Concept
Privilege at Every Stage
Proceedings to which evidence rules apply
Privilege at Every Stage
Rule 1101(c) settles one question in a single sentence: the rules on privilege apply to all stages of a case or proceeding.1 That sentence explains a feature of Rule 1101(d). The subsection takes the rest of the Federal Rules of Evidence out of grand-jury proceedings, preliminary examinations, sentencing, and the other listed matters, and each time it does so it excepts the rules on privilege.2 Rules 1101(a) and 1101(b) decide which courts and cases the Rules govern, Rule 1101(d) then subtracts particular proceedings, and the privilege rules stay with the case through both steps.3 A privilege claim therefore cannot be answered by pointing out that the proceeding is one in which the Rules do not apply.
Privilege differs from the ordinary rules in who controls it. Parties invoke or waive the ordinary rules as litigants, as an essential part of the adversary system. Owners invoke or waive privileges, and an owner may or may not be a party to the litigation.4 A client whose lawyer is summoned before a grand jury is not a litigant in that room, yet the privilege remains the client's to invoke or waive. This difference in ownership fits the design of Rule 1101: the party-driven rules can fall away in a given proceeding while the owner-driven privilege rules remain.
Applying the privilege rules at every stage does not make a privilege claim prove itself. Rule 104(a) directs the court to decide any preliminary question about whether a privilege exists, and it frees the court from the evidence rules except those on privilege.5 The person asserting a privilege must show the facts that give rise to it, and a mere assertion does not carry that burden.6 Rule 1101(c) thus guarantees that the claim will be heard and decided under the privilege rules in every proceeding, but the claimant must still establish the privilege.
A single hearing that draws two objections of different kinds tests the rule most cleanly.
The hearsay objection fails because the hearsay rule is one of the ordinary rules, and Rule 1101(d)(3) lists a preliminary examination in a criminal case among the matters in which those rules do not apply.7 The privilege objection rises or falls on the privilege rules alone, because Rule 1101(c) keeps them in force at every stage. The states confirm the pattern: they differ on whether the rules of evidence otherwise apply at a preliminary hearing, but all of them recognize privileges there.8 The same sorting works in the other settings Rule 1101(d) lists. A lawyer subpoenaed to a grand jury may assert the client's attorney-client privilege, and at sentencing or a bail hearing the privilege rules apply even though the ordinary rules do not.
Because the privilege rules govern at every stage, the way they operate at each stage matters, and United States v. Zolin shows one consequence. Rule 104(a) leaves the privilege rules binding on the judge, so one might suppose the judge may never look at a communication over which privilege is claimed. The IRS in Zolin sought exactly that review, in camera, to show that the crime-fraud exception, which removes protection from communications made to further a crime or fraud, applied. The Court first determined that Rule 104(a) does not prohibit the review. It then asked the question as one of the federal common law of privileges under Rule 501, and it concluded that a complete prohibition against an opponent's use of in camera review to establish the crime-fraud exception is inconsistent with the policies underlying the privilege.9 A claim of privilege therefore opens the court's inquiry into the privilege and its limits, and it does not end that inquiry.
Students tend to err in one of two opposite directions. The first is to reason that a grand jury, a bail hearing, or a sentencing is listed in Rule 1101(d), so the witness's privilege claim fails along with the other objections, and Rule 1101(d) itself rules that out by excepting privilege. The second is to reason that because privilege survives, every objection that sounds protective survives with it. A hearsay or relevance objection rests on an ordinary rule, and it is unavailable in the listed proceedings no matter how confidential the material seems. The useful question is which kind of rule the objection invokes: a privilege rule follows the case into every proceeding, and an ordinary rule does not.