Concept
The Adverse Party's Rights
Refreshing recollection
The Adverse Party's Rights
Rule 612 gives an adverse party certain options whenever a witness uses a writing to refresh memory, and the options exist because the writing usually stays out of the jury's sight even though it may have shaped what the jury hears.1 Only cross-examination can test whether the witness truly remembers, and cross-examination needs the writing to do the job. One authority puts it this way: "With the memorandum before her, the cross-examiner has a good opportunity to test the credibility of the witness's claim that her memory has been revived, and to search out any discrepancies between the writing and the testimony."2
The rule answers three questions, and this unit takes them in order. The first is when the options exist: a writing used on the stand triggers them as of right, while a writing used before testifying triggers them only if the court decides that justice requires it.3 The second is what the opponent may take once they exist: production at the hearing, inspection, cross-examination about the writing, and introduction of any portion that relates to the testimony, with unrelated matter screened out by the judge.4 The third is what follows when the writing is withheld: the court may enter any appropriate order, but a prosecution that fails to comply in a criminal case faces a mandatory remedy.5 In a criminal case, the entitlement described in the second question gives way where 18 U.S.C. § 3500 provides otherwise.6
Writings Used While Testifying
A writing the witness uses on the stand puts the adverse party in its strongest position, because the options arise without any decision by the court.7 The usual setting is a witness who admits on the record that she has forgotten. Counsel hands her a memorandum to inspect, and when she then speaks from a memory thus revived, her testimony is the evidence, not the writing.8 Leading questions should not be used on direct examination except as necessary to develop the witness's testimony,9 which leaves a writing as one way to prompt a forgetful witness. The opponent is entitled to see what that prompt said.
Rule 612(b) lists four entitlements, and each does separate work for the cross-examiner:10
- Production at the hearing puts the writing in the courtroom while the witness is still on the stand, when cross-examination can use it.
- Inspection lets counsel read the writing and build questions from what it says.
- Cross-examination about the writing tests the witness's claim that memory returned and searches for discrepancies between the writing and the testimony.11
- Introduction of the related portions puts the writing itself before the jury, which may weigh it against the testimony.12
The four work in sequence. Production brings the writing into the room, inspection lets counsel read it, and cross-examination turns what counsel read into questions. Two kinds of question matter most. One attacks the claim that the writing revived memory, for example by asking whether the witness can recall anything beyond what the page says. The other points to any gap between the testimony and the writing and leaves the jury to decide which is accurate. Both aim at what the jury cannot learn by watching the witness, which is whether memory actually returned.
The payroll pages stay out because the introduction right reaches only the portion that relates to the testimony.13 The limit follows from the purpose of the right. The opponent receives the writing so that the refreshed testimony can be tested, and a page of payroll entries tests nothing about it. When the producing party claims that a writing contains unrelated matter, the judge examines it privately and deletes that matter, a procedure taken up below.14 A lawyer who offers an entire report merely because a witness glanced at it therefore receives only the passages that bear on what the witness said.
The jury's use of an introduced page is limited as well. A document introduced by opposing counsel may be considered by the jury in assessing the witness's credibility, and it may serve as substantive evidence only if it is otherwise admissible, because Rule 612 creates no separate exception to the hearsay rule.15 In the supervisor's case, the time entry is received to show the jury a discrepancy, and that use works by comparison without requiring that the entry be true. If counsel instead wanted the jury to accept the entry as proof that unloading began at the earlier hour, the use would depend on the entry's truth, and the entry would need an independent route into evidence.
The party who called the witness stands differently. Had the log matched the supervisor's testimony line for line, the plaintiff would be the one eager to put it before the jury, and Rule 612 gives it no way to do so. The proponent does not get to introduce the document merely because it jogged the witness's memory.16 The log was a memory jogger, and the evidence is the supervisor's testimony from restored memory.17 Inspection of the writing, or its use on cross-examination, does not by itself make it admissible on behalf of the proponent.18 The proponent's way to the jury runs through a different rule. If refreshing fails and the record qualifies under Rule 803(5), the record may be read into evidence, but it is received as an exhibit only if the adverse party offers it, as the preceding section explained.19
Because the rule speaks of options, the adverse party also decides how many to use. A cross-examiner who inspects the writing and finds it consistent with the testimony may decline to introduce it, and the jury then never sees it.20 The usual exam error runs the other way, treating Rule 612 as if it made the writing admissible for its truth or gave the calling party a right to offer it.
Writings Used Before Testifying
A writing used before testifying reaches the adverse party only if the court decides that justice requires it.22 The options are the same four, production, inspection, cross-examination, and introduction of related portions,23 but the gate is judicial. A writing the witness read in counsel's office the week before trial does not become the opponent's to examine merely because it was read. The opponent must ask, and the judge decides whether this writing deserves the access that a writing used on the stand receives automatically.
The justice requirement was imposed to prevent time-consuming fishing expeditions at trial among the multitude of papers a witness may have used in preparing for testimony, and to avoid disclosure of information protected by a privilege.24 A writing used on the stand raises neither difficulty, because it is a particular document identified in front of the court and counsel, so nothing has to be hunted down among the rest.
The gate does not close the door on pretrial writings. Many older cases refused to enforce a demand for production at trial of matter reviewed before testifying, but a growing number had reached the contrary conclusion even before the Federal Rules, and the adoption of Rule 612 accelerated that trend.25 The rule reflects a judgment that other means, notably discovery, give parties access to pertinent materials in the adversary's hands, so it suffices to leave to the judge the question whether the opponent may have a writing used as a memory aid before trial.26 The result is a middle position. No absolute right exists to compel production of such a writing, and no writing is invariably shielded from disclosure.
The Advisory Committee's Note supplies the touchstone: access should be granted "only to those writings which may fairly be said in fact to have an impact upon the testimony of the witness."27 That focus tracks the reason an opponent wants the writing at all, since cross-examination can test whether the testimony follows the page only if the page shaped the testimony. The discovery premise also carries less weight in criminal cases, where pretrial discovery is limited, and that counsels the judge toward allowing the adversary to inspect.28 The usual exam question asks whether the opponent can demand what a witness read to prepare, and the answer turns on what the record shows that reading did and on whether the opponent had another route to the document.
Two facts moved the answer between those scenes: whether the record links an identified document to the testimony, and whether the opponent had another way to reach the document. In the civil scene both point away from production, and a demand for an entire box is the fishing expedition the justice requirement was meant to prevent.29 In the criminal scene both point toward production, and an order for it opens the Rule 612(b) options to the defense.30 Such an order changes only what the opponent may do, because neither inspection of the writing nor its use on cross-examination by itself makes the document admissible on behalf of the party who called the witness.31
Preparation materials sometimes include something privileged, such as a letter from a client-witness to the client's lawyer about the case, or a lawyer's work product, meaning materials prepared in anticipation of litigation. The justice requirement then collides with the protection those doctrines give. The House Judiciary Committee's report states an intention that nothing in Rule 612 bar an assertion of privilege, usually lawyer-client, for a writing referred to before or at trial, yet support exists for the proposition that using a privileged writing to refresh recollection waives the privilege.32 Finding waiver is easy when the witness consults the writing on the stand, because it would be patently unfair for a witness to consult a writing in open court and refuse the opposing counsel a look.33 The pretrial case is harder, since the review happened outside the courtroom. The privilege at stake is ordinarily either the absolute attorney-client privilege or the qualified protection for work product.34
The courts have divided over that harder case into three groups:
- Some courts order production whenever a privileged writing was reviewed before testifying.
- Others require production only if the privilege has been waived, as by disclosure to outsiders, and find no waiver when a client merely reviews his own statements.
- A third group asks whether the reviewed writing had an impact on the testimony.35
Early federal cases leaned toward overriding privilege when the witness consulted a passage before trial for the precise purpose of reviving memory. More recent decisions override it only when the record shows that the writing actually refreshed memory and affected the testimony, a position that fits best with the Advisory Committee's focus on impact.36 A district court in James Julian, Inc. v. Raytheon Co. required production of a binder prepared by counsel for corporate officers to review before deposition testimony and found that work product protection had been waived.37 One authority observes that it is not at all clear that Congress intended Rule 612 to authorize judges to override protections otherwise afforded by privilege or the work product doctrine.38
The same letter consulted on the stand would present no contest, since waiver is obviously warranted there.39 When a claim of privilege succeeds in blocking access, the court may make any order justice requires, and where the claim is made known in advance, one obvious solution is to forbid the witness to refresh from the writing at all.40 A lawyer who prepares a witness with a privileged document therefore risks either disclosure or the loss of that document as a reminder, and because the law is unsettled, the outcome depends on which approach the court follows.
The Supreme Court has noticed the rule without applying it. In a footnote to United States v. Nobles, the Court observed that new Rule 612 entitles an adverse party to inspect a writing relied on to refresh memory while testifying and authorizes disclosure of writings relied on before testifying if the court deems it necessary in the interests of justice, but it declined to consider the rule because the Federal Rules of Evidence were not in effect at the respondent's trial.{{cite:56e45009-9ae6-46d1-ae9a-5918ff9383}} The footnote helps explain how the rule is built and says nothing about how the justice standard should be applied. How the court screens an ordered writing for matter unrelated to the testimony, and what follows when the writing is withheld, are taken up in the next two subsections.
Unrelated Matter and In Camera Review
Rule 612(b) adds a screening step to the adverse party's right to receive the writing. If the producing party claims that the writing includes unrelated matter, the court must examine it in camera, delete any unrelated portion, and order that the rest be delivered to the adverse party, and any portion deleted over objection must be preserved for the record.42 Examining a writing in camera means that the judge reads it privately, so the court sees everything while the opponent sees only what survives. The step applies to a writing reviewed on the witness stand and to a pretrial writing that the court has decided, in the interests of justice, should be disclosed.43 It exists because unrelated matter falls outside what the opponent may receive, the same limit that governs which portions the opponent may introduce.44 A memo that mixes the facts the witness recalled with pages about some other matter therefore cannot cross the courtroom in full, since the other pages give cross-examination nothing to test.
The rule gives the decision to the judge, and the reason lies in who would otherwise make it. The party holding the writing has a stake in how much of it the opponent reads, and the passage most worth hiding is often the one that contradicts the testimony, which is also the passage a party might be tempted to call irrelevant. The opponent cannot answer that label, because the opponent has not seen the page. A neutral reader removes the difficulty: the judge reads the whole writing, compares it with what the witness said, and rules on each portion. The last sentence of the rule completes the design. A deleted portion kept in the record lets an appellate court read what was cut and decide whether the deletion was proper, whereas a record without it would leave the ruling beyond review.
Paragraph five shows why the producing party's label does not control. The opponent's access is measured by whether a portion relates to the testimony, and the court decides that by reading the writing, even when the producing party has already pronounced the portion unrelated. The usual exam error is to assume that a party may black out whatever it considers irrelevant before handing over a refreshing writing. The rule requires a ruling by the court, made in camera, and it requires that anything deleted over objection remain available for review. What follows when a writing is not delivered as ordered is taken up next.
Failure to Produce the Writing
Rule 612(c) supplies the consequence that gives the adverse party's rights their force. If a writing is not produced or is not delivered as ordered, the court may issue any appropriate order, but if the prosecution does not comply in a criminal case, the court must strike the witness's testimony or, if justice so requires, declare a mistrial.48 The two failures the rule names track the steps described above. The writing may never be produced at the hearing when the opponent calls for it, or it may be ordered delivered after the court's in camera screening and then withheld. The rule therefore has a general clause and an exception, and the exception removes the judge's discretion in exactly one setting.
The reason for attaching a consequence at all lies in who controls the writing. The party that called the witness chose the memory aid and gets the benefit of testimony the aid may have shaped, while only the opponent can test whether that testimony reflects genuine memory, and cross-examination cannot do that work without the writing. If the calling party could keep the writing back at no cost, it would collect the benefit of the refreshed testimony and deny the opponent the one tool for examining the testimony's source. The rule closes the gap by aiming the remedy at the testimony the writing helped produce, so that a party who withholds the writing risks losing the very testimony the withholding was meant to protect.
In a civil case, and in any case where the noncomplying party is not the prosecution, the court has an open-ended choice. The treatise's account of the rule lists examples of what an order may include: striking the testimony, contempt, dismissal, or findings against the offender.49 Those examples show the range without confining it, and the breadth fits the variety of failures a court may meet, since a document misfiled and found the next morning calls for a different response than a flat refusal to obey a delivery order.
The criminal exception works differently because it fixes the outcome. When the prosecution does not comply, the court must strike the witness's testimony, and the only alternative to striking is a mistrial if justice so requires.50 Striking is the baseline, and the rule leaves the choice of a mistrial to the judge. What the judge cannot do is choose a lesser order that leaves the testimony standing.
The fixed remedy likely reflects the defendant's position. As the discussion of pretrial writings noted, discovery in a criminal case is limited,51 so the writing may be the defense's only way to test the witness's claim of restored memory, and an order that left the testimony in place could leave the defendant facing testimony that cannot be tested. The prosecution therefore faces a plain choice between delivering the writing and losing the testimony.
The exception runs in one direction only. Its text applies when the prosecution fails to comply, so a criminal defendant whose witness refreshed from a writing that the defense then withholds is governed by the general clause, and the court may issue any appropriate order without being bound to strike. A civil litigant likewise has no automatic striking to fear, although striking remains one of the orders available. The usual exam error is to apply the mandatory remedy to every noncompliant party in a criminal trial, or to treat any civil failure as automatically costing the witness's testimony.