Concept
Capacity Versus Other Attacks
Ability to observe, remember, or relate accurately
Capacity Versus Other Attacks
Capacity impeachment claims that the witness lacked the physical ability to perceive, or the mental ability to remember, what the witness describes.1 The claim sits next to Rule 602, which allows a witness to testify to a matter only on evidence sufficient to support a finding of personal knowledge.2 A witness who clears that threshold can still be impeached on the ground that she was not equipped to know what she says she knows. Because Rule 601 forbids judges to exclude a witness for lack of capacity, the jury is the audience for the attack.3
Three other attacks aim at the same target, the jury's willingness to believe the witness, and from the counsel table all four can look alike. Bias claims that the witness has a reason to favor one side, such as a relationship with a party or a stake in the outcome. Specific contradiction claims that part of the testimony is untrue because it fails to match some fact about the world. Impeachment by prior inconsistent statement claims that the witness told a different story on an earlier occasion. Capacity differs from all three because it concerns the witness's own equipment for perceiving and remembering, not her motive, the world around her, or her past words.
The labels matter because the proof rules differ from one method to the next. Credibility attacks are made on cross-examination, where leading questions are permitted and the questioning is usually limited to credibility and matters raised on direct.4 Bias evidence is always relevant and may be proved with extrinsic evidence, meaning proof from a source other than the witness's own answers, such as a second witness or a document, subject to Rules 401 and 403.5 Specific contradiction is different: the Federal Rules do not govern it, and the common law collateral evidence rule limits the extrinsic proof a party may use, as explained below.6 A lawyer who picks the wrong label offers the evidence on the wrong theory, and the opponent's objection will be framed around the label the lawyer chose.
The label follows the fact the evidence tends to prove. Poor eyesight bears on whether an honest witness could have seen the event at all. A consulting fee bears on why a witness testifies the way she does. One witness can be attacked on both grounds, because the two theories are independent, but the cross-examiner should keep them apart. The usual exam mistake is to see the word unreliable in a fact pattern and write capacity, when the facts describe a motive or a conflict with the record.
Contrast a third kind of showing. Suppose a witness testifies that she saw the fatal blow from a distance by the light of a full, bright moon, and the cross-examiner offers an almanac showing that the moon gave little light that night. She has made no earlier statement about the night. There is only her trial testimony and a fact about the sky that undermines her credibility.7 The almanac is specific contradiction, because it shows that the testimony fails to match the world. It is not a prior inconsistent statement, because no earlier statement is involved. It is not capacity impeachment either, because it says nothing about her eyes, and the nearsightedness evidence above was the kind of showing that does.
Specific contradiction carries a limit that bias does not. Under the common law collateral evidence rule, a party may not introduce extrinsic evidence to prove a matter that is not material to a claim or defense, or to the credibility of some other witness.8 The rule keeps trials from filling with side disputes about details that decide nothing. Whether the almanac comes in therefore turns on whether the lighting matters to a claim or defense, and a party cannot get around that limit by announcing that the evidence goes to credibility.
Parties also reach for the wrong label when they relabel a credibility problem as something more drastic. In United States v. Bedonie, the appellants sought a further hearing on the incompetency of the government's key witnesses, and the court described the complaint as, more accurately, one of incredibility.9 Each witness had taken the oath and testified to being present at the events described. Each had been exhaustively cross-examined before the jury on the substance of prior inconsistent statements and on the witness's explanations for them. The court could not say the trial court abused its discretion in refusing the hearing or in deciding that the jury should weigh credibility.10 A string of inconsistencies shows what the witness said at different times, and the jury may weigh that against her. A capacity attack would need evidence about her ability to perceive or remember, as with the nearsighted witness above.