Concept
Cases and Proceedings Covered
Proceedings to which evidence rules apply
Cases and Proceedings Covered
Knowing that a court is covered answers only half of the scope question. Rule 1101(b) answers the other half by listing the matters in which the Rules apply: civil cases and proceedings, including bankruptcy, admiralty, and maritime cases; criminal cases and proceedings; and contempt proceedings, except those in which the court may act summarily.1 Rule 1101(a), covered above, names the courts and judges the Rules bind, but a judge in a covered court does more than try lawsuits and prosecutions. The same judge issues arrest warrants, handles extradition, and sentences defendants, and Rule 1101(d) treats those tasks separately.2
Each half of the test limits the other. The Rules regulate how parties offer proof and how a judge resolves objections to it, so they belong where adversaries contest facts before a decision maker. A rule keyed only to the court would sweep in every task a federal judge performs, including tasks in which no contested offer of proof occurs. A rule keyed only to the kind of matter would ignore the forum. Requiring both a covered court and a covered matter keeps the Rules at full adversarial trials and hearings and leaves the exceptions to be handled one by one.
Civil and criminal cases come first, followed by contempt, the one category the rule qualifies with an exception of its own. On an exam, ask which court is sitting under Rule 1101(a), then ask what kind of matter that court is deciding under Rule 1101(b).
Civil and Criminal Cases
Rule 1101(b) opens with two broad categories: civil cases and proceedings, expressly including bankruptcy, admiralty, and maritime cases, and criminal cases and proceedings.3 The entries sort matters by kind, civil or criminal, and not by claim or charge. A contract suit, a securities class action, a wire fraud prosecution, and a firearms case all fall inside them without being named.
The words cases and proceedings travel together because Rule 101(b) defines the terms the Rules use. A civil case means a civil action or proceeding, and a criminal case includes a criminal proceeding.4 The definitions stretch case to reach proceedings, and Rule 1101(b) repeats the point in its own text. Coverage therefore attaches to an evidentiary hearing held inside a lawsuit or a prosecution as well as to the trial itself. If case meant only the trial on the merits, a party could escape the Rules by calling a hearing a mere proceeding. The text closes that gap.
The express mention of bankruptcy, admiralty, and maritime cases removes any doubt that the Rules follow those specialized dockets. A district court that tries an admiralty claim for damage to cargo passes both steps of the coverage inquiry: a district court is on the Rule 1101(a) list, and an admiralty case is a civil case under Rule 1101(b).5 A bankruptcy judge hearing a contested bankruptcy matter passes both steps the same way.
Criminal coverage works identically. A federal jury trial on a felony indictment is a criminal case in a covered court, so the Rules govern what evidence the jury hears. Because the criminal entry also reaches criminal proceedings, the same coverage extends to contested evidentiary hearings within a prosecution, subject to the exceptions taught below.
The tempting error is to treat the criminal label as a switch that turns the Rules on at every stage of the case. Rule 1101(b) settles coverage for the case and its proceedings. Rule 1101(d), taken up in its own section, removes certain stages from a covered case, and sentencing is one of them.6
Two questions therefore stay separate on an exam. The first asks whether the matter is a civil or criminal case or proceeding in a covered court, and Rule 1101(b) answers it. The second asks whether the stage in question is one that Rule 1101(d) removes from a covered case, and a later section of this chapter answers that.
Contempt Proceedings
Rule 1101(b) closes its list with contempt proceedings, the only entry that carries a qualification: the Rules apply in "contempt proceedings, except those in which the court may act summarily."8 The first half of that entry is a coverage rule, so a contempt matter in a covered court is presumptively governed by the Rules, just as a civil or criminal case would be. The second half withdraws one kind of contempt matter. Because the qualification sits inside Rule 1101(b) itself, it determines which contempt proceedings count as covered at all, and it works separately from the list of excluded proceedings in Rule 1101(d), which a later section takes up.9
The line falls where it does because of what the Rules regulate. They matter most when a court must decide a disputed fact on proof that one side presents and the other contests. A contempt matter that proceeds that way looks like any other adversarial hearing: the court gives notice of the accusation, witnesses testify, the accused answers, and the judge makes findings that support a sanction. The person facing the sanction needs the same screening of unreliable proof that protects a civil defendant or a criminal accused, so the Rules apply. A court acting summarily holds no such hearing. A power to act summarily is a power to respond without notice, testimony, and objections, and an evidence code has little to regulate where no proof is offered.
The summary case is easiest to see alone, because the instinct is to assume that any judge ruling on anything in a covered court is bound by the Rules.
A different contempt matter in the same courthouse comes out the other way.
The word contempt appears in both scenes, and a covered federal court sits in both. The scenes differ in what the court is doing. In the first the court responds at once without a hearing. In the second it tries a disputed accusation with notice and an opportunity to present evidence. Rule 1101(b) draws its line there.
The tempting error is to let the contempt label decide the question in either direction. Some students conclude that every contempt matter is covered because contempt appears on the list, and others conclude that none is covered because the entry mentions an exception. The entry covers contempt proceedings generally and excludes those in which the court may act summarily. Rule 1101 does not itself say when a court may act summarily, so that question belongs to the law governing contempt. An exam stem will usually signal the category, either by describing a noticed hearing with witnesses or by describing an immediate response to something the judge saw, and you should sort the stem accordingly.