Concept
Conditional Relevance
Relevancy
Conditional Relevance
Some evidence helps the jury only if a second fact is true. In a murder prosecution, the first witness is the police officer who searched the defendant's home, and he testifies that he found a machete under the defendant's bed. The testimony bears on the case only if the murder was committed with a machete, and not with a gun or some other lethal instrument.1 Its relevance depends on a fact that no one has yet proved.
A civil case has the same shape. Puck sues Dora and testifies to the terms of an offer he received. If a third party made the offer, Puck's account of its terms is irrelevant; the testimony supports a consequential fact if, and only if, Dora made or authorized the offer.2
Relevance often runs through a chain of inferences that the evidence itself supports. In a murder prosecution, Knapp claimed self-defense and said he had heard a rumor that the sheriff had killed a man. The prosecution offered medical testimony that the man had died of an illness caused by alcoholism, and the court held the testimony logically relevant. It justified an inference that Knapp had not heard the rumor he claimed to have heard, which made it less probable that he had reason to fear the sheriff, which made it less probable that he acted in self-defense and more probable that he was guilty of murder.3 Rule 104(b) addresses a dependency of another kind. The machete and Puck's account carry the jury nowhere until other evidence establishes the fact on which each depends.
Trials add a practical difficulty, because evidence reaches the jury one item at a time.4 Puck must produce evidence of the terms of the offer and also of the identity of the offeror, and one of the two must come first. A judge who ruled on relevance the moment Puck described the offer would have to exclude testimony that the rest of the proof might make relevant, or admit it with nothing yet to support it. Rule 104(b) avoids that dilemma in two ways: it sets a modest standard for the proof of the connecting fact, and it lets the judge admit the item now on the condition that the proof come later.5
Rule 104 as a whole answers three questions about any fact on which admissibility depends: who decides whether the fact has been proved, what burden of proof applies, and what evidence may be used to prove it.6 The subsections below take up the standard and the timing of proof under Rule 104(b), and then show how to tell a Rule 104(b) question from a Rule 104(a) question.
The Sufficiency Standard
When the relevance of evidence depends on whether a fact exists, the proponent must introduce proof “sufficient to support a finding that the fact does exist.”7 The operative words are “support a finding.” A finding is a conclusion about what happened, and the rule reserves that conclusion for the jury. The judge plays a monitoring role and asks only whether the proponent's proof would permit the jury to reach it.8
The measure is a reasonable juror. The judge admits the item if a reasonable juror could find the connecting fact more likely than not, which is the civil preponderance standard applied from the jury's seat and not the judge's own.9 A judge who privately believes the connecting fact probably false must still admit the item when a reasonable person could believe otherwise. The judge cannot pass on the credibility of the foundation testimony. The judge accepts it at face value and asks whether, if the jury believes it, a rational, permissive inference of the connecting fact follows.10
The jury keeps the final word because connecting facts are questions jurors answer all the time. Did A actually make a particular oral statement? Did B sign the letter offered in evidence? The jury's role on the merits would shrink if judges made the final decisions on such questions.11 Deciding them also requires nothing at odds with common sense, so there is every reason to think jurors will do it well.12 The judge still screens, because common sense also counsels against wasting the jury's time unless there is at least some minimal reason to think the connecting fact is true.13
The machete case shows both results. Once the prosecution makes a threshold showing sufficient to allow, though not require, a rational factfinder to conclude that the victim was killed with a machete, the court admits the officer's testimony.14 If the prosecution offers nothing on the point, no reasonable juror could find the connecting fact, and the relevance objection succeeds. The judge need not find the prosecution's showing persuasive, and the defense may answer it with contrary proof; the jury then weighs both sides in deciding whether the condition is met.15
Steps two and three carry the rule's division of labor. The judge considers only evidence the jury will have before it, meaning evidence admitted under the rules of evidence, because the jury makes the ultimate valuation.16 The judge sets credibility aside for the same reason: it belongs to the jury.
Authentication and a witness's personal knowledge are the standing examples. The court resolves an authenticity dispute under a low standard, whether there is sufficient evidence for a juror to find that the item is genuine, and a judge who has doubts still admits the item if a reasonable person could find it genuine.17 A gun found next to a murder victim's body helps resolve the case only if it is the gun used in the crime. The jury decides whether it is, the judge's task is to ensure that a reasonable juror could so conclude, and only in extreme cases does the judge take that decision over.18 Once the proponent makes this minimal prima facie showing, attacks on it are normally matters of weight for the jury.19 The jury makes the real determination whether a witness has personal knowledge or a letter is authentic, and the opponent has no strict right to voir dire the witness on the foundation, although some judges allow it.20
The same standard governs in criminal cases. Proof of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt describes the totality of the evidence and not each item in it, and applying that standard to single items would make convictions virtually impossible.21 The burden of proving a preliminary fact is therefore the same in civil and criminal trials, because Rule 104 decides what the jury may hear and does not decide who is liable or guilty.22
Huddleston v. United States applied this standard to evidence of uncharged misconduct. The Supreme Court treated the question whether the defendant committed the uncharged act as one of relevancy conditioned on fact.23 The proponent therefore need not convince the judge that the act more likely than not occurred; it is enough to present evidence from which some reasonable person could believe that it more likely than not occurred. An eyewitness to the earlier event will ordinarily suffice, even if the judge is not personally convinced that the witness's recollection is accurate.24
After the judge's screen, the real decision moves to the jury. The proponent's proof and the opponent's contrary proof both go to the jury as part of its overall determination of the facts, and the jury may be told to use or ignore the item according to whether it finds the condition fulfilled.25 The judge steps back in only at the extremes: when the foundation is too thin to support a finding, or when all the evidence, including the opponent's, leaves no basis on which a reasonable juror could still find the condition fulfilled. The judge then excludes the item or tells the jury to disregard it.26
Connecting Up
Rule 104(b)'s second sentence addresses timing: the court “may admit the proposed evidence on the condition that the proof be introduced later.”28 If Puck's lawyer assures the judge that he will later produce evidence that the offeror was Dora, the judge may admit the terms of the offer now, conditioned on that assurance.29 Lawyers say the evidence is admitted subject to connecting up, and they call the assurance a promise to connect up the evidence.30
The option exists because the proof cannot all arrive at once. A trial is an evidentiary sequence in which the events portrayed by the evidence unfold one at a time,31 and the witness who supplies the connecting fact may not yet have taken the stand. Conditional admission is a matter of judicial discretion, because the order of proof is largely within the trial judge's discretion.32 A judge who doubts that the promise will be kept may require the connecting evidence first.
The practice reaches any pair of interdependent items. A statement made in the defendant's office matters against him only if he was in the office when it was made or was in a position to hear it. When the relevance of two items is interdependent in this way, the court will admit one on the attorney's promise that the other will be produced.33
The last step has teeth. If Puck never produces evidence that Dora made the offer, his earlier testimony about its terms has nothing to attach to, and on the opponent's motion the judge strikes it and instructs the jury to disregard it.34 The remedy depends on the opponent's asking. When counsel defaults on the promise and the proper motion is made, the court may strike the evidence or declare a mistrial, depending on how serious and how curable the prejudice is.35 In a civil case, the court may order a new trial for an opponent who has been seriously prejudiced.36
A bar answer on this issue follows the same sequence. In one model answer, the examinee notes that the judge may allow the testimony subject to being connected up to other evidence that establishes its relevance, that testimony not ultimately connected up must be stricken, and that the judge's ruling was correct because the testimony was connected up by showing that it went to the defendant Davis's common plan or scheme.37 Your own answer should name the connecting fact, say that the evidence comes in subject to connecting up, and state that a failure to connect up leads to a motion to strike and an instruction to disregard.
Rule 104(a) or 104(b)?
Rules 104(a) and 104(b) both concern facts on which admissibility turns, so a preliminary fact has to be assigned to one of them before anyone can say who decides it. Under Rule 104(a), the court “must decide any preliminary question about whether a witness is qualified, a privilege exists, or evidence is admissible,” and in deciding it is not bound by the evidence rules except those on privilege.39 Under Rule 104(b), the proponent need only introduce proof sufficient to support a finding of the connecting fact, and the jury makes the finding.40
The assignment changes the analysis in three ways. Under Rule 104(a), the judge is the factfinder. The judge decides the preliminary fact by a preponderance of the evidence, in civil and criminal cases alike,41 and may consult inadmissible evidence, except privileged communications.42 Under Rule 104(b), the judge is a monitor. The question is whether a reasonable juror could find the condition more likely than not, and the judge may consider only evidence the jury will have before it.43 The preponderance standard before the judge is therefore the heavier burden for the proponent, and the freedom to use inadmissible evidence belongs to Rule 104(a) alone, because under Rule 104(b) the jury makes the ultimate valuation.44
The division follows function. Rules that exclude relevant evidence rest on policy considerations, and when such a rule turns on a fact, the court decides that fact alone, although the evidence on it may still bear on weight and credibility before the jury. Examples include the qualification of an expert witness, the conditions of a hearsay exception, and the voluntariness of a confession.45 Conditional relevance is different in kind. The condition is a link in the evidence's own logic, and finding it asks jurors to do nothing at odds with common sense.46
In the great majority of cases the two steps produce a clear answer.47
A dying declaration shows the Rule 104(a) side, and it is a good first test because the tempting answer is wrong. In a murder prosecution, the government offers the victim's statement, “Defendant killed me,” which falls within the dying-declaration exception to the hearsay rule only if the victim believed death was imminent when speaking. A student might call that belief a link the jury must find, since the statement seems to matter only if the victim spoke in the shadow of death. The second step corrects the instinct. If the belief were not shown, the statement would still be relevant in a prosecution for the victim's murder, because it still points to the killer. The missing fact is a condition set by the hearsay rule, which excludes relevant evidence, so the judge decides it.48
The machete runs the other way. The officer's testimony is admissible only if the victim was killed with a machete. If that fact were not proved, the testimony would not be relevant at all, so Rule 104(b) controls.49
Authentication and personal knowledge sit on the Rule 104(b) side. In United States v. Sliker, the court called authentication perhaps the purest example of a rule respecting relevance, because evidence admitted as something can have no probative value unless that is what it really is, and it noted that the Advisory Committee's note to Rule 901 places authentication questions under Rule 104(b).50 A witness's personal knowledge follows the same path, and the jury decides whether the witness has it.51 A construction supervisor's shouted warning, offered to show that a delivery driver was contributorily negligent, matters only if the driver heard or should have heard it in time to stop, which is again a link in relevance.52
One item of evidence can raise questions on both sides of the line. When the government offers evidence of an uncharged act, whether the defendant committed it is a question of relevancy conditioned on fact, while the findings concerning identity, intent, and prejudice are preliminary facts for the judge.53 The definitions alone do not sharply separate these applications. The classification rests on function: the jury traditionally decides who the perpetrator was, while the judge decides whether potential prejudice so overbalances probative value that the jury should not hear the evidence at all, and the perpetrator issue became one of conditional relevance primarily because the Supreme Court in Huddleston characterized it that way.54 The judge makes the balancing decision with all the circumstances in view. Major factors counseling against admission include the inflammatory nature of the bad act and its similarity to the charged crime, although no single factor need be decisive.55
Whichever rule governs, Rule 104(e) preserves a party's right to introduce before the jury evidence relevant to the weight or credibility of other evidence.56 The right matters most after a Rule 104(a) ruling. When the judge finds the conditions of a hearsay exception met, the evidence on the preliminary fact still bears on weight and credibility and falls within the jury's province,57 so the opponent may show the jury that the declarant was heavily sedated when speaking. Rule 104(d) adds that a criminal defendant who testifies on a preliminary question does not thereby become subject to cross-examination on other issues in the case.58