Concept
Counting the Ten Years
Convictions more than ten years old under Rule 609(b)
Counting the Ten Years
Rule 609(b) switches on only after enough time has passed. By its terms it applies "if more than 10 years have passed since the witness's conviction or release from confinement for it, whichever is later."1 The sentence works as a gate. A conviction inside the ten years is governed by Rule 609(a) alone. A conviction outside them is generally inadmissible unless its probative value "substantially outweighs its prejudicial effect," a test far stricter than the ordinary balance.2 Later sections take up that test and the notice requirement. The count comes first, because an arithmetic error here sends the whole analysis down the wrong path.
The count is a measurement between two dates, and the rule treats the two ends unequally. The text fixes the start: the later of the conviction or the release from confinement for it. It does not fix the end. It requires that more than ten years have "passed" without saying passed as of what moment in the case, and courts have filled that gap in different ways.3 Each end therefore needs separate treatment, and a student who blurs them will miscount cases near the line.
Starting the Clock
The phrase "whichever is later" gives the count no single starting event.4 Two dates compete, the date of conviction and the date of release from confinement for that conviction, and the rule starts the count at the one that falls last. A witness who was never imprisoned has only the conviction date, so the ten years begin to run there.5 A witness who was confined has both dates. Release normally comes after conviction, so the count normally begins at release.6
The later-of rule keeps a prison term from using up the clock. If the count always began at conviction, a witness given a long sentence could walk out of prison with the conviction already more than ten years old. The age limit rests on the idea that an older conviction is less probative of character, and that character is assessed as of trial.7 Counting from release measures the time since the sentence for that conviction ended.
On an exam stem, which date controls turns on one fact: was the witness confined for this conviction? The first timeline shows confinement moving the clock.
Students often count from the conviction date out of habit. That instinct fails in the first timeline, because the conviction looks old but the rule does not ask how old the conviction is. In the second timeline the same habit lands on the right answer, for a reason worth seeing.
The two witnesses share a conviction year and a trial year. Confinement is the only fact that separates them, and it moves the start of the clock seven years and flips the governing standard.
A sentence of time served is the one situation in which confinement does not push the date later. When the court sentences the defendant to the days already spent in jail, release does not come after the conviction, so the conviction date is the later one.8 The rule also speaks of release from confinement "for it," meaning the conviction being offered, so time in custody on an unrelated offense does not move this clock. The dates the text lists are conviction and release from confinement. The end of a probation or parole term is not among them.
Courts have occasionally moved the starting point on unusual facts. In United States v. McClintock, the Ninth Circuit answered yes to the question whether the ten-year period should be extended when a person convicted flees after release on parole.9 Treat the case as a marker that the period can be extended on facts like these, not as a separate test. The default remains the later of conviction and release.
Stopping the Clock
The rule's text supplies the start of the ten years but is silent about the finish. Rule 609(b) applies "if more than 10 years have passed since" the conviction or release.11 Passed by what moment? The count could close on the date of trial, on the date the witness testifies, or on the date of indictment, and each reading fits the words. Courts differ on which to use.12
The three candidates fall in a fixed order: the indictment comes first, the trial next, and the witness's testimony last. An earlier end point leaves less time on the clock, so more convictions stay inside the window and are judged under Rule 609(a). A later end point lets more convictions cross the ten-year mark and fall under Rule 609(b). Whichever end point a court picks, the logic is the same: the older the conviction, the less it says about the witness's character, which is assessed at the time of trial.13
The choice decides an outcome only for a conviction near the line. A conviction eight years old and one fourteen years old land on the same side of the gate whichever end date a court uses. The hypothetical below measures to the start of trial.
The second witness is also where the split between courts shows up. Suppose that witness does not take the stand until more than a month into the trial. A court that measures to the date of testimony would find that the ten years have run by then, while a court that measures to the start of trial would find that they have not.
An exam answer should name the end point it uses, count to it, and keep the arithmetic visible. When the later-of date sits within a few weeks or months of the ten-year line, add a sentence noting that a court using a different end point could reach the other result.