Concept
General Scope of the Rules
Proceedings to which evidence rules apply
Where the Evidence Rules Apply
General Scope of the Rules
Every evidence question starts with a threshold one: does the code apply at all? Rule 101(a) answers it in two sentences. The Federal Rules of Evidence apply to proceedings in United States courts, and Rule 1101 sets out the specific courts and proceedings covered, along with the exceptions.1 Rule 101 is titled "Scope; Definitions," but the scope provision in subdivision (a) is the part that matters here.2 The provision follows the pattern of Rule 1 in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Criminal Procedure, and Appellate Procedure, each of which opens with a broad statement of scope. It also points to Rule 1101, where the exceptions to coverage are specified in detail.3 The scope question therefore gets answered in two steps. Rule 101(a) states the general principle, and Rule 1101 answers it for a particular court and a particular kind of proceeding. The rest of this chapter follows Rule 1101 in that order.
A code that announces its own reach matters because of what it replaced. Until the Rules appeared, evidence law was mostly a creature of common law tradition. Statutes in most states covered only pieces of it, such as the physician-patient privilege, business and public records, and some aspects of impeaching witnesses, and comprehensive codes were slow to arrive and slow to gain acceptance.4 Without a code, nearly every evidentiary issue that came up at trial, and they arise by the score, sent lawyers and judges to case law and treatises. The Federal Rules took effect on July 1, 1975, and were restyled effective December 1, 2011, so the text you work with today is the restyled version.5
The phrase United States courts draws the outer boundary by forum. The Federal Rules apply in the federal proceedings the rule describes, and a large majority of states have copied them, with some variation in specific provisions.6 A state that copies the federal text has written its own evidence code, and that code governs in the state's courts. Rule 101(a) does not reach a state-court proceeding, however closely the state code tracks the federal one. A bar-exam stem that sets a trial in a state with a word-for-word copy of the federal rules is testing whether copying the text changes which court is sitting. It does not.
The two courtrooms share the same claim and the same evidence-code wording. They differ only in the court that is sitting, and that is the first fact Rule 101(a) looks to. Once the forum is a United States court, the analysis turns to Rule 1101.