Concept
Which State's Law
State law governing the effect of a presumption (Rule 302)
Which State's Law
Rule 302 tells a federal court to give a presumption the effect that state law gives it, and the rule's text names no state.1 That silence causes no trouble when every contact in the lawsuit lies in one state, because only one body of state law could be meant. Many civil cases are less tidy. A contract may be made in one state, an injury suffered in a second, the parties domiciled in a third, and the federal courthouse located in a fourth. When those states treat the same presumption differently, the command to apply state law leaves a gap, and the court must fill it before the presumption can do any work.
The gap opens only after the conditions covered earlier in this chapter are met: the case is civil, and state law supplies the rule of decision for the claim or defense. Two questions then close it, and each is answered from a different place. The first asks how the federal court selects among the states whose law could apply. The second asks whether the forum classifies the presumption rule as substantive or procedural, a classification that can decide which state's law reaches the presumption. Keeping the two apart shows which step produced the answer.
Forum Choice-of-Law Rules
Rule 302 answers the Erie question and leaves a second question open. It answers that state law, not federal law, controls what a presumption does on a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.2 It does not say which state's law, and that question survives even after a federal court has resolved to apply state law instead of federal law.3 Choice of law, the set of rules a court uses to decide which jurisdiction's law governs a dispute that touches more than one place, supplies the answer, and Rule 302 contains none of it.
The forum's own rules supply it. Under Klaxon Co. v. Stentor Co., a federal court must apply the conflict-of-laws rules of the state in which it sits.4 The judge therefore asks how the forum state's courts would resolve the choice-of-law question and follows that resolution. The reasoning carries over from Erie: a federal court hearing a state-law claim should not choose among states by a method different from the one the forum's own courts would use, or the choice of courthouse could change which presumption the jury hears about. Rule 302 supplies the command to apply state law, and the forum's rules identify the state.
Melville v. American Home Assurance Co. teaches the point because the court took the shortcut and then withdrew it. The court sat in Pennsylvania and faced a claim on a New York insurance contract, and the question was whether New York's presumption against suicide controlled.5 In a pretrial bench opinion, relying largely on Pilot Life Insurance Co. v. Boone, the court concluded that Rule 302 referred it to the law of the state whose law supplied the rule of decision, which was New York.6 Pilot Life had reversed a district court that applied forum law “qua forum law” to the presumption against suicide, and it had classified the presumption as substantive contract law because the presumption is inseparably connected with the right to defend.7
On reflection, the court saw that this reading asked Rule 302 to do a job it cannot do. The rule cannot create a federal choice-of-law rule at odds with the state choice-of-law rules that Erie and Klaxon make controlling.8 The pretrial opinion had treated Rule 302 as pointing to New York before asking what Pennsylvania's courts would do. The court reexamined Palmer v. Hoffman as well and found no federal rule of choice of law there.9
The court kept its result and discarded its reasoning.10 It reached New York's rule by the route Klaxon requires, predicting how Pennsylvania's courts would classify and apply it. The court concluded that Pennsylvania would treat the New York rule as one meant to create or affect substantive rights of insurers and insureds, and would treat the presumption as substantive.11 Melville is one district court's prediction of Pennsylvania law in a single case. It illustrates a method and reports no state's general law of presumptions. The next subsection takes up how a forum makes the classification.
A judge who reasoned that Alpha's law governs merely because Alpha's law created the policy would repeat the shortcut that Melville withdrew.
The same gap opens under the competency rule, which has the same structure as Rule 302: in a civil case, state law governs the witness's competency regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.12 In Turbyfill v. International Harvester Co., a federal court in Michigan had to choose between Michigan and Missouri law on a competency question.13 The court applied Klaxon and asked what Michigan's conflicts rules required. Michigan applies its own law to procedural questions, including the admissibility of evidence, even when another jurisdiction's substantive law supplies the rule of decision.14 Turbyfill is not a presumption case. It shows that a forum's conflicts rules can route a state-law question back to forum law, and that possibility matters because state courts generally treat burdens and presumptions as procedural.15
Substance Versus Procedure
Selecting a state is often not the last step. A forum asked to apply another state's rule about burdens or presumptions usually classifies that rule first, as substantive or procedural. A rule classified as substantive goes with the law of the state that otherwise governs the claim, and a rule classified as procedural stays with the forum. The classification can therefore decide whose presumption the jurors hear about.17
State courts generally call burdens of proof and presumptions procedural, so the law of the forum governs rather than the law of the state whose substantive rules otherwise apply.18 That pattern departs from the Erie analysis earlier in this chapter. Federal courts applying Erie ask how burdens and presumptions affect the outcome, and state courts deciding conflicts questions generally have not treated that effect as controlling.19
The Restatement (Second) of Conflict of Laws explains the pattern by what these rules are for. A rule of general application dealing with the burden of persuasion is almost certainly concerned primarily with trial administration, and the forum will not apply the other state's version of such a rule.20 A rule of that kind attaches to no particular right, so a forum that applies its own version overrides no judgment about the right at stake.
The exception matters as much as the rule, because decisions applying it are perhaps as numerous as decisions applying the general rule.21 Courts have phrased the exception in different ways, but its gist is that the forum applies the other state's burden or presumption rule when that rule is inseparably connected to the substantive right the other state created.22 The Restatement states the exception in terms of purpose. Forum law governs the burden of proof and the effect of presumptions unless the primary purpose of the relevant rule of the state of the otherwise applicable law is to affect the decision of the issue.23 Its comment sorts the two kinds of rule. A rule that singles out a relatively narrow issue from the general norm and gives it peculiar treatment may have been designed primarily to affect the decision of that issue, and a rule of that sort will usually appear in a statute, though it need not.24 A state that writes special treatment for one issue has made a judgment about that issue, and a forum that replaced the rule would override the judgment.
Melville applied the exception. What the parties contested sharply was the effect of the presumption against suicide on the plaintiff's burdens, and Pennsylvania and New York law diverged dramatically on the point.25 Following Pennsylvania's choice-of-law approach, the court predicted that Pennsylvania would treat the presumption as substantive.26 It gave two reasons. The presumption against suicide appears generally designed to affect the decision of the issue, a point that the case itself illustrated dramatically, and it singles out a relatively narrow issue from the general norm.27
The absence of a matching Pennsylvania rule did not matter. A forum with no substantive law on an issue, facing a sister state that has some, stands where every conflicts case stands: it must decide under its choice-of-law principles whether to apply the sister state's rule.28 The court still found a limited use for Rule 302, as an aid to classification and not as an interstate choice-of-law rule.29 Melville remains one court's prediction of one state's law. It shows how classification is done and does not report what any state's courts actually hold.
The materials describe a general pattern with a substantial exception, not a uniform national rule. The forum's own decisions control the classification, so a student who assumes that every presumption follows the claim's state, or that every presumption follows the forum, will misplace one of the two categories. A short sequence keeps the sorting honest once Rule 302's conditions are met.