Concept
What Contradiction Is
Contradiction
Impeachment by Contradiction
What Contradiction Is
Any party, including the party that called the witness, may attack the witness's credibility.1 The attacks come in five kinds. Three give the jury a general reason to doubt the witness's word without pinpointing any one error: bias, a deficiency in the witness's capacity to observe, remember, or recount, and an attack on the witness's character.2 The other two, prior inconsistent statements and contradiction, target a particular misstatement but say nothing about why it was made.3 Contradiction is the fifth kind, proof by other witnesses that material facts are not as the witness testified.4
Some credibility facts need no attack at all. A witness's occupation and residence may be elicited on direct or cross-examination as a matter of right, because they help the jury decide how much credit the testimony deserves.5 Contradiction asks for more, because it asserts that something the witness said is wrong.
Impeachment by contradiction presents evidence that part or all of a witness's testimony is incorrect. Suppose an eyewitness to an auto accident testifies that the car that caused it was red, and the impeaching party proves that the car was yellow. The jury is invited to infer not that the witness lied but that she made a mistake of fact, so that the rest of her testimony may contain other errors and deserves to be discounted.6
The inference rests on ordinary logic. A person who remembers or describes some things incorrectly may testify incorrectly about others, and the jury can lower its estimate of the witness whether the falsehoods were intentional or accidental.7 Evidence law therefore treats factual errors as logically relevant to general credibility. The technique pays for its directness with silence about cause: the error could come from faulty perception, faulty memory, or deliberate falsehood, and the proof does not say which.8
Contradiction arises when counsel sets one witness's account against other proof. Suppose witness A testifies about the condition of the road at the time of an accident. The lawyer who called her, with the court's permission, examines her as if on cross-examination but cannot get her to retract or change her account. Counsel then calls witness B and directs B's attention to the condition of the road, or even to A's testimony, and B's account conflicts with A's. A has been impeached by contradiction.9 The mere fact that B's testimony is not entirely congruent with A's does not impeach A; what makes it contradiction is counsel's use of B against A's account. The example also shows Rule 607 at work, since the party that called A is the one attacking her.10
Contradiction should not be confused with self-contradiction, in which the conflict lies between two statements by the same witness. Suppose Wendy tells the plaintiff and a police officer at the scene that the defendant's car entered the intersection on a red light, and at trial she denies making the statement, says the light was green, or says she cannot remember.11 Wendy has been caught against her own earlier words, and Rule 613 governs how the earlier statement is put to her and when extrinsic proof of it may come in. The common-law cross-examiner worked from a strict script: lead the witness gently to the inconsistency, show her the statement if it was written, call attention to its time and circumstances, and only then ask whether she made it.12 Rule 613(a) relaxes that script by providing that a party examining a witness about a prior statement need not show it or disclose its contents to the witness, though on request the party must show it or disclose its contents to an adverse party's attorney.13 Rule 613(b) bars extrinsic evidence of the statement until the witness has had an opportunity to explain or deny it and the adverse party an opportunity to examine the witness about it, unless the court orders otherwise.14
Contradiction needs no earlier statement at all. In 1858, William "Duff" Armstrong was accused of killing a man with a "slung shot." The key prosecution witness claimed to have seen the fatal blow from some distance away because the moon was full and bright. Lincoln, defending, impeached the witness with an almanac showing the phases of the moon, suggesting that the moon gave little light. The case involved no prior statement, only trial testimony and the fact that the moon's light was weak.15 This chapter therefore uses contradiction for a clash between testimony and fact, and self-contradiction for a clash between two statements by the same witness.16
The Federal Rules do not expressly list contradiction as a method of impeachment, yet the federal courts continue to permit it, and rightly so, because including Article VI reflects the drafters' recognition that a witness's credibility is a fact of consequence under Rule 401.17 Two controls apply. Rule 403 lets the court exclude relevant evidence whose probative value is substantially outweighed by dangers such as unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, misleading the jury, undue delay, wasting time, or needlessly presenting cumulative evidence.18 And the common-law collateral evidence rule prohibits extrinsic evidence offered to prove a matter that is not material to a claim or defense, or to the credibility of some other witness.19 The sections that follow take up how that rule operates.