Concept
Selecting Remedies on the Facts
Aggrieved buyer's remedies when the seller breaches
Selecting Remedies on the Facts
Section 2-711(1) names four events that open the buyer’s remedies: the seller fails to make delivery, the seller repudiates, the buyer rightfully rejects, or the buyer justifiably revokes acceptance. After any of them the buyer may cancel, recover so much of the price as it has paid, and, whether or not it has cancelled, pursue damages.1 Damages come by one of two routes: cover, or damages for nondelivery.2 Subsection (2) adds remedies that reach the goods themselves when the seller fails to deliver or repudiates, and subsection (3) gives a buyer who holds rejected or revoked goods a security interest in them.3 The earlier sections taught each remedy alone. This one teaches how they combine.
Acceptance divides the buyer’s remedies into two tracks. Section 2-711 serves the buyer who has not accepted the goods or who has justifiably revoked its acceptance.4 A buyer who accepts and keeps nonconforming goods recovers under § 2-714, whose “value difference” measures its damages, with incidental and consequential damages added under § 2-715 where appropriate.5 Section 2-711 is also a guide and not a full inventory. Its caption, “Buyer’s remedies in general,” does not exclude remedies that sit in other sections.6 A fact pattern therefore calls for a route through the whole scheme, and the route starts with a question about the buyer: has it accepted the goods?
Because each remedy has its own text, a buyer can often claim several at once, and that raises two problems. The first is how much one loss can support. The Code answers by rejecting election of remedies and by measuring the whole recovery against the position performance would have produced.7 The first subsection below shows how that limit works. The second problem is method. The second subsection turns the chapter into a sequence that runs from the triggering event to a final dollar figure.
Cumulative, Not Duplicative
Section 2-711(1) is a menu whose items stack. After nondelivery, repudiation, rightful rejection, or justifiable revocation, the buyer may cancel and, “whether or not he has done so,” may cover or recover damages for nondelivery “in addition to recovering so much of the price as has been paid.”8 The words “in addition” join the refund to the damages remedies, and the word “or” joins cover to nondelivery damages. The only choice the text forces is between the two damages measures.9
The Code wrote the menu this way because it rejected election of remedies. Under prior law, a buyer who rescinded and refused or returned the goods recovered the price paid and no more, while a buyer who sought damages had to affirm the agreement and keep the goods.10 Neither buyer could both leave the deal and be paid for the breach. Section 2-711(1) removes the choice. The right to cancel and recover the price does not preclude money damages, which the buyer may recover whether or not it cancels.11
Cumulative does not mean that every remedy pays in full on the same loss. The Code applies its remedies to put the injured buyer where performance would have put it,12 and that expectancy can be satisfied only once. The damages formulas respect the limit. Cover damages are the cost of cover minus the contract price,13 and market damages are the market price when the buyer learned of the breach minus the contract price,14 so neither formula pays back the price itself. Money the buyer has already paid returns, if at all, through the refund. The refund and the damages therefore cover different slices of one loss, and together they leave the buyer paying the contract price for the replacement and nothing more. A buyer who prepaid, covered, and then sues may be tempted to claim the refund, the cover difference, and the market differential. The Code allows the first two.
The market formula is closed to the bakery to the extent it covered, because that remedy applies only when and to the extent the buyer does not cover.15
The add-ons stack by the same logic. Section 2-715 permits incidental and consequential damages where appropriate.16 Consequential damages compensate the profit the buyer would have earned by reselling or otherwise using the goods in a deal with a third party,17 a loss that the gap between the replacement price and the contract price does not measure. Consequential damages must also be foreseeable and proved with reasonable certainty.18 A layer the buyer cannot prove drops out, and the other layers stand.
Possession and use of the goods do not defeat these remedies. A New Mexico decision rejected the argument that a buyer who had physical possession of a vehicle before revoking could not recover nondelivery damages.19 The court explained that the damages in § 2-711 apply to a buyer who rightfully rejects and to one who justifiably revokes, and that physical delivery does not eliminate them.20
Accepted goods run on a separate track, and the authority there does not speak with one voice. A buyer who keeps nonconforming goods recovers under § 2-714.21 A decision applying Arkansas’s Code calls revocation of acceptance and damages for breach of warranty “nonalternative in character,” so that the buyer “may pursue either remedy or both.” The same decision stresses that they are “separate remedies treated in entirely different sections of the Code” offering “separate forms of relief.” A finding of breach of warranty therefore did not by itself entitle that buyer to cancellation and the return of his down payment.22 Treatise authority states a stricter rule. A plaintiff generally may not recover both restitution and damages for breach and must elect at some stage, and in the warranty setting the buyer is entitled to either restitution or damages, not both.23 The likely reason is that § 2-714 measures damages for a buyer who retains the goods,24 so a refund of the whole price on top of that measure would pay twice for goods the buyer still holds. A student who meets a combined claim for a refund and warranty damages should state the § 2-711 rule first, identify which track the buyer is on, and flag the contrary authority instead of declaring a winner.
Use raises a separate limit. A refund returns the whole price, but a buyer who revoked may have driven the car or lived in the home for months first, and the seller can ask for a credit against the buyer’s recovery. In the New Mexico vehicle case the seller argued that the buyer’s use and a dent should be set off against her damages, and the court held that such an offset is legally permissible.25 The seller still got no reduction. The record showed use and a dent but gave neither evidence nor inference of the reasonable value of the use, the loss in value from the dent, or the cost of repair, and without a basis for a dollar figure it was not error to apply no offset.26
Where the evidence supplies a figure, the offset applies. In a mobile-home case, buyers who had revoked kept occupying the home because that was the most feasible way to protect it from water damage. The trial court gave the defendant an offset for the rental value of the home during the occupancy, and the appellate court found that the defendant suffered no loss from it.27 Some courts likewise award sellers a sum for the value buyers derived from use before rejection or revocation.28 The two outcomes differ on proof, not principle: the mobile-home court had a rental value to apply, and the vehicle seller had only the fact of use.
A problem that lists every remedy the buyer wants thus reduces to three checks. Add the claims against the position performance would have produced. Strike any claim that pays the same loss a second time. Ask whether the seller has proved a value for the buyer’s use of the goods. A buyer who covered keeps the refund and the cover difference. A buyer who kept accepted goods stays on the § 2-714 track. A rejecting or revoking buyer who used the goods owes a credit only to the extent the seller can put a number on the use.
Walking the Menu
Section 2-711(1) fixes the order in which a buyer-remedies problem should be worked. Its opening clause names the four events that unlock every remedy on the list, and the rest of the subsection says what the buyer may do once one of them has occurred.34 A route from the first fact to a final figure works because each stop depends on the one before it. A refund needs a trigger, a cover price counts only if the buyer covered, and a lost-profit claim can be sized only after the base measure is fixed. Working in the statute’s sequence collects the remedies the facts support and leaves out the rest.
Courts describe the menu in much the same order. A Washington decision states the damages choice as two alternatives. One is cover, in which the buyer purchases substitute goods in good faith and without unreasonable delay and recovers the cost of cover minus the contract price. The other is damages for nondelivery, “also known as ‘hypothetical cover,’” measured by the market price when the buyer learned of the breach minus the contract price.35 Idaho’s version of § 2-711(3) also lists the buyer’s right to resell the goods as an aggrieved seller to recover any part of the price paid and the expenses reasonably incurred in their inspection, receipt, transportation, care, and custody.36 The order has a practical logic. The buyer exits, then gets paid, then protects the goods, and each later item is sized by an earlier one: the add-ons ride on the base measure, and the base measure exists only after a trigger.
The first step decides whether the rest of the menu applies. Section 2-711 serves a buyer that has not accepted the goods, either because the seller failed to deliver or repudiated or because the buyer rightfully rejected. A buyer that justifiably revokes acceptance joins them, with the same rights as a rejecting buyer.37 A buyer that accepted nonconforming goods and kept them still holds the goods, so its damages come from § 2-714.38 The sorting cannot be skipped, since a defect in the goods does not by itself open § 2-711.
Once the posture places the buyer on the § 2-711 track, cancellation and the refund come next. The statute gives both to every such buyer, and its words “whether or not he has done so” keep the damages remedies open whatever the buyer decides about cancelling.39 Only money actually paid counts toward the refund, so the step begins by totaling deposits and prepayments. Step three then chooses the base measure. The statute writes cover and nondelivery damages as alternatives,40 and the choice turns on what the buyer did, because the market remedy applies only when and to the extent the buyer does not cover.41 An Illinois appellate court applied that rule when a defendant argued that the market formula governed a repudiation after the aggrieved party had covered. The court rejected the argument, noting that § 2-713 applies where the aggrieved party has not effected cover and that § 2-712(2), the cost of cover minus the contract price, supplies the measure where it has.42
Step four adds the layers that sit on the base measure. Consequential damages carry conditions the other layers lack. The loss must result from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller had reason to know when contracting, it must be a loss that cover or other reasonable steps could not have prevented, and it must be foreseeable and proved with reasonable certainty.43 The middle condition ties step four back to step three. A buyer that took the market formula and made no effort to replace the goods may keep the base differential yet lose the lost profits that a reasonable replacement purchase would have avoided.
Steps five and six add the least money in the typical problem. The goods-reaching remedies of § 2-711(2) open only when the seller fails to deliver or repudiates.44 They matter chiefly when damages leave the buyer short, as with a unique item that no market can replace, and a decree is reserved for a proper case. A buyer who can cover or recover a market differential already holds an adequate remedy, so the step usually ends with a sentence explaining why no decree is proper. The security interest in step six belongs to a different buyer, one who rejected or revoked and holds the goods. It secures the price paid and the expenses reasonably incurred in inspection, receipt, transportation, care, and custody, and it lets the buyer hold the goods and resell them as an aggrieved seller would.45 A buyer whose seller failed to deliver or repudiated has no goods in its possession or control to secure its payments,46 so ordinarily only one of the two steps applies to a given buyer.
A complete run through the steps looks like this when a seller repudiates after taking a deposit.
The $3,800 passes the single-satisfaction check in step seven. The fabricator laid out $2,000 as a deposit, $11,500 for the replacement, and $300 in fees, a total of $13,800, and the recovery leaves it with a net cost of $10,000, the price it agreed to pay. Double counting would break that arithmetic. Suppose comparable presses sold for $12,500 on the day the fabricator learned of the repudiation. A student might add the $2,500 market differential to the cover damages, but the fabricator covered, so the market formula is closed to it.47 The addition would raise the recovery to $6,300 and cut the net cost to $7,500 for a press promised at $10,000, so the fabricator would profit from the seller’s breach.
The remaining trap concerns consequential damages. Suppose the fabricator had left the press unreplaced for three weeks and then billed the seller for three weeks of lost production profit. The claim would run into the condition that the loss be one cover or other reasonable steps could not have prevented, and the facts say a comparable press was available.48 The fabricator would still recover a base measure, because market damages stand as a complete alternative for a buyer who does not cover,49 but the lost profit that a prompt replacement would have avoided drops out. A buyer for whom no reasonable replacement existed stands differently, and its idle-line losses can fall within the statute. Posture sits above every one of these figures. Had the fabricator accepted the press and found a defect later, the cancellation, refund, and cover arithmetic would never begin, because the problem would belong to § 2-714.