Concept
Raising and Preserving the Issue
Convictions more than ten years old under Rule 609(b)
Raising and Preserving the Issue
Rule 609(b)(1) admits a conviction more than ten years old only if its "probative value, supported by specific facts and circumstances, substantially outweighs its prejudicial effect."1 A judge can make that finding only from what the parties put before the court. The companion requirement points the same way: the proponent must give "reasonable written notice" so that the adverse party has "a fair opportunity to contest its use," and an opportunity helps only the party who takes it.2 The cases divide the work into two halves. The opponent must ask for the weighing in a form the judge can act on. Once the opponent asks, the judge must do the weighing, and a careless word at trial does not take the request back.
Williams v. Dieball shows what happens when the opponent's half goes undone. Williams moved in limine, asking the court to rule before trial on whether the evidence could be offered, to keep out his prior convictions. The motion recited the Rule 609 standard and stopped. It did not ask the court to perform the balancing test, and it offered no argument about how or why the probative value of the convictions was substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. The defendants then addressed the balancing issue in their response, and Williams filed no reply. The court held that the argument was not preserved for appeal.3 Williams also pointed to inflammatory comments that defense counsel made when referring to the convictions, but he had not objected to them at trial, so that complaint failed for the same kind of reason.4
The opinion speaks of the Rule 609 standard in general terms, but its lesson carries over to Rule 609(b), where the proponent itself must support probative value with specific facts and circumstances.5 An opponent who answers that showing with nothing leaves the judge a one-sided record. A bare recitation of the standard tells the judge only what the judge already knows. What the judge lacks is a picture of this witness, this conviction, and the ways a jury might misuse it, and the party who stands to lose the weighing is best placed to supply that picture. Williams asked for nothing the judge could act on, and so he gave the trial court no ruling to get wrong.
The judge's half appears in the appeal of a defendant named Arney. In opening argument, defense counsel used the word "anything." The trial judge then ruled that any testimony could be elicited from Arney, and so never weighed the probative value of the remote conviction against its prejudicial effect.6 The appellate court disagreed on both points. Counsel's word did not bar Arney from objecting, and Arney objected effectively when the government told the court it would seek to elicit the conviction on cross-examination. Rule 609, as that court interprets it, requires the weighing. The requirement may be viewed as mandatory rather than discretionary, which places it outside review for abuse of discretion.7 The court vacated the conviction as to Arney and remanded so the district court could do the weighing itself. If probative value did not substantially outweigh prejudicial effect, the conviction would be set aside and Arney given a new trial. If it did, the judgment would stand affirmed and Arney would be resentenced.8
Read together, the two decisions mark the two halves of the process. In Arney the objection reached the court when the government announced its plan, and the error lay with a judge who skipped the weighing on the strength of a loose phrase. In Williams the opponent's motion supplied no argument to weigh, and the balancing complaint was lost on appeal. The opponent is protected against a judge who skips the step, but only if the opponent has made the request in a form that gives the judge something to weigh.
Two exam patterns follow. A stem in which defense counsel tells the jury in opening that the government may ask about anything tests the instinct to find a waiver, and the Arney decision rejects that instinct. A stem in which the opponent's motion is a single recitation of the standard, with no facts and no answer to the proponent's showing, tests the opposite lesson. A party who never asked for the weighing in a form the judge could act on cannot complain on appeal that the judge failed to perform it.