Concept
Rule 302 in Context
State law governing the effect of a presumption (Rule 302)
Rule 302 in Context
Rule 302 reads like a freestanding command, but it is one of three exceptions to a single default. In a civil case, state law governs the effect of a presumption regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.1 The sentence says nothing about the evidence questions it does not reach, and those are nearly all of them. The Federal Rules of Evidence generally apply whether federal or state law supplies the rule of decision, and in diversity cases they give way to state evidence rules only in limited areas: presumptions, privileges, and the competency of witnesses.2
Two questions follow. Why does a federal court keep its own evidence rules when state law governs the claim, and how does it treat a state rule that looks like evidence law but may carry substance? And what do the other two exceptions share with Rule 302? The opening subsection takes the first question and the closing subsection the second. Because the three rules use nearly identical trigger language, one analysis serves all of them.
Federal Rules Remain Default
In a federal diversity action, state law governs substantive issues and federal law governs procedural issues. Rules of evidence count as procedural, so the Federal Rules of Evidence, not state evidence law, apply in federal diversity proceedings.3 The Rules confirm the point about themselves: they "apply generally to civil actions and proceedings."4 Legg v. Chopra drew the practical consequence, noting that the admissibility of expert testimony is a matter of federal, rather than state, procedure.5
A federal court keeps its own evidence rules because of what evidence rules are for. A pure rule of evidence, like a pure rule of procedure, concerns only accuracy and economy in litigation, so it should be tailored to the capacities and circumstances of the particular judicial system, here the federal one.6 A substantive rule concerns the channeling of behavior outside the courtroom, and where state law regulates that behavior, state law should govern even though the case sits in federal court.7 The question for any state rule is therefore which of the two it is.
The exceptions are few and listed. Even in diversity cases, federal courts apply the federal rules of evidence rather than state rules, save with respect to presumptions, privilege, and the competency of witnesses, which Rules 302, 501, and 601 govern.8 Presumptions work on the burden of proof, and the burden decides who loses. Courts act only when parties ask them to and "prove their case," so litigants carry burdens or lose if they fail, and burdens are among the slipperiest subjects in procedure and evidence.9 Rule 302 leaves the effect of a presumption on that burden to the state that wrote the claim.
Everything outside the list stays federal. A state rule that is only a rule of evidence is inapplicable in a diversity case, because the federal rules of evidence apply in its place.10 The label "evidence rule" does not settle the matter, though, because some state evidentiary rules have substantive aspects that defy the substance-procedure distinction and create a potential Erie conflict. The parol evidence rule is the familiar example: it relates to trial procedure and is nonetheless substantive in nature.11 Many rules mix evidentiary or procedural with substantive policy concerns, and the "mend the hold" doctrine is another.12 A court cannot sort a state rule by the heading it carries. It has to ask what the rule is designed to do.
Barron v. Ford Motor Co. of Canada Ltd. applied that inquiry to a North Carolina rule against admitting testimony that a person failed to wear a seatbelt. The court began with the default. The federal rules of evidence apply even in diversity cases, none of the three exceptions was involved, and a North Carolina rule that was only a rule of evidence would be inapplicable, since federal evidence law has no counterpart.13 It then asked whether the rule was a rule of evidence for Erie purposes or a substantive rule binding in a diversity case, or in any other case in which state law supplies the rule of decision.14 The answer turned on purpose. The rule is evidentiary if it is motivated by concern that jurors attach too much weight to a plaintiff's failure to wear a seatbelt, and substantive if it is designed not to penalize persons who fail to fasten their belts.15
The court resolved the question in favor of the state's substantive judgment. As a matter of North Carolina substantive law, evidence that the plaintiff had failed to fasten his seatbelt is irrelevant to show that his damages should be cut down as a penalty for unreasonable behavior, and irrelevant evidence is inadmissible under the federal rules.16 The court presumed that seatbelt use is more common now than it was in the 1960s, but North Carolina's courts had not reexamined their rule, and the federal court applied it as it stood.17 The federal rules stayed in charge throughout, with Rule 402 supplying the ground of exclusion. North Carolina supplied only the judgment about which conduct counts as unreasonable. A state rule that looks like evidence law enters a federal diversity trial by this route when it states substantive law.
An exam stem that attaches a state rule to a federal diversity trial is asking which law controls, and the answer comes from what the state rule does.
In the first scene the state rule manages proof and nothing more, so the federal default holds. In the second the state has reached one of the three places where the Rules themselves defer to it. Barron sits between the two scenes: a rule dressed as evidence law turned out to express a substantive judgment, and the court had to read the rule's purpose to find out.
Privilege and Competency Parallels
Rules 501 and 601 repeat Rule 302's formula almost word for word. Rule 601 provides that every person is competent to be a witness unless the rules provide otherwise, but in a civil case state law governs the witness's competency regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.19 Rule 501 provides that federal common law, as interpreted by United States courts in the light of reason and experience, governs a claim of privilege unless the Constitution, a federal statute, or other rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise, but in a civil case state law governs privilege regarding a claim or defense for which state law supplies the rule of decision.20 Rule 302 uses the same trigger for presumptions.21
Together the three rules mark the limited areas in which a federal court in a diversity case applies state evidence rules. The rest of the Rules apply whether federal or state law supplies the rule of decision.22 Legg ties the three to Erie. Rule 601 incorporates the Erie mandate by expressly providing that, when state law supplies the rule of decision, a witness's competency is determined under state law, and the court cross-referenced Rules 302 and 501 as parallel directions to state law.23
Legg also shows the competency rule operating on a state statute. The court recognized that some state evidentiary rules have substantive aspects that create a potential Erie conflict, and it held that the Tennessee statute before it was precisely the type of rule Rule 601 addresses.24 That holding reverses the usual default. Although the admissibility of expert testimony is generally a federal procedural matter, a state rule that fixes who is competent to testify falls under Rule 601, and in a diversity case state law decides who may take the stand.
An exam stem that puts a Dead Man's Statute in a federal courthouse invites the answer that evidence is procedural, so the federal rules control. That answer reasons from the courthouse, while the rule asks about the source of law for the claim. Change the claim to a federal statutory one and state law no longer supplies the rule of decision, so the general federal rule that virtually every person is competent governs.25
Privilege has the same second pole. When the claim or defense arises under federal law, state law supplies no rule of decision, and Rule 501 calls for the federal law of privileges, as it does in criminal cases.26 Federal common law, developed in light of reason and experience, decides the claim, and the privilege rules of the state where the court sits do not bind it.
Each of the three rules refers to state law without naming a state. Which state's law applies is the choice-of-law question taken up earlier in this chapter, and it arises for privilege and competency just as it does for presumptions.