Concept
Production and Persuasion Burdens
Effect of civil presumptions (Rule 301)
Production and Persuasion Burdens
Rule 301 speaks in terms of two burdens, and a presumption touches only one of them. In a civil case, unless a federal statute or another rule provides otherwise, the party against whom a presumption is directed must produce evidence to rebut it; the presumption does not shift the burden of persuasion, which remains on the party who had it originally.1 The rule cannot be applied until the two burdens can be told apart.
The everyday phrase “burden of proof” hides the difference, because it covers both the burden of persuasion and the burden of production.2 A lawyer who says the plaintiff has the burden of proof on negligence may mean that the plaintiff must bring forward some evidence of negligence or lose without the jury ever deciding the issue. The same lawyer may mean that the plaintiff must convince the factfinder and loses if it stays unconvinced. A party can satisfy the first obligation and still lose on the second, so the discussion below uses the two precise terms and drops the ambiguous one. The payoff is practical: the party against whom a presumption is directed bears the burden of production, and in the federal system and most states the presumption has no effect on the burden of persuasion. That is the most frequently tested aspect of burden of proof and presumptions.3
The two burdens answer different questions. Production asks whether an issue reaches the factfinder at all; persuasion asks how the factfinder must resolve an issue that does reach it. Rule 301 moves only the first. Production comes first below, because it is the burden the rule places on the opponent of a presumption, and persuasion follows, because it is the burden the rule leaves alone.
Burden of Production
The burden of production is the responsibility to bring forward evidence on an issue, and a party who carries it must bring forth enough evidence or risk losing automatically.4 At every moment of a trial only one party holds that responsibility. The court looks to that party when asked to end the case early, by dismissal, summary judgment, directed verdict, or a similar motion, and it asks whether the party has offered enough evidence to let the case continue.5 A party who bears the burden on an element and offers nothing on it leaves the jury nothing to weigh, so the opponent is entitled to a directed verdict (judgment as a matter of law).6 The party who must persuade the factfinder on an element ordinarily carries the burden of producing evidence on it too.7
The two elements differ in one respect: whether any evidence supports each. Producing evidence on acceptance earned that element a place before the jury, and nothing more. Meeting the burden of production means only that the jury may consider whether the party carried its burden of persuasion; it does not shift the burden of persuasion to the opponent.8 The seller therefore faces a jury question on acceptance although it offered no response. An opponent's silence is not a concession. It costs the opponent only when the proponent's proof is so strong that a jury could reach a single conclusion.
The burden of production can also move during a trial. A party whose evidence is so compelling that, unanswered, a jury could find only for that party has shifted the burden of production to the opponent, who must now produce meaningful evidence or risk a directed verdict. If the opponent produces it, the issue reaches the jury.9
The burden of production also supplies the logic of a presumption under Rule 301. Proof of the basic fact has the same practical effect as overwhelming evidence on the presumed fact: the opponent must come forward or lose the point. In the mailed-letter example, once the sender produces evidence adequate to support a finding that the letter was properly mailed, the judge instructs the jury to find that the letter arrived unless the addressee presents evidence of non-receipt.10 That shift reaches only the duty to produce evidence. Who must ultimately persuade the factfinder is the subject of the next subsection.
Burden of Persuasion
The burden of persuasion, sometimes called the risk of non-persuasion, decides who loses when the factfinder cannot be brought to a conclusion. A party who bears it loses the issue unless the factfinder is persuaded that the proposition has been established by a preponderance of the evidence or another applicable standard.12 Production asks whether an issue reaches the jury; persuasion governs how the jury must resolve an issue that does.
The burden matters most when the evidence is evenly balanced: the jury is instructed that in that event it must decide against the party who bore the burden of persuasion.13 The tie rule operates only when the party with the burden has produced enough for the issue to reach the jury. A party who bears the burden of persuasion and produces no evidence that could support a verdict loses by directed verdict instead.14
The mailed letter shows the rule at work. A sender who must establish receipt carries the burden of persuasion on receipt, so if the jury finds the evidence of receipt exactly balanced, the sender loses on that point. The presumption of receipt does not rescue the sender. It moved only the duty to produce evidence to the addressee,15 and once the addressee produces evidence of non-receipt, the sender is left with the original task of persuading the jury that the letter arrived.
Substantive law decides which party carries the burden of persuasion on each element, and the reasons behind particular allocations vary. Fairness may suggest placing the burden of an element on the party who controls the evidence, and probabilities may be estimated, with the burden placed on the party who will benefit from a departure from the supposed norm.16 Payment illustrates the first reason: it has long been regarded as an affirmative defense, and Rule 8(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lists it as one.17 Rule 301 leaves whichever allocation applies undisturbed.
Unlike the burden of production, the burden of persuasion does not move when a party produces evidence. In the widget dispute from the last subsection, the buyer's witness meets the burden of production on acceptance, yet the jury remains free to disbelieve the witness. The burden of persuasion does not pass to the seller, so even a seller who offers no evidence leaves the jury to decide whether the buyer has persuaded it by a preponderance of the evidence.18 Production is a threshold that one credible witness can cross; persuasion concerns the weight the jury gives all the proof.
The same logic governs the party against whom a presumption is directed. That party must produce evidence to rebut the presumption, and unless a federal statute provides otherwise, the presumption has no effect on the burden of persuasion; only the burden of producing evidence is affected.19 When a problem says a presumption is directed against a defendant, the defendant must come forward with evidence. The usual error is to treat the defendant as obliged to convince the jury of the opposite fact. Federal statutes that alter this default appear in the section on where Rule 301 yields. Without such a statute, the party who had to persuade the factfinder before the presumption arose must still persuade it afterward.