Concept
Assignment Defined
Assignment of rights
Assignment of Contract Rights
Assignment Defined
A painter who has promised to paint an owner's house for $25,000 may transfer the right to that payment to a bank in return for a loan. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts calls such a transfer an assignment and defines it in one sentence: an assignment of a right is a manifestation of the assignor's intention to transfer it, by virtue of which the assignor's right to performance by the obligor is extinguished in whole or in part and the assignee acquires a right to that performance.1
That sentence packs three events into one. The assignor manifests an intention to transfer, which sets the transfer in motion (the next section takes up what that manifestation requires). The assignor's own right then ends, entirely or to the extent of the part transferred. And the assignee acquires the right the assignor has given up. Because the loss on one side and the gain on the other happen together, an assignment is a true transfer: the person who held the right no longer has it.
The vocabulary for the three people involved stays fixed throughout this chapter. The party who holds the contractual right is the obligee under the contract and, on transferring it, becomes the assignor. The person who receives the right is the assignee. The other original party, who owes the performance, is the obligor.2 In the painter's transaction, the painter is the assignor, the bank is the assignee, and the owner is the obligor of the duty to pay.3 Each label describes a role with respect to one right. The painter also owes the owner a duty to paint, so the same person can assign one right while remaining bound by a separate duty.
Parties assign rights for the reasons owners dispose of any property: they sell them, give them away, or pledge them as collateral.4 A lender who advanced $10,000 repayable in six months may prefer cash now and sell the right to repayment to a finance company. The buyer will ordinarily pay less than face value, to reflect the burden of collection and the risk of default.5 A grandparent owed $1,000 by a neighbor may give the right to that payment to a grandchild, who then collects from the neighbor. A builder under a $10,000,000 contract, payable as the work progresses, may need money before work begins and so assign the right to payment to a financial institution in return for a loan. That right has not yet been earned, because it is conditioned on performance of the contract.6
In each of these transactions the obligor's position changes little. The borrower still owes repayment and the owner still owes the price of the finished house; the difference is the payee. An owner may not be pleased to pay a bank, but doing so is not a great additional burden.7 Because the assignor's right is extinguished to the extent of the transfer, the obligor owes that performance to the assignee in place of the assignor.8 Later sections qualify this picture with the limits on assignability and with the rules on notice and defenses.
Now suppose the painter, instead of transferring the payment right, hires a subcontractor to do the painting. Only the performance of the duty has been passed along. That is a delegation, and the painter remains liable to the owner if the work is shoddy.9 A duty cannot be assigned, because an obligor has no power to extinguish a duty and transfer it to someone else without the obligee's consent. The owner bargained for the painter's promise, and that promise stays in force until the duty is discharged. The contrast with the bank is exact: after the assignment the painter can no longer collect the price from the owner, but after the delegation the painter can still be held to the promise to paint. Courts sometimes speak of "assigning" a duty; that phrase is a misnomer, and it should be read as a delegation.10 Delegation gets its own treatment later. The point here is only that assignment ends the assignor's hold on a right, while delegation releases no one from a duty.
The law lets rights move this way because the owner of a contractual right can transfer it like any other property, and the law generally presumes that contract rights can be transferred unless the contract or public policy precludes it.11 Early common law took the opposite view. It treated contract rights as personal to the parties and therefore not assignable, and it also prohibited assignment because trading in rights was thought to commit maintenance, the offense of tending to spur litigation. These rules began to erode with the rise of commercial business in the seventeenth century.12 The commercial value shows up clearly in a merchant who sells on credit. The goods have left the shelves, no cash has come in, and restocking takes cash. The merchant can sell the accounts receivable or borrow against them as collateral, so assignability of contract rights serves as a lubricant to the production-distribution process.13 A duty, by contrast, is something the obligor owes rather than owns. It is not the obligor's property, so the presumption of transferability is weaker, and delegation faces greater restrictions than assignment.14