancellation opens only after the buyer wrongfully rejects or revokes acceptance, fails to make a payment due on or before delivery, or repudiates.2
The word is a term of art, and the Code's definitions, not everyday speech, supply its meaning. As quoted in a footnote in Brewer v. J-Six Farms, L.P., cancellation occurs when either party puts an end to the contract for breach by the other, and its effect is the same as that of termination, except that the canceling party also retains any remedy for breach of the whole contract or any unperformed balance.3
The definition does two jobs. Ending the contract frees the seller from its own remaining duties. Without that power, a seller facing a buyer who has stopped giving shipping instructions or stopped paying would have to keep goods, production capacity, and credit committed to a deal the buyer has abandoned. The retained-remedies clause answers the opposite risk. Ending a contract could look like giving it up, and a seller who feared that reading would hesitate to end anything and would go on absorbing the cost of waiting. Because the definition preserves every remedy for breach of the whole contract or any unperformed balance, ending the contract costs the seller nothing on its claim. The seller leaves the relationship and keeps its right to be paid for the bargain the buyer broke.
The Code keeps cancellation apart from termination, which occurs when either party, under a power created by agreement or by law, puts an end to the contract otherwise than for its breach.4 On termination, all obligations still executory on both sides are discharged, and any right based on prior breach or performance survives.5 What survives is whatever has already accrued, such as the debt for goods already delivered or a claim for an earlier breach. Cancellation adds the seller's claim over the future, the remedy for the unperformed balance. The difference traces to whether a breach exists to support it. An ending authorized by the contract's own terms or by law answers no wrong, so nothing remains for a remedy to compensate beyond what has already come due.
Cancellation pays nothing by itself. It ends the contract and preserves the seller's remedies, and the money still comes from another item on the menu, which is why cancellation is paired with resale, damages for nonacceptance, or the price and never offered as a substitute for them. The cases show the pairing at work. In Peace River Seed Co-operative, Ltd. v. Proseeds Marketing, a seller cancelled its grass seed contracts after the buyer stopped giving shipping instructions as seed prices fell.6 Cancelling did not cost the seller its claim, because the court held that it was entitled to market-price damages even if they exceeded its resale-price damages.7 In Hessel v. Christie's, Inc., the auction's conditions of sale listed canceling the sale and reselling the property among Christie's remedies when a buyer failed to pay in full within seven calendar days.8 The court added that even without those conditions, Hessel was in breach, and Section 2-703 let Christie's cancel the sale and resell the Koons and the Basquiat at auction.9
The two sellers reached cancellation from different triggers, a refusal to give instructions in one case and a missed payment in the other. Each then ended the deal and looked to another remedy for the money: market-price damages in Peace River, and resale in Hessel. A student who lists cancellation as the seller's remedy and stops has not told the examiner how the seller gets paid.
Cancellation also marks one branch of the choice a seller faces when a buyer backs out. In Precision Mirror & Glass v. Nelms, the buyer's anticipatory breach came after the seller had already cut the glass, and the court added that even if the glass had not been cut, a seller faced with such a breach may either accept the repudiation or continue to perform and sue for breach.10 The buyer who walks away from a contract without cause is the party in breach, so he is not canceling. Cancellation belongs to the party aggrieved by the other's breach. The Code frames the same choice in its treatment of repudiation. The aggrieved party may await performance, or it may resort to any remedy for breach even after saying it would wait and urging retraction, and in either case it may suspend its own performance or proceed to identify goods to the contract or salvage unfinished goods.11 Cancellation is the remedy-for-breach branch of that choice, and it tells the buyer that the seller treats the repudiation as final. A seller that waits keeps the contract alive and its own duties with it, while a seller that cancels discharges them.
The scope limit that governs the whole menu governs cancellation too. The seller's remedies reach the goods directly affected by the breach, and they reach the whole undelivered balance only if the breach is of the whole contract.12 In Shields Pork Plus, Inc. v. Swiss Valley Ag Service, the buyer's rejection of 300 of 680 properly tendered pigs was a breach as to those pigs, and the buyer's later repudiation put the rejected deliveries after it in play.13 A seller's cancellation is therefore only as broad as the breach behind it.