Concept
Written Notice Requirement
Convictions more than ten years old under Rule 609(b)
Written Notice Requirement
A conviction more than ten years old reaches the jury only if the proponent clears two separate hurdles, and the second is notice. The proponent must give the adverse party “reasonable written notice of the intent to use it so that the party has a fair opportunity to contest its use.”1 Evidence of the old conviction is “admissible only if” the rule's conditions are met, so a missing notice keeps the conviction out however the weighing under the first condition would have come out.2 The duty belongs to subdivision (b), which applies when more than ten years have passed since the conviction or release from confinement, whichever is later. A conviction inside that window carries no written-notice condition.3
The first condition explains the second. The proponent must show probative value, “supported by specific facts and circumstances,” that substantially outweighs prejudicial effect, and an opponent cannot answer facts he has not seen.4 Written notice lets the opponent marshal arguments against admissibility before the conviction is offered.5 The need is plainest in a criminal case. An accused who can be freely impeached with prior convictions will probably decline to testify, and one who does testify risks having the jury use the convictions to infer a criminal character instead of an untruthful one.6 A party facing an old conviction therefore needs time to fight it, and notice supplies that time.
The rule's wording makes four demands. The notice must be written, so an oral warning does not satisfy the text. It must announce an intent to use the conviction, and “it” in the rule is the conviction, so the opponent learns which conviction the proponent plans to offer. It must be reasonable. And it must serve its stated purpose: a fair opportunity to contest use of the conviction. The rule fixes no deadline and no number of days. The purpose clause measures reasonableness, so notice is reasonable when it arrives early enough and specifically enough for the opponent to mount a real contest. A student who recites a fixed period has invented one.
The notice condition and the balancing condition are joined by “and,” so the proponent must satisfy both, and they answer different questions.7 The balancing condition asks whether the conviction deserves to be heard at all. The notice condition asks whether the opponent had a fair chance to argue that it does not. A strong showing on the first therefore does nothing for the second. Fraud convictions feel as though they ought to come in, and treating that strength as a substitute for notice is the error that costs points.
A proponent who does the work in advance reaches a better position, though not necessarily a winning one.
Timely notice earns the proponent a hearing and nothing more. Old convictions are sometimes admitted under the notice provision, but ordinarily they are excluded.8 If the judge in the second scene finds probative value and prejudicial effect about even, the conviction stays out, because the proponent needs probative value that substantially outweighs prejudicial effect.9
On an exam, give notice its own line in the Rule 609(b) analysis, separate from the balance, and look for when and how the proponent disclosed the conviction. A conviction first raised on cross-examination, with no earlier notice, fails. One mentioned only aloud at a pretrial conference fails the writing demand. A stem that is silent on notice leaves you to say that notice is required and must be shown. Check the date count first, because a nine-year-old conviction falls outside Rule 609(b) and needs no written notice.