Concept
Testifying Defendants and Character
Reputation or opinion rehabilitation
Testifying Defendants and Character
A criminal defendant cannot be compelled to testify, but one who chooses to take the stand places his credibility in issue as any other witness does.1 Rule 608(a) therefore reaches him like every other witness: reputation or opinion testimony supporting his truthful character is admissible only after his character for truthfulness has been attacked.2 His decision to testify also frees the government to offer evidence bearing on his believability, though it does not open the door to attacks on his general character.3
The difficulty is that an accused has a second, separate route to character evidence. Rule 404(a)(2)(A) lets him offer a pertinent trait of his character, and a defendant who wants to vouch for his own testimony may try to claim that route and skip the wait that Rule 608(a) imposes. Both routes put a character witness on the stand to speak well of the defendant. They differ in what the praise is offered to prove, and that difference decides which rule governs.
Two Rules, Two Purposes
Rule 404(a)(2)(A) is a substantive exception. A criminal defendant is entitled to introduce evidence of a pertinent trait of his character, even though the general rule bars propensity inferences, because he may have a very hard time refuting mistaken eyewitness testimony or developing other exculpatory proof.4 The jury hears that the defendant has the trait and may infer that he is less likely to have committed the charged crime.
Pertinence ties the trait to the charge. Evidence of nonviolence would not be admitted in an embezzlement case. Evidence of honesty and careful treatment of other people's property would clearly be admissible in a trial for theft. Testimony that a defendant is generally law-abiding may be treated as pertinent to any criminal charge.5
Rule 608(a) does a different job. Character evidence offered under it asks the jury to believe the defendant's testimony, not to doubt that he committed the crime, and the Rule permits it only after an attack on his character for truthfulness.6 The Rules allow propensity inferences about a witness's truthfulness in part because the veracity of witnesses is a highly important issue and because the data behind those inferences are thought likely to be accurate and quick and clear to prove.7 That rationale explains why the inference is allowed at all. The Rule's timing sentence still decides when support may come in.
A testifying defendant may be in a position to claim either rule, so the two situations must be kept apart: the defendant who takes the stand and thereby becomes subject to an attack on his credibility, and the accused who offers a pertinent trait under Rule 404(a)(2)(A), with or without testifying himself.8 Whether the defendant testifies does not decide which rule applies. The purpose of the offer does.
Danehy, Drury, and the Purpose Test
United States v. Danehy shows the purpose test at work. Danehy testified and then tried to bolster his testimony with evidence of his reputation for truthfulness. The court held that he was offering the evidence to bolster himself as a witness rather than to show a trait pertinent to the crime charged, so Rule 608 and not Rule 404 governed.9 Rule 608 permits truthful-character evidence only after the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked by opinion or reputation evidence or otherwise. Government counsel who point out inconsistencies in the accused's testimony and argue that he is not credible have not attacked his reputation for truthfulness, so Danehy could not bolster himself with reputation evidence.10
The purpose test closes a loophole. If a testifying defendant could label his own truthfulness a pertinent trait and offer it under Rule 404, the attack requirement would bind every witness except the one with the most at stake. Danehy therefore turns on the use the evidence would serve, not on the label the defendant attaches. Compare the rule on juror testimony about deliberations: jurors might regard divine guidance as coming from outside the jury room, yet testimony about it stays out because it involves only the individual thoughts and feelings of jurors and is not the kind of outside influence the rule allows.11
Drury applies the same timing rule. After reviewing the exchanges between the government's counsel and Drury, the court held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in excluding the proffered testimony, and it repeated that evidence of a witness's truthful character is admissible only after the character for truthfulness has been attacked.12 The abuse-of-discretion standard anticipates the discussion of trial court discretion below.
When the Trait Is Pertinent to the Charge
The result changes when the trait itself bears on the charged offense. An accused who offers a pertinent trait may do so whether or not he testifies, and no attack on his credibility has to come first.13
That route carries a price. Once the defendant offers the trait, the prosecution may respond with its own character witnesses, and the prosecutor may cross-examine the defendant's character witnesses by asking whether they have heard or know about specific past actions by the defendant.14 The next section takes up that cross-examination.