Concept
Delegating Conditions
Delegation of duties
Delegating Conditions
A person whose act is a condition of another party's duty may have someone else perform that act, and the delegate's performance satisfies the condition unless the delegation is contrary to public policy or the terms of the agreement.1 The rule rests on the difference between a duty and a condition. A duty is a promise, and its maker is liable if it is broken. A condition is an event that must occur before another party's duty to perform arises, and the person whose act supplies that event may have promised nothing. That person gains the other side's performance by acting and fails to gain it by not acting.
Delegation is allowed because a condition poses a different question from a duty. The question is whether the required event happened, not who answers for a breach. When a delegate performs the act, the party whose duty depends on it receives exactly the event the contract called for, and refusing to credit that event would let the party escape the bargain over whose hands did the work. Delegation is therefore the default, and the agreement or public policy can forbid it. A further limit applies unless the parties agree otherwise: the agreement requires performance by a particular person only to the extent that the obligor, the party whose duty the condition qualifies, has a substantial interest in having that person perform or control the acts required.2 That interest marks the point at which a substitute's act becomes a different event from the one the contract described.
An option contract shows the rule at work, because an option holder can be bound to nothing. Suppose an owner gives a buyer an option to purchase land for $10,000, payable within ten days. The buyer promises nothing, and the option is accepted by tendering the price. If the buyer's friend tenders the $10,000 within the ten days, the condition is satisfied. Payment of money is delegable,3 and the owner receives exactly what the option required: the price, on time. Who supplied it changes nothing for the owner.4
Change the price and the result changes with it. Suppose the option can be accepted only by one year of the buyer's personal services to the owner, and the buyer sends a substitute to render them. The owner may decline. A duty is non-delegable where performance by the delegate would vary materially from performance by the obligor, and the test is whether performance by the delegating party, or under that party's personal supervision, was bargained for.5 The owner bargained for the buyer's own services and so has a substantial interest in receiving them from that person.6 The buyer's personal performance would still satisfy the condition. Cash is interchangeable and services are not, and that difference decides the two cases. Because the substantial interest protects the owner, the owner may also waive it. As with an attempted delegation of a non-delegable duty, the owner accepts the substitute by dealing with it.7
Drafting can move a payment from one category to the other. Had the buyer promised to pay the price, the payment would be a duty rather than a condition, and the rules for delegating duties would govern. A duty to pay money is delegable under those rules too, although a delegation built on the delegate's own promissory note or other instrument of credit fails unless the delegate is willing and able to tender cash instead.8
A problem about delegating a condition runs through the same questions as a problem about delegating a duty. Identify the act that triggers the other party's duty. Check whether the agreement or public policy forbids delegating it. Then ask whether the other party has a substantial interest in that particular person's performance. The difference lies in the cost of failure. When the performer has promised nothing, a failed delegation breaches nothing; the condition has simply not occurred, and the other party's duty never arises.