Concept
The Creditor Beneficiary's Position
Creditor-beneficiary remedies
Creditor Beneficiary Remedies
The Creditor Beneficiary's Position
Debtor owes Creditor $200,000. Debtor sells a plot of land to Buyer for $200,000, and their contract stipulates that Buyer will pay the price to Creditor.1 Debtor's purpose is to send the proceeds directly to Creditor and settle the debt, so Creditor's payment is no fortuitous result of the contract; the contract specifically calls for it.2 This transaction serves as the running example for the chapter.
Creditor is a creditor beneficiary because Buyer's performance will satisfy an obligation of Debtor, the promisee, to pay money to Creditor, the beneficiary.3 That condition comes from Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 302(1)(a), and every remedy rule in this chapter depends on it. The test that separates intended from incidental beneficiaries is taught elsewhere. Here the debt is a given, and the question is what the beneficiary may do about it.
The pattern appears in Lawrence v. Fox. At Fox's request, Holly lent Fox $300, stating at the time that he owed that sum to Lawrence for money borrowed, and Fox promised to pay Lawrence the next day.4 Holly corresponds to Debtor, Fox to Buyer, and Lawrence to Creditor. Lawrence sued on Fox's promise, and the court held that a third person may maintain an action on a promise made to another for his benefit when the promise rests on consideration the debtor advanced.5 Lawrence was a creditor of Holly, the promisee, and the promise grew out of Holly's wish to provide for satisfaction of that obligation. That is why plaintiffs like Lawrence came to be called creditor beneficiaries.6
Buyer's promise leaves Creditor holding two claims. Section 310(1) applies where an intended beneficiary has an enforceable claim against the promisee, and it lets that beneficiary obtain a judgment or judgments against the promisee, the promisor, or both, based on their respective duties to the beneficiary.7 The Restatement defends the direct claim in suretyship terms. The promisee is surety for the promisor, the promise is an asset of the promisee, and a direct action by the beneficiary against the promisor is normally appropriate to carry out the intention of both contracting parties, even though no one means to give the beneficiary a gift.8 Debtor stands behind Buyer's payment, and Buyer's promise is an asset in Debtor's hands. The next sections take the two claims in turn, Creditor's claim against Buyer on the promise and Creditor's continuing claim against Debtor on the debt, and then ask what happens when Creditor sues both.
The vocabulary has changed since Lawrence, though his own position has not. The first Restatement defined the creditor-beneficiary case in § 133(1)(b) as one where the promisor's performance would satisfy an “actual or supposed or asserted duty of the promisee to the beneficiary.”9 The Second Restatement speaks instead of an intended beneficiary under § 302(1)(a), although its comment acknowledges that the type is often called a creditor beneficiary, and some courts still use the discarded expressions.10 Lawrence fits comfortably within § 302(1)(a), so for his case the revision was only a rewording.11
For other situations the revision made a substantive difference, and the differences show what the debt must look like. The duty the promisee owes the beneficiary must be a duty to pay money or its near equivalent.12 A non-money obligation can qualify when it is easily convertible into money, as with commodities or securities actively traded in organized markets; less liquid obligations are left to § 302(1)(b).13 A “supposed or asserted” duty no longer suffices, because there is no suretyship if the promisee was never under any duty to the beneficiary, and the same comment excludes the beneficiary of a promise to discharge a lien on the promisee's property or to satisfy a third person's duty.14 In the other direction, a debt barred by the statute of limitations or a bankruptcy discharge, or unenforceable under the Statute of Frauds, still counts. If B promises A to pay such a debt that A owes C, C is an intended beneficiary under § 302(1)(a).15 Because § 310(1) speaks of an enforceable claim against the promisee, the two-defendant picture in this chapter assumes a debt that Creditor can still collect.16
Owing a debt to the third party is only half of the test; the other half is that the promisor's performance will itself satisfy the debt. The Restatement's own illustration holds the debts constant and varies the promise. B promises A to pay whatever debts A may incur in a certain undertaking, and A incurs debts to C, D, and E. If the promise means that B will pay C, D, and E, they are intended beneficiaries under § 302(1)(a). If B is to pay the money to A so that A can pay them, they are at most incidental beneficiaries.17 The debts are identical under both readings, and the only fact that moves is where B's performance goes. When an exam stem mentions debts and a promise, ask whether the promisor's performance runs to the creditors or to the person who owes them.
The nephew is not shut out of court. Section 302(1)(b) reaches a beneficiary when the circumstances indicate that the promisee intends to give the beneficiary the benefit of the promised performance.18 But Owner owes the nephew nothing, so the nephew has no debt-based claim against Owner, and the missing second claim changes the remedy picture. The last section of this chapter returns to that contrast.