Concept
Cross-Examining the Character Witness
Reputation or opinion rehabilitation
Cross-Examining the Character Witness
Calling a character witness lets the proponent answer an attack on a principal witness, and it lets the opponent put accusations to the jury through a witness the proponent cannot control. Rule 608(b) governs the exchange, and its two sentences pull in opposite directions. The first bars extrinsic evidence of a witness’s specific instances of conduct when it is offered to attack or support the witness’s character for truthfulness; the lone exception is a criminal conviction under Rule 609. Extrinsic evidence is proof from outside the witness’s own answers, such as another witness or a document. The second sentence lets the court, on cross-examination, allow inquiry into specific instances that are probative of the truthfulness or untruthfulness of the witness being cross-examined or of “another witness whose character the witness being cross-examined has testified about.”1
A character witness who has vouched for a principal witness falls in that second category. The opponent may therefore ask the character witness about the principal witness’s conduct, though the opponent must accept whatever answer comes back.
The cross exists because of what the direct leaves out. On direct, the character witness gives a conclusion, a reputation or an opinion, with none of the episodes behind it. A conclusion is worth only as much as the knowledge and standards of the person who reaches it, and cross-examination is how a jury learns how much that is. The first subsection covers what the cross-examiner may ask and why the questions work. The second covers the limits that keep those questions from becoming a smear.
Testing Knowledge and Judgment
The cross-examiner asks the character witness about specific conduct of the principal witness that bears on honesty. At common law the phrasing depended on the kind of testimony: a reputation witness was asked “Have you heard?” and an opinion witness “Do you know?” or “Are you aware?” The distinction mattered so little in practice that the Federal Rules abandon it, so either phrasing may go to either witness.2 The character witness may also be asked whether she is familiar with the principal witness’s convictions, arrests, and indictments, and acts involving dishonesty or false statement are fair game even when they never produced a conviction.3
An illustration shows why the questions bite. Coach Jones has given a bad opinion of Gardner, and the other side answers by calling Reverend Gram, who vouches for her honesty. Jones’s side then asks Gram about damaging incidents in Gardner’s past. The questions are built so that the attacker gains whichever way Gram replies. If Gram did not know of the incidents, he lacked important information about Gardner. If he did know of them, his good opinion of her honesty is hard to understand.4 The second answer can also suggest bias: a witness who knows the unfavorable fact and still vouches for the principal witness is either lying or applying a rather strange standard for good character.5
A reputation witness faces the same dilemma in a form that fits what that witness claims to know. A witness who has not heard about the principal witness’s bad conduct may not be plugged into the community whose talk supposedly makes up the reputation. A witness who has heard about it and still reports a good reputation calls the community’s judgment into question.6 Either answer weakens the testimony.
The answers matter only as impeachment of the character witness. They do not prove that the principal witness did the act, and for that reason the cross-examiner must take whatever answer comes back: the only legitimate relevance of this line of questioning is the character witness’s credibility.7 The next subsection develops that restriction.
For the proponent, this exposure is part of the price of rehabilitation. The question itself carries the accusation, and the proponent chose the witness who must face it. Anyone deciding whether to call a character witness should ask what the other side could put to that witness and whether the witness has an answer. The other side often already holds the material. Coach Jones presumably has reasons for his bad opinion, perhaps drawn from specific instances of Gardner’s behavior, and his side is entitled to turn those reasons into questions for Gram.8
Exam stems invite three mistakes here. One is to call the question improper because the character witness could not have mentioned specific acts on direct. Another is to treat a “no” answer as proof that the principal witness did the act. The third is to confuse the clauses of the Rule: a question about the character witness’s own conduct falls under Rule 608(b)(1), while a question about the person the witness vouched for falls under Rule 608(b)(2).9
Limits on Cross-Examination
Five limits keep the cross-examination from turning into a smear, and each answers a different danger. The first is a threshold: the person the character witness vouched for must have testified.
That limit comes from the text of the Rule, which reaches “another witness whose character the witness being cross-examined has testified about.”11 A person who never takes the stand is not a witness. United States v. Anderson turned on that gap. Anderson tried to bring out Besore’s felony conviction while cross-examining Thibodeau, but Besore never testified.12 The appeals court held that Rule 608(b)(2), which speaks of “another witness,” could not reach him, so the district court correctly refused to admit specific instances of Besore’s conduct during Thibodeau’s cross-examination.13 Anderson then tried a second route, arguing that the real target was Thibodeau’s credibility and the conviction could come in through the back door. The court shut that door as well, because Rule 608(b) refers to specific instances of the conduct of a witness, and Besore was not one.14 The structure explains the result: credibility evidence helps a jury weigh testimony, and an absent person has no testimony to weigh.
The second limit is a good-faith basis. A question such as “Did you know she was fired for falsifying records?” puts the accusation in the questioner’s own words, and the jury hears it whatever the answer. Whatever the form of the question, the cross-examiner must have a good-faith basis in fact for the inquiry, and if counsel cannot show one at sidebar after an objection, the judge should bar it.15 A cross-examiner who asks without a reasonable basis commits gross misconduct.16
The third limit requires that the act bear on truthfulness. The Rule reaches only instances probative of the principal witness’s character for truthfulness or untruthfulness.17 Acts that qualify normally involve deceit, a false statement, or falsification, some element of active misrepresentation.18 Courts usually treat specific acts of dishonesty or false statement as sufficiently probative.19 The character witness vouched for honesty and nothing else, so the cross asks whether that judgment survives the facts. A fraudulent insurance claim bears on the question. A shove in a parking dispute does not, because a person can be violent and honest.
The fourth limit is the court’s discretion. The Rule says the court may allow the inquiry, so permission is never automatic. The court asks whether the instance is probative of untruthfulness and whether, under Rule 403, the probative value of the question and answer on credibility is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. It also considers how effective a limiting instruction under Rule 105 would be.20 Rule 611(a)(3) adds a power to preclude cross-examination that would harass or unduly embarrass a witness.21 The next section takes up that discretion in full.
The fifth limit binds the cross-examiner to the reply. Extrinsic evidence of an act that produced no conviction is inadmissible, so after the character witness denies the act or professes ignorance of it, the cross-examiner must take the answer.22 The Advisory Committee’s Note to the 2003 amendment says the absolute prohibition on extrinsic evidence applies when the sole reason for offering it is to attack the witness’s character for truthfulness.23 A criminal conviction is the one exception. One justification for letting jurors draw propensity inferences about truthfulness is that the underlying data are likely to be accurate and subject to quick and clear proof, a description that fits a conviction better than an uncharged accusation.24
The first four steps decide whether a question may be asked, and the fifth governs what the cross-examiner can do with the reply. Steps one and five do the most work on exams, because stems rarely make them obvious. Step one hides in a sentence noting that the person praised was never called, and step five in counsel’s request to call a second witness after a denial.