Concept
Courts Covered by the Rules
Proceedings to which evidence rules apply
Courts Covered by the Rules
Rule 101(a) says the Federal Rules of Evidence apply in United States courts, and it sends you to Rule 1101 for the specific courts and proceedings, along with the exceptions.1 Rule 1101(a) answers the court question with a list. The Rules apply to proceedings before:2
- United States district courts;
- United States bankruptcy and magistrate judges;
- United States courts of appeals;
- the United States Court of Federal Claims; and
- the district courts of Guam, the Virgin Islands, and the Northern Mariana Islands.
Every entry on the list is a federal court or a federal judge, so the Rules attach to the forum where the proceeding takes place. On any exam stem, identify the court first and ask which words of which code govern second. Bankruptcy and magistrate judges appear by name, so the Rules follow a matter into their courtrooms just as they follow it into a district court's.
State courts appear nowhere on the list, so Rule 1101(a) does not reach them, and each state court applies its own evidence law. A large majority of states have copied the Federal Rules, with some variation in specific provisions, which is why a state-court hearsay objection often sounds just like a federal one.3 The copy is still state law, however, in force because the state enacted it. Suppose a county court in such a state tries a contract dispute without a jury, under a code identical in wording to the federal text. The county court is not on the Rule 1101(a) list, so the federal Rules do not govern it, and the state's code does.
Coverage follows the court even when state law supplies the claim. In a diversity case, a federal court applies state substantive law, yet the Federal Rules generally still govern the evidence, whether federal or state law supplies the rule of decision.4 The Rules yield to state evidence rules only in limited areas: presumptions, privileges, and competency of witnesses. See Rules 301, 501, and 601.5
Students often let the source of the claim choose the evidence code, which sends every objection in a state-law case to state evidence law. Rule 1101(a) looks at the forum first, and state law enters a federal courtroom only through the limited areas the Rules themselves leave to it.