Concept
Leading on Cross-Examination
Form of questions
Leading on Cross-Examination
Rule 611(c) gives one question of form two opposite default answers. Leading questions should not be used on direct examination except as necessary to develop the witness's testimony; ordinarily, the court should allow them on cross-examination.1 Both defaults answer to one concern, the risk that a witness will adopt the words the lawyer supplies. On direct, that risk is real, because the examiner called the witness and can expect cooperation. On cross, it shrinks, because the other side called the witness and the examiner has no cooperative bond to exploit. When the reason for a rule weakens, the default that rests on it reverses.
The exception for hostile witnesses runs on the same logic. When a party calls a hostile witness, an adverse party, or a witness identified with an adverse party, the court should ordinarily allow leading even on direct.2 Cross-examination builds that antagonism into the structure of the trial, so the rule can state a default without any showing. The word ordinarily keeps one door open: when the supposed opponent is in fact friendly to the examiner, the court may refuse leading. The first subsection below covers the ordinary rule, and the second covers the friendly witness. The question to ask of any leading objection on cross is who the witness is to the examiner.
Leading as the Ordinary Rule
The Advisory Committee noted that the rule conforms to tradition in making leading on cross-examination a matter of right, qualified only by the word ordinarily.3 The tradition rests on three features of the cross-examined witness. The opposing party called the witness. The cross-examiner has not prepared or rehearsed the witness on the matters covered on direct. And the relationship is presumed to be antagonistic, so the witness is unlikely to accept blindly the suggestion built into a question.4 The reason for prohibiting leading questions, that the witness will respond to counsel's suggestions, therefore generally does not apply to a witness under cross-examination.5
Leading is also the cross-examiner's main instrument of control. Narrow questions limit the witness's range of response, and a question phrased to call for a particular answer lets the examiner question the witness on the examiner's own terms and minimize the damage.6 The substance reaches the factfinder largely through the questions, and the answers confirm or acknowledge what each question in effect asserts.7 Under the guise of asking questions, the cross-examiner makes factual assertions on the record and forces the witness to assent, and so virtually testifies for the witness.8
The features that made leading suspect on direct are the ones cross-examiners value. A pointed question can invoke the witness's conscience and awaken her memory enough to dislodge her from an earlier version of events, expose limits or inaccuracies in her memory, and focus her attention on important details.9 Cross-examiners also lead to elicit favorable facts, to have the witness repeat favorable facts from direct, to establish undisputed facts the theory of the case needs, to get the witness to qualify or modify unfavorable testimony, to show that the testimony does not hurt on the critical points, and to keep the cross-examiner's theory before the trier of fact.10 Each of these aims is pursued in leading form.
Two limits keep the permission from becoming unbounded. The first is the word ordinarily, which lets the court refuse leading when the witness is friendly to the examiner, a limit the next subsection develops. The second is the court's control over the mode and order of examination under Rule 611(a), which lets the court protect witnesses from harassment or undue embarrassment.11 Within those limits, a cross-examiner may make repeated efforts to obtain an answer, by asking a question more than once or by rephrasing it to reach a single idea in more than one way, and the court's power to prevent harassment balances that traditional freedom.12 A rule against rephrasing would let a witness's first evasion end the inquiry. The line falls where repetition stops pursuing an answer and starts pressuring the witness.
Counsel's standard reply to a leading objection, "Your Honor, this is cross-examination," does not settle the matter. A proper ruling comes from analysis, not from one reflex answering another, and the analysis turns on the actual relationship between examiner and witness.13 On an exam, a stem that shows a lawyer leading a witness the opponent called calls for overruling the objection, and the answer should give the reason: the witness is presumed unfriendly and was not prepared by the examiner.
Friendly Witnesses on Cross
The word ordinarily in Rule 611(c)(1) marks the point where the permission to lead on cross-examination stops.15 Each reason for permitting leading on cross describes a relationship between questioner and witness, so the permission lasts only as long as the relationship does. The Advisory Committee wrote the qualification for that situation: it furnishes a basis for denying leading when the examination is cross-examination "in form only and not in fact."16 A lawyer who holds the formal right to cross-examine but the practical position of a direct examiner loses the leading privilege, because the danger that justified the ban on direct has come back.
That danger returns whenever the witness is partial to the lawyer asking the questions. If the witness favors the cross-examiner, leading carries the same risk it carries on direct, and the court has discretion to prohibit it.17 The rule's own wording leaves the matter to the judge: the court should ordinarily allow leading, a phrase of suggestion and not command, within the judge's control over the mode and order of interrogation.18 Many jurisdictions let the judge forbid leading when the witness appears biased in the cross-examiner's favor and likely to yield, although some somewhat illogical decisions permit it anyway.19
The Advisory Committee gave three examples of cross-examination in name only. A party is called by the opponent and then questioned by his own counsel, an examination that savors more of redirect. An insured defendant proves to be friendly to the plaintiff. And one defendant questions a friendly witness called by a codefendant, an examination that amounts to direct and, under the traditional rule, must proceed without leading.20
The first example connects to the adverse-party rule taught earlier in this chapter. When a plaintiff calls the defendant, the plaintiff may lead from the first question.21 The defendant's own lawyer then takes the same witness, and what the label calls cross-examination is in substance a friendly direct. A cross-examiner generally cannot lead a witness who is her own client or aligned with her client, as when defense counsel "cross-examines" the defendant after the plaintiff called the defendant.22 Most jurisdictions allow the witness's own counsel to examine immediately, but on request the judge should forbid leading questions during that examination.23
The codefendant problem shows how much of the procedural setting drops away once the relationship is isolated.
The judge may sustain the objection. A codefendant called Wendy, but she is also Doug's sister, and a sister is likely to accept whatever her brother's lawyer suggests. The traditional rule treats one defendant's examination of a friendly witness called by a codefendant as direct examination in substance, which must proceed without leading.24 If Doug were unrelated to Dan and Wendy, the family tie that makes her likely to yield would be gone, and the ordinary rule for cross would govern unless something else in the record showed that she favored Doug.25
The two versions share the same caption, the same witness, and the same question, and the answer turns on the single fact of relationship. Neither the label cross-examination nor the questioner's status as a codefendant decides the objection. The judge asks whether this witness is likely to yield to this questioner, and either ruling rests in the judge's discretion. Appellate courts have shown an almost total unwillingness to reverse for infractions of the leading rules.26 In one case where the trial court refused to let a party lead witnesses, the appellate court affirmed because the party never said what additional testimony leading would have produced, and any harm was therefore purely speculative.27
A stem that labels an examination cross-examination invites the quick answer that leading is allowed, and that answer is right for the ordinary opposing witness. The cue to watch for is a tie between witness and questioner: a party questioned by his own counsel, a relative of the questioner's client, or a witness sponsored by a codefendant whose interests the questioner shares.