Concept
Purpose of Sequestration
Exclusion of witnesses
Sequestration of Witnesses
Purpose of Sequestration
Rule 615(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence tells the court what to do when a party asks: it "must order witnesses excluded from the courtroom so that they cannot hear other witnesses' testimony." The court may also do so on its own.1 A request of this kind is called invoking the rule on witnesses, and Rule 615 sets no deadline for making it.2 The mechanics are simple: witnesses who are not on the stand wait outside until they are called. The reason for the rule shapes nearly everything else in Rule 615, so it comes first.
A witness who sits through other testimony learns what the others remember, which details are likely to be contested, and where the story has gaps. With that knowledge the witness can tailor an account on purpose, and can also be influenced without realizing it. In either case the cross-examiner finds it harder to expose fabrication, collusion, inconsistency, or inaccuracy.3 Cross-examination works by finding differences between one witness and another, or between a witness and the physical facts. Hearing the earlier testimony lets a witness smooth those differences away before anyone can test them.
The apocryphal story of Susanna and the Elders, an addition to the Old Testament book of Daniel, illustrates the principle.4 The point carries over to modern trials. Agreement between two witnesses is worth something only if each reached it alone, and agreement formed by listening proves little.
There is no constitutional right to the exclusion of witnesses from the courtroom, yet exclusion orders are available in virtually every jurisdiction.5 Rule 615 goes further than permitting such an order: when a party asks, the court "must" make it.6 A mandatory rule is workable because the burden is small. Persons who are not yet testifying are asked only to wait outside.
Courts state the purpose in the same terms. One court has called exclusion "a time-honored practice designed to prevent the shaping of testimony by hearing what other witnesses say."7 Another puts it as preventing one witness from "shaping his testimony to match that given by other witnesses at the trial."8
Because the target is exposure to testimony, Rule 615 governs who may hear what is said in the courtroom. It does not address whether an excluded witness's testimony is admissible. A witness kept in the hallway still takes the stand when called, and the answers are tested under the ordinary rules of evidence. Sequestration protects only the conditions under which the testimony is formed, so that the jury can weigh it as the independent account it is supposed to be.
Keeping that purpose in view helps predict the rest of Rule 615. An order under subsection (a) operates only to exclude witnesses from the courtroom, so the rule separately allows further orders aimed at disclosing and accessing testimony.9 Separation matters outside the courtroom as well as inside it, because it prohibits witness-to-witness communication in both places.10 The persons whom the court may not exclude are those whose presence a party can justify by something other than the risk of tailoring, and Rule 615(a) lists them.11 A violation raises the very concern the rule exists to prevent. For each topic below, ask what independence the rule is trying to preserve.