Concept
The Beneficiary's Enforceable Right
Identification and disclaimer
Unidentified Beneficiaries and Disclaimer
The Beneficiary's Enforceable Right
Everything else in this chapter assumes one point: an intended beneficiary holds a right against the promisor. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 304 states it. A promise in a contract creates a duty in the promisor to any intended beneficiary to perform the promise, and the intended beneficiary may enforce the duty.1 Because the duty runs from the promisor straight to the beneficiary, the beneficiary sues in its own name rather than borrowing the promisee's claim.
That direct claim is what makes the benefit meaningful. The beneficiary can pursue performance on its own and need not wait for the promisee to take enforcement action, and that independence is the crucial requirement for giving a third-party beneficiary standing to sue.2 The point is easy to see in will cases, where the promisee is often unavailable to sue. Hale v. Groce applies the rule to a legatee who sues the lawyer hired to draft a will.
The direct claim is a nineteenth-century American development. English common law gave the beneficiary no direct action unless the beneficiary could show that the promisee acted as its agent or that the contract created a trust.3 American law moved past that limit in the mid-nineteenth century, and Lawrence v. Fox, 20 N.Y. 268 (1859), is recognized as the groundbreaking case. Holly lent Fox $300 and owed Lawrence the same sum, so Holly and Fox agreed that Fox would repay Lawrence. Fox did not pay. Lawrence sued, and Fox defended on the ground that Lawrence was no party to the contract and there was no privity between them.4
A gratuitous promise produced the same kind of suit in Seaver v. Ransom. Mrs. Beman signed a will already prepared after the Judge swore that, if she did, he would leave the niece enough in his own will "to make up the difference." Mrs. Beman signed and died. When the Judge died, he had left the niece nothing. The niece, who was no party to the Judge's promise, claimed breach and sued his estate for the value of the real estate, found to be $6,000.5
The modern vocabulary grew out of cases like these. The Restatement (Second) recognized that the terms "donee" beneficiary and "creditor" beneficiary carry overtones of obsolete doctrinal difficulties. It replaced them with "intended" and "incidental" beneficiaries, terms that distinguish beneficiaries who have rights from those who do not.6 Intended beneficiaries include creditor and donee beneficiaries along with other third parties the first Restatement did not reach.7
Intent draws the line between the two groups. The test is whether the contract manifests an "intent to benefit" the third party who claims enforceable rights.8 The inquiry centers on the promisee, whose manifested intention in obtaining the promise matters most: did the promisee mean to create enforceable rights in the third party? If so, nothing is unjust, inequitable, or unfair in requiring the promisor to perform the duty owed to the third party or answer to that party for breach.9
Compare a contract in which Debtor owes Creditor $200,000, sells a plot of land to Buyer for $200,000, and stipulates that Buyer will pay the price to Creditor. Creditor does not profit by fortuity here. The payment is the performance the contract specifically calls for, and Debtor's purpose was to send the proceeds directly to Creditor. Creditor's benefit is therefore not merely incidental but clearly contemplated and deliberately conferred, and Creditor can enforce the promise against Buyer.10 The café and Creditor both gain from a contract between others. What separates them is whether the contract was meant to reach the claimant with a right of enforcement.
Two further questions arise once a claimant clears that line. The first is whether the right still arises when the beneficiary was not identified when the contract was made. The second is whether a beneficiary who never agreed to the arrangement may refuse the right by disclaiming it. The sections below take them in that order.