Concept
Why Convictions Impeach
Admissibility of a conviction to impeach under Rule 609(a)
Impeaching With Prior Convictions
Why Convictions Impeach
A prior conviction says nothing about what happened on the day of the events being tried, yet Rule 609 lets a party use one to cast doubt on a witness. The rule's opening line fixes the limit: its provisions govern attacking a witness's character for truthfulness by evidence of a criminal conviction.1 The conviction does one job. It suggests that the witness is the sort of person who lies and so deserves less belief.
The suggestion rests on a chain of three inferences. A conviction indicates a propensity to violate the law. That propensity means the witness is more willing than others to lie. And a tendency to lie is probative of whether the witness is lying on the stand.2 Each link moves from past conduct to present conduct, which is propensity reasoning, and it is fair to ask whether the chain holds.
It holds less well than its long use suggests. No empirical evidence shows that a person who has been convicted is more likely than others to lie. American courts have nonetheless long relied on prior convictions as proper impeachment.3 Several justifications support the practice. The veracity of witnesses is a highly important issue. The data on which the inference rests are likely to be accurate and subject to quick and clear proof. And it seemed anomalous at common law, and to the drafters of the Federal Rules, for a person convicted of serious crimes to appear before a jury and benefit from the jury's likely assumption of a clean record.4
The chain does not work equally well for every crime, and Rule 609 sorts convictions accordingly. It separates a conviction for a crime involving a dishonest act or false statement from convictions for other crimes, such as criminal assault or manslaughter. Crimes of lying or deceit point strongly toward a witness's lack of truthfulness, so Rule 609 makes this class automatically admissible.5 The legislative history explains the choice: such convictions are "peculiarly probative of credibility" and are always to be admitted, not left to the court's discretion.6
The second sorting question is who the witness is. Every witness risks impeachment by conviction, but a criminal defendant who testifies faces a special danger. The worry is that the jury, once it learns of the defendant's past wrongdoing, will not confine the conviction to the narrow question of truthfulness, and the prospect deters many defendants from testifying in their own defense.7 A defendant who stays off the stand does not escape the convictions entirely, but they can then come in only on other rationales that are harder for the opponent to establish.8
Timing sharpens the problem. Courts often decide admissibility in pretrial proceedings, and a defendant can challenge a ruling allowing impeachment only by testifying and then being impeached. Defendants are therefore deterred both where the rule properly applies and where the ruling might be wrong.9
Those two sorting questions, what the crime was and who the witness is, organize the rest of the rule. A conviction for a crime punishable by death or imprisonment for more than a year (a felony in the federal system and most states) may be used, but only after balancing. For a criminal defendant, the conviction's probative value must outweigh its prejudicial effect, a reverse 403 standard that favors exclusion. For every other witness, ordinary Rule 403 applies. Separately, any conviction, felony or misdemeanor, that entails dishonesty or false statement comes in with no discretion to disallow it.10 Rule 609 also discourages the use of stale convictions, those more than ten years old, and of juvenile adjudications.11 The next sections take these categories in turn.