Concept
Self-Authentication Under Rule 902
Authentication and identification
Self-Authentication Under Rule 902
Rule 902 shifts the work of authentication from the proponent to the item itself. The items it lists "are self-authenticating; they require no extrinsic evidence of authenticity in order to be admitted."1 Extrinsic evidence is proof from outside the exhibit, such as a witness who saw a document signed or a custodian who explains where it was kept. Under Rule 901(a), the proponent ordinarily must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.2 For an item that Rule 902 names, the exhibit on its face provides its own foundation, so the proponent tenders it and the judge admits it without a sponsoring witness.3
The two rules are built differently, and the difference governs how you use them. Rule 901 offers examples of authentication methods, and a party is not limited to them.4 Rule 902 takes the opposite approach. It supplies a closed list of fourteen categories, and each category has some intrinsic feature that provides the necessary assurance of authenticity.5 A closed list makes sense because the shortcut is safe only where something in the item, or an official's attestation, makes fabrication unlikely. If the list were open, every proponent could argue that an exhibit looks genuine enough to skip the foundation, and Rule 901 would lose its force.
Falling outside the list costs a proponent only the shortcut. In one case, none of the plaintiffs' documents came from official custody or carried an official certification, so none was self-authenticating. The court held that the plaintiffs' failure to procure certified copies did not bar authentication under Rule 901, because the method in Rule 902 is not exclusive.6 The proponent must then lay the ordinary foundation. The law does not presume that such a document is genuine, but the evidence that satisfies Rule 901 may be direct or circumstantial.7
The categories rest on two kinds of assurance, and each explains why a witness becomes unnecessary. The first is official attestation. Many categories describe records and instruments that bear a public seal or an attestation, including a certification, by a public official.8 A seal purporting to be that of the United States, a state, or a political subdivision of either is one example.9 A document accompanied by a certificate of acknowledgment lawfully executed by a notary public or another officer authorized to take acknowledgments is another.10 The second kind of assurance is a low risk of forgery combined with easy verification. Newspapers and trade inscriptions carry little risk of forgery or alteration, and an interested party can usually confirm genuineness or reveal falsity with little effort. An article falsely claimed to come from the January 12, 2018 edition of the New York Times, for example, would be exposed as a forgery by anyone who checked that edition.11
The boundary of the list matters most when a proponent asks Rule 902 to do more than it says. A court considering a social-media profile page observed that none of the enumerated categories, which include certain public records, periodicals, and business records, applied to that page.12 The page therefore received no shortcut and needed extrinsic proof of authenticity. An item does not join a category by resembling one of its members. A page that looks like a periodical is not a periodical for Rule 902 purposes.
The sections that follow walk through the categories in rule order. The last two categories were added in 2017: Rule 902(13) covers certified records generated by an electronic process or system, and Rule 902(14) covers certified data copied from an electronic device, storage medium, or file. Those amendments follow the 2000 amendment for business records, which lets a qualified witness's certification establish authenticity. The aim is to lower the cost of authenticating electronic evidence, because the authenticating witness need not be produced at trial.13
Self-authentication has a ceiling. It means only that the item can be admitted and considered by the jury. It does not bar the opponent from offering counterproof on authenticity or from arguing that the item deserves little or no weight.14
The same limit reaches the contents of a self-authenticating item. Self-authentication does not resolve questions about the source or accuracy of the information a document reports, so an objection that a newspaper or periodical contains inadmissible hearsay or expert opinion remains available.15 Authentication is one gate among several that a document must pass, and the final section of this chapter returns to the others.