Concept
Methods of Attack and Support
Impeachment of hearsay declarants
Methods of Attack and Support
Rule 806 sets a single standard for every attack in this section. Once a qualifying statement is in evidence, the declarant's credibility may be attacked, and then supported, by "any evidence that would be admissible for those purposes if the declarant had testified as a witness."1 The rule lists no techniques of its own. It sends the court to the rules that govern a witness on the stand and asks, for each item of attacking or supporting evidence, whether that item would come in had the declarant been sworn and questioned. A yes admits the evidence against the absent speaker. A no keeps it out on the same terms.
The attacks that carry over are the familiar ones: prior convictions, bias or interest, defects in the ability to perceive or remember, and character for untruthfulness.2 Impeachment by inconsistent statement carries over too, but Rule 806 changes its procedure, so it has its own section below.3 Each method rests on a different theory of why a speaker might be unreliable, and each has its own limits. Support comes last because it answers attack. After the opponent impeaches, the proponent may offer whatever would rehabilitate a live witness in the same position, and evidence of truthful character comes in only after evidence of untruthful character has been introduced.4
Importing the live-witness rules wholesale avoids two bad alternatives. The jury is asked to believe the declarant, so the declarant's credibility matters.5 A code more protective than the live-witness rules would let a proponent use an out-of-court account while shielding its source from scrutiny that any testifying witness faces. A code less protective would expose the absent speaker to attacks the rules deny against a person on the stand, such as a conviction too stale to be used against a live witness. Parity gives the declarant exactly what a witness gets, and every technique arrives with the restrictions that govern it.6 A few live-witness techniques depend on the person's presence in the courtroom, and the discussion of character below shows where parity runs out for that reason. Prior convictions come first because the live-witness limits on them are the most detailed.
Prior Convictions
A prior conviction reaches an absent declarant by the route Rule 806 marks out. The court asks whether the conviction would be received against the speaker had the speaker testified. If so, it comes in under the same restrictions that govern a witness in the courtroom.7 Rule 806 writes no conviction rules of its own. It borrows Rule 609, so every limit Rule 609 places on a live witness's record also limits the declarant's.8
A conviction matters because a crime involving lying or deceit points strongly toward a lack of truthfulness, and that inference holds whether the person speaks from the stand or through a document the jury is asked to credit.9 Parity also protects the declarant. Rule 609 discourages the use of stale convictions (more than ten years old) and of juvenile adjudications, and it admits serious crimes without dishonesty only after a screening. Those limits would mean little if an absent declarant could be impeached with records that no live witness would have to answer for.10
Rule 609 sorts convictions onto two tracks, and the track decides what the opponent must show. Under Rule 609(a)(2), a conviction for any crime, regardless of the punishment, must be admitted if the court can readily determine that establishing the elements of the crime required proving, or the witness's admitting, a dishonest act or false statement. Admissibility on this track is automatic.11 Under Rule 609(a)(1), serious crimes that involve no dishonesty or false statement are only candidates for admission, and the court balances probative value against prejudicial effect before the jury hears of them. An offense that fits neither track stays out. A stem that stresses the declarant never took the stand offers a distractor, because absence from the courtroom removes the chance to question the declarant and leaves the conviction available.
The same parity reaches a declarant whom a jury might least expect to see impeached: a criminal defendant who never takes the stand. When the defendant's out-of-court statement comes in as hearsay, for example because the defense offers it under a hearsay exception, the prosecution may impeach the defendant with prior convictions as it could any declarant.12 A defendant who testifies faces that exposure, and a defendant who could place an account before the jury through a hearsay exception while staying off the stand would otherwise escape it. The rule reaches hearsay statements and the statements described in Rule 801(d)(2)(C), (D), and (E), so it does not apply when the prosecution offers the defendant's own statement against the defendant as an admission.13
Convictions travel to an absent declarant more easily than another familiar technique, questioning about past bad acts that never produced a conviction. A live witness can be asked about such acts on cross-examination, but a declarant who is not in court cannot be asked anything, so that method has no parallel unless the declarant is available and can be called as a witness.14 A conviction needs no questioning, which makes it the first attack a party reaches for against an absent speaker.
Bias and Capacity
Two of the most common attacks on a live witness, bias and defective capacity, reach the declarant unchanged, because each is evidence that would be admissible had the declarant testified.16 Bias is any tie, interest, or motive that could lead a person to shade an account, such as kinship with a party, a stake in the outcome, or a grudge. Capacity is the ability to perceive, remember, and report an event, and it is undermined by facts such as distance, poor light, intoxication, or a failing memory. The opponent may show a bias that could have affected the statement and may offer evidence about the declarant's ability to have perceived what the statement describes.17 Because the declarant is not in court to be asked about any tie to the case, the opponent proves bias through other witnesses or records.
These attacks tell the jury something different from what a conviction tells it. A conviction impugns the declarant's character, evidence of poor eyesight casts doubt on perception, and evidence of probable bias falls somewhere between the two.18 A capacity attack does not claim that the declarant lied. Its thrust is that the declarant, sincere or not, may be wrong.19
That message is the one a hearsay declarant's statement most needs. The jury hears the words without watching the speaker and without hearing anyone ask how far away the speaker stood. Admission under a hearsay exception puts the words before the jury, but it does not tell the jury whether the speaker was related to a party or could see the event. Rule 806 lets the opponent supply those facts.20
Capacity attacks reach sensitive ground when the proposed defect is a mental illness. Counsel cannot simply ask a witness whether he has been seeing a psychiatrist for ten years. The court applies Rule 403 and weighs four considerations: the nexus, according to medical authorities, between the alleged condition and testimonial accuracy; the importance of the witness's testimony; the time needed to receive the psychiatric evidence; and the extent to which the evidence may be far more embarrassing than probative.21 Rule 806 relaxes procedure only, and separate restrictions in other rules remain, so the same weighing governs when the person under attack is a declarant.22
The two scenes show where the limit sits. Evidence of a tie to a party or of a poor vantage point is concrete, quick to prove, and bears directly on whether the statement is accurate. A bare mention of psychiatric history has none of those features until someone connects it to the point on which the declarant spoke.
Character for Untruthfulness
One thing the opponent of a live witness may try to prove is that the witness is, by character, untruthful, and Rule 806 opens the same attack against a hearsay declarant once the statement is admitted.24 Proof of truthful character may answer it, but only after untruthful character has first been put in evidence.25 The proof typically comes from lay witnesses who know the declarant and can speak to the declarant's character for veracity.26 It takes one of two forms. Reputation evidence reports what people who know the declarant say about the declarant's honesty, and opinion evidence reports the witness's own judgment, formed from dealings with the declarant. Both come from someone other than the declarant, so the declarant's absence is no obstacle.
A student who has just studied the character-evidence rules may expect an objection here, and the instinct has a solid basis. Rule 404(a)(1) bars the use of evidence about a person's character to show that the person acted in conformity with that character at a particular time.27 Impeachment is a recognized exception, and the reason lies in what each use of the inference asks the jury to do.28 Proving a person's character to show how that person acted in the dispute risks trying people instead of cases. Proving character to show whether to believe the person who is speaking answers a question the jury must resolve anyway, because most trials turn on which witnesses the factfinder believes and the factfinder needs to know what kind of person each one is.29 A hearsay declarant's statement stands in for testimony, so the jury is asked to believe the declarant just as it would a witness.30 The inference that is forbidden when aimed at the dispute is permitted when aimed at the speaker.
The exception has a shape that follows from its reason. The trait the opponent proves must be truthfulness, because that is the trait that bears on belief, and evidence that a declarant is hot-tempered or careless says nothing about the reliability of the account. The witness must also know the declarant, since reputation and opinion testimony have value only when they come from acquaintance.
Reputation and opinion describe a person in general terms, so any acquaintance can deliver them to an absent declarant. Proof of one particular lie is different. A live witness is questioned about specific past acts on cross-examination, but a declarant who is not in court cannot be asked about anything, so the technique has no parallel unless the declarant is available and can be called as a witness.31 A stem in which a third party describes a specific episode of the declarant's lying is therefore not a reputation or opinion attack, and it is not admissible merely because character for untruthfulness is a proper subject. The limits on that technique have their own section below.
Supporting the Declarant
Rule 806 gives a party two tools against an absent speaker's credibility, in a fixed order: the declarant's credibility "may be attacked, and then supported, by any evidence that would be admissible for those purposes if the declarant had testified as a witness."33 The rule treats the declarant as a witness for impeachment and rehabilitation alike, so an impeached declarant may be rehabilitated in the same ways, and on the same terms, as a live witness.34 Support uses the same measuring stick as attack. The court asks what the proponent could offer to repair the declarant's standing had the declarant been sworn and cross-examined, and it receives that evidence.
Truthful-character evidence is the clearest illustration. For a live witness, proof of good character for truthfulness comes in only where evidence of character for untruthfulness has first been introduced, and the same condition governs a hearsay declarant.35 A person who knows the declarant testifies to the declarant's reputation for honesty or gives an opinion that the declarant is honest, and the declarant's absence is no obstacle, since the testimony comes from someone else. It works as a reply to a charge the opponent has already put before the jury.
Two reasons explain why the rule allows support and why support waits for attack. A rule that permitted attack and forbade repair would leave the jury with a damaged picture of a speaker who cannot answer an accusation by taking the stand. Yet evidence that a speaker is honest tells the jury nothing it needs until someone has suggested otherwise, so the opponent's attack opens the door and the proponent cannot open it alone.
An exam-style fact pattern shows the sequence, and it begins with the instinct that loses the point. A proponent whose declarant has been attacked in some way often assumes that any attack permits any support.
A different scene shows the door opening.
The difference between the scenes lies in what the opponent's evidence attacked. Truthful-character support answers an attack on truthfulness, so the rule ties it to the introduction of untruthful-character evidence.36 A capacity attack leaves the declarant's honesty untouched, so the proponent answers it with evidence that meets it, such as proof of a clear view, and proof of honest character has nothing to reply to. A proponent who opens with praise for the declarant before any attack offers support that the rule's order of events does not yet allow. Other forms of rehabilitation follow the live-witness rules and carry their own conditions, which this section does not cover.