Concept
Why Presumptions Exist
Effect of civil presumptions (Rule 301)
Why Presumptions Exist
Unless a federal statute or another rule provides otherwise, Rule 301 gives every civil presumption the same procedural effect: the party against whom the presumption is directed must produce evidence to rebut it, and the burden of persuasion stays with the party who had it originally.1 That one rule governs dozens of presumptions, and it does not say why any of them exists.2 Courts also disagree on labels, so a device one jurisdiction calls a presumption another may call an inference.
The reason behind a presumption matters. It tells you how strong the presumption's claim to special treatment is, and it explains why lawmakers sometimes want a presumption to do more than Rule 301 allows. Three justifications account for most presumptions. Some rest on probability: proof of the basic fact makes the presumed fact likely enough to rely on. Some advance a policy, such as settling estates, protecting survivors, or recovering damages after accidents. Some offset one party's superior knowledge or easier access to the evidence.3 The categories overlap. Each entry on the standard sample list carries some probative force, and several also reflect access or policy, so the useful question is which consideration does the most work. Because many presumptions have at least some public policy underpinnings, that question is not always easy to answer.4 The three subsections below take the justifications in turn.
Probability-Based Presumptions
A presumption rests on probability when proof of the basic fact makes the presumed fact likely enough that the proponent may rely on it until the opponent answers. Every entry on the standard sample list carries some probative force of this kind, though most also rest on other considerations.5 The mailed letter is the best model. Proof that a letter was regularly addressed and mailed supports the presumption that the addressee received it.6 Even this presumption appears among the entries where easier access to evidence also matters, but likelihood does most of the work.
Experience supplies the link, because properly mailed letters ordinarily arrive. If the law demanded proof of delivery, every sender would have to prove a fact that is almost always true, just to guard against the rare letter that goes astray. The presumption lets the sender prove the cheap, available fact of mailing. It leaves the addressee, who alone claims that this letter was the exception, to come forward with evidence that it never arrived. Under Rule 301 that burden is one of production only, so a sender who needs receipt still carries the burden of persuading the jury.7
The bailment presumption marks the edge of the category. When goods are delivered to a bailee in good condition and come back damaged, the bailee is presumed negligent.8 Damage on return proves little about carelessness by itself, since goods break and spoil without anyone's fault. The presumption works because the bailee had custody and knows what happened, while the bailor does not. Superior access, not likelihood, carries that presumption, and the access-based subsection below takes it up.
When an exam stem presents a presumption, ask what ordinary experience says about the basic fact. If experience says the presumed fact usually follows, the presumption is probability-based. Whether that likelihood keeps any force after the presumption is rebutted is a question for the later section on the residual inference.
Policy-Based Presumptions
Some presumptions exist because lawmakers want a particular result, whatever the odds in the individual case. A presumption of this kind is policy-based: it favors one side because a social or economic goal calls for it. The clearest example is the presumption that a child born during a marriage is the husband's child. A forceful policy favoring the legitimacy of children, joined with strong probability, gives this presumption special strength.11 The presumption once had considerable importance but has diminished with the use of DNA evidence, which can answer paternity directly.12
Other policies also drive presumptions. The source ties policies favoring the settlement of estates, the protection of survivors, and the recovery of damages in cases of accident to particular entries on its sample list.13 Policy and probability usually travel together, and the mailed letter is the contrast case: its presumption rests mainly on experience with the mails, and no social goal asks the law to favor senders over addressees as such. Classification therefore turns on a practical question: does a purpose beyond likelihood help explain why the law creates the presumption?14
Policy-based presumptions are the ones most often argued to deserve more force than Rule 301 gives them. The argument for reassigning the burden of persuasion, rejecting Thayer's view, grows stronger when either probative force or policy appears quite strong.15 In securities cases, for example, the Supreme Court has held that the presumption of investor reliance on a fraud on the market shifts to the defendant the burden of showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the plaintiffs did not actually rely.16 Rule 301 leaves room for such departures, because it applies only unless a federal statute or the rules provide otherwise,17 and Congress may enact a presumption and specify its effect.18 Because the procedural effect of a presumption may vary with its source, check the source of each presumption rather than assuming the ordinary effect.19
Access-Based Presumptions
A third group of presumptions exists to counteract one party's superior access to the proof. The source lists superior knowledge or easier access to the evidence as operative for five of its eight sample presumptions, including the mailed letter, the damaged bailment, and the last carrier of goods damaged in transit.22 Each pairs basic facts the proponent can prove with a presumed fact about events that the opponent is far better placed to explain.
The reason follows from how proof works. When the evidence sits in someone else's hands, that person's silence can defeat a proponent who was not there. A presumption cures the problem by letting the proponent prove only the circumstances pointing toward responsibility, which are the basic facts, and then requiring the holder of the information to come forward. A burden of production fits that gap closely. The holder discharges it by telling what it knows, and because the proponent keeps the burden of persuasion, nobody loses merely because the other side was better positioned.23
The bailment presumption shows the pattern. A bailee, such as a mover, a repair shop, or a warehouse, takes temporary custody of another's property. When goods are delivered to a bailee in good condition and come back damaged, the bailee is presumed negligent.24 The basic facts show that the goods were in the bailee's keeping when the harm occurred, so the bailee alone can say how they were handled.
The last-carrier presumption applies the same logic to a chain of handlers. When goods are damaged during transit provided by more than one carrier, the last carrier is presumed to have caused the damage.25 The shipper sees the goods only at the start and at the end and cannot tell on which leg the damage occurred. Each carrier can account for the period the goods were in its hands, and the last carrier can answer with evidence that the goods were already damaged when they reached it. The presumption directs the burden of speaking to the party who can supply the answer most cheaply.
Superior access explains why a presumption exists, but it does not create one. Rule 301 neither defines nor lists presumptions, so each must come from a case, a statute, or another rule.26 An exam stem in which the defendant knows more than the plaintiff therefore raises a further question: does a recognized presumption attach to the basic facts actually proved?
Custody at the moment of harm separates the cases. In the bailment and carrier examples, the basic facts themselves put the goods in the defendant's keeping when the damage occurred, which makes the defendant the person best placed to explain it. Ownership of a building puts no one in that position, because many people may have used the stairs and the owner has no better view of the fall than anyone else. Even where an access-based presumption applies, Rule 301 asks the opponent only to come forward with evidence. What that evidence does to the presumption is the subject of the later sections on how the bubble operates.