Concept
Who Counts as a Beneficiary
Intended or incidental beneficiary
Intended and Incidental Beneficiaries
Who Counts as a Beneficiary
A beneficiary, in the Restatement's definition, is any person other than the promisee who will gain when a promise is performed.1 Two conditions carry the definition: the person is not the promisee, and performance will benefit that person. Nothing in it asks whether the contracting parties wanted that person to have a claim, or whether a court would let the person sue. At this stage a beneficiary is simply someone who gains if the promise is kept. Later sections of this chapter sort beneficiaries into those who hold enforceable rights and those who do not.
The definition borrows two terms, so the roles come first. A promise is a manifestation of intention to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, made so that the person receiving it is justified in understanding that a commitment has been made.2 The person manifesting that intention is the promisor, and the person to whom the manifestation is addressed is the promisee.3 Those labels can mislead in a bilateral contract, because the terms are relative: each party is a promisor as to its own performance and a promisee as to the performance the other side promised. From the beneficiary's side of the table, though, "promisor" has a fixed meaning: the party who has committed to perform in the beneficiary's favor.4
The way out of the relativity is to start with the one promise the claimant wants to enforce. Its maker is the promisor, and the person to whom it was made is the promisee.5 Order matters here. Whether a beneficiary holds rights depends on what the promisee meant to accomplish by obtaining that promise, so the analysis turns on the promisee's intentions, and no one can ask about those intentions until the promisee has been found.6
The running example for this chapter is a three-party sale. Debtor owes Creditor $200,000. Debtor contracts to sell land to Buyer for $200,000, and the contract stipulates that Buyer will pay the price to Creditor.7 Take Buyer's promise to pay. Buyer made it and is the promisor. Debtor received it and is the promisee. Creditor is neither, will receive the money, and is therefore a beneficiary.8 Debtor supplies the contrast. Payment to Creditor discharges Debtor's debt, so Debtor gains from Buyer's performance. But Debtor is the promisee of that promise, and the definition reaches only persons other than the promisee. The labels also move with the promise: if the question concerned Debtor's promise to convey the land, Debtor would be the promisor and Buyer the promisee.
Being a beneficiary tells you nothing about rights, and the Restatement says so directly. Its comment describes "promisee" and "beneficiary" as neutral with respect to rights and duties: either, both, or neither may have a legal right to performance. Neither is necessarily the person who receives performance, the person who gets the economic benefit, or the person who furnished the consideration.9 The label asks only whether a person gains, and the law then asks a second question about whether that person may enforce the promise. The second question divides beneficiaries into intended beneficiaries, who acquire a right by virtue of the promise, and incidental beneficiaries, who do not.10
Older case law sorts beneficiaries with enforceable rights under two labels you will keep meeting. Historically, courts called them donee or creditor beneficiaries, and called a third party without enforceable rights an incidental beneficiary. The line between donee and creditor depends on whether the promisee was trying to confer a gift on the third party or to discharge an obligation, real or assumed, that was owed to that party.11 Creditor in the running example is the classic creditor beneficiary: Debtor's purpose in the sale is to have the proceeds travel directly to Creditor to settle the debt.12 The classification is only an aid, not a conclusive test, for deciding whether a beneficiary has enforceable rights at all. In some jurisdictions it also affects the parties' power to modify or rescind their contract.13