Concept
Opportunity to Be Heard
Judicial notice
Opportunity to Be Heard
Judicial notice can settle a fact before the jury ever weighs it. In a civil case, the court must instruct the jury to accept the noticed fact as conclusive; in a criminal case, it instructs that the jury may or may not accept the fact as conclusive.1 Because notice may completely or partially foreclose the jury's decision on an issue, the party who stands to lose that decision needs a chance to argue against it.2 Rule 201(e) supplies that chance in two sentences.
The first sentence states the right: on timely request, a party is entitled to be heard on the propriety of taking judicial notice and on the nature of the fact to be noticed. The second reaches a court that moved first: if the court takes judicial notice before notifying a party, the party, on request, is still entitled to be heard.3 The hearing thus covers two questions. Propriety asks whether the fact qualifies for notice at all. The nature of the fact asks what, exactly, the court proposes to treat as established.
Notice has work to do only for facts the parties will not stipulate and that are not common knowledge the jury can be assumed to share.4 Those are the facts an opponent has reason to contest, and the contest follows the indisputability standard. The opponent argues that the fact is neither generally known within the trial court's territorial jurisdiction nor capable of accurate and ready determination from sources whose accuracy cannot reasonably be questioned.5 The argument goes to the judge. Evidence that would otherwise be offered to persuade the jury about the issue is presented to the judge instead, in an effort to keep the question one for the jury and to prevent the judge from deciding it personally.6
Rule 201(e) promises a hearing on request and promises no advance warning. The rule does not require a party to notify an adversary that it is asking the court to take notice; it entitles the adversary, on timely request, to be heard.7 A party's request itself tells the opponent what is coming, so an opponent can be caught unaware only when the court acts on its own motion. Even then, a trial judge may need to consider notifying the parties only when she intends to notice a fact that is less than obviously true.8
The second sentence of the rule keeps the safeguard alive when the court moves first. If the judge takes notice without giving the opponent a chance to be heard, the opponent should receive that chance afterward, and the court should withdraw the instruction if the objections persuade it.9 A late hearing is therefore not an empty gesture, because its remedy is withdrawal of the instruction. Notice may be taken at any stage of a proceeding, including on appeal.10
The hearing right has constitutional roots. Affording a litigant an opportunity to be heard on the propriety of judicial notice is consistent with important constitutional guarantees.11 In Ohio Bell Telephone v. Public Utilities Commission, the Supreme Court held that taking judicial notice without giving the parties an opportunity to be heard violates due process. The case arose on review of an administrative determination, but the principle it announced is the one the rule's hearing right honors at trial.12
The two hypotheticals turn on one fact: what the party did after the court acted. The defendant in the first asked to be heard and won; the plaintiff in the second asked for nothing. The rule's word timely carries weight here, because the entitlement arises on request, and a party who says nothing has made none.
The hearing right belongs to adjudicative facts. For legislative facts, the background about the setting in which a legal rule will operate, the governing standard is very likely one of probability rather than indisputability.13 The parties usually have their say through arguments over the governing law, exchanged briefs, and Brandeis briefs, so no one has felt a need to formalize a hearing procedure. Gaps remain: an appellate opinion sometimes rests on legislative facts that first appear in the decision itself, and counsel never get to respond. Practice relies on judges' sense of elementary fairness to guard against that result.14