Concept
Erie and Presumptions
State law governing the effect of a presumption (Rule 302)
Erie and Presumptions
A federal court that tries a state-law claim must decide what a presumption does to the proof, and Federal Rule of Evidence 302 hands that decision to the state. In a civil case, “state law governs the effect of a presumption regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.”1 The sentence packs four conditions into one line, and all four must hold before state law displaces the federal default described above.
Burdens explain why the rule exists. Courts normally act only when parties ask them to and “prove their case,” so a litigant who fails to carry a burden loses, yet the subject of burdens is among the slipperiest in procedure and evidence.2 A presumption operates on those burdens, and the outcome of a case may turn on which party carries the burden of persuasion. Where little evidence exists on an issue, the burden of producing evidence may control the result instead.3 Recognizing these stakes, federal courts applying Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins have consistently held that when an issue is decided under state law, state law controls both the burdens of proof and the presumptions on that issue.4 Rule 302 follows the Erie doctrine in the same way.5
The Supreme Court stated the principle compactly in Dick v. New York Life Insurance Co.: “Under the Erie rule presumptions (and their effects) and burden of proof are ‘substantive.’” Uniroyal, Inc. v. Home Insurance Co., New York is one federal decision that cites Dick for that proposition.6 Another court, agreeing with Pilot Life, found it difficult to conceive of a “presumption” more substantive in nature, in terms of affecting the substantive claim or defense, than the presumption against suicide.7
The alternative shows why. A state that creates a cause of action also decides how to resolve doubt about its elements, and a presumption with burden-shifting force records a judgment that the opponent should bear the risk when the evidence is balanced. If a federal court replaced that judgment with the bursting bubble of Rule 301, the same claim on the same evidence could be won in the state courthouse and lost in the federal one. Litigants would then pick a forum for the treatment their presumption received. Rule 302 removes that incentive by letting the state’s allocation of risk travel with the claim.
Rule 302 is a deference rule, and it contains no theory of presumptions of its own. It does not say whether a presumption shifts the burden of persuasion or only the burden of producing evidence. It says whose law answers that question. If state law follows the Morgan-McCormick view, under which a presumption shifts the burden of persuasion, a federal court will apply that view in a diversity action, even though Rule 301 most likely adopts the bursting-bubble theory for federal claims.8
The deference stops at the element line. Rule 302 defers to state law only as to presumed facts that constitute an element of a claim or defense. Presumptions of lesser impact stay under the Thayer, or bursting-bubble, approach of Rule 301, even in a diversity case in which state law otherwise applies.9 These lesser presumptions, which operate as to a lesser aspect of the case, are sometimes called “tactical presumptions,” and the federal rule governs them.10
Four yeses send the judge to state law, and Rule 301 steps aside. A single no leaves the federal default in place. Later sections of this chapter take up each question, and the two hypotheticals below show the first three answers and the last one at work.
A fact pattern that pairs a basic fact with rebuttal evidence usually tests one thing, the source of the rule of decision. Change that source and the result flips.
Identical proof produces opposite results because the source of the rule of decision differs. Rule 302 does not tell the court what a presumption does. It tells the court where to look, so the first task on a problem like this is to identify whose law governs the claim, and the second is to apply that law’s treatment of the presumption.