Concept
The Propensity Bar
Admissibility of character
Admissibility of Character Evidence
The Propensity Bar
Rule 404(a)(1) bars one inference: that because a person has a certain character or character trait, the person acted in accordance with it on a particular occasion.1 The rule does not ban character evidence outright. It bars character evidence offered for that purpose, and evidence of specific acts is not barred by Rule 404 when offered to prove something besides a person's character.2
People draw this inference constantly outside the courtroom, and with good sense. An employer choosing a new hire, a lender deciding whether to make a loan, a sports executive weighing a trade, and a bar's character and fitness committee all rely on appraisals of character.3 Coworkers hunting for whoever took a lunch from the break-room refrigerator look first at the colleague already caught taking other people's food.4 Each reasons that a person with a particular trait is more likely to act in line with it, and parties in civil and criminal trials frequently want to bring that same reasoning into court.5
The rule depends on a precise vocabulary. Character is a person's disposition generally, or toward a particular trait such as peacefulness or truthfulness.6 Reputation is the community's estimate of the person, and it is a method of proving character rather than character itself.7 A single trait can be shown by several routes. A lender called a "usurious cheat" might face a witness to his reputation for exorbitant rates, former employees who give their opinion that he is dishonest, and borrowers who describe particular loans on which he misstated the interest.8 Using proof of a trait to establish conduct on a particular occasion is the propensity argument, which treats character as substantive evidence.9
The inference the rule blocks
A defendant on trial for robbing a liquor store has robbed gas stations several times before and has a reputation as a thief.10 The prosecution wants the jury to hear both, and its argument runs through three links:
- The defendant robbed gas stations before, or is known in the community as a thief.
- Those facts show that he is a thieving type of person.
- A thieving type of person is more likely to have robbed this liquor store.
The middle link does the work. It turns past facts into a conclusion about what kind of person he is, and the last link turns that conclusion into a conclusion about what he did on this occasion.11 Rule 404(a)(1) rejects that line of analysis, so the reputation and the earlier robberies are equally barred when offered to support it.12
Why the law excludes relevant evidence
Irrelevance is not the objection. Whether a person is careful or reckless, even-tempered or short-tempered, honest or dishonest may bear directly on a claim or defense. The danger lies in what a jury may do with the information: it may decide the case is about the prior incident, or conclude that a party is so bad that punishment should follow whatever the merits. The Federal Rules respond by significantly limiting the availability of character evidence.13
Against that danger, the evidence offers little. Character is multidimensional and means different things to different people, so gas station robberies may not show a thieving type at all (if there is such a type), and reputation evidence invites a similarly wide range of readings.14 Even a real trait is hard to measure, because it is hard to know how deep it runs or what it says about a person at the crucial moment.15
The costs are collateral issues, consumed time, and unfair prejudice, and prejudice carries particular weight.16 In Old Chief v. United States, the Court described unfair prejudice as an undue tendency to suggest decision on an improper basis. It named as an improper basis the generalizing of a defendant's earlier bad act into bad character, taken as raising the odds that he committed the act now charged or as calling for preventive conviction even if he is innocent.17 A juror who learns that the defendant has robbed before may turn against him and convict on a weak case. That juror may reason that a mistaken conviction will not blemish an already tarnished record.18
Good character falls under the same bar
The bar protects good character as firmly as bad. Character evidence, the Advisory Committee's note to Rule 404(a) observes, subtly permits the trier of fact "to reward the good man and to punish the bad man because of their respective characters despite what evidence in the case shows actually happened."19
A surgeon sued for malpractice shows the point. She offers a near-perfect record in earlier operations to prove she took reasonable care in this one. The record may make her an appealing choice for a future patient, but the lawsuit asks about one operation. Evidence that a surgeon usually meets the standard of care is beside the point, just as evidence of mistakes on other patients would not establish carelessness in the operation at issue.20
What the bar leaves open
The bar applies in civil and criminal cases alike.22 Rule 404 looks like a blanket prohibition but carries exceptions, which the following sections develop.23 Rules 413, 414, and 415 depart from the general bar in sexual-offense civil and criminal cases. They permit evidence of a defendant's past sex offense to support an inference that the defendant committed another offense of that type.24
Because the bar targets an inference and does not forbid a topic, the same facts may come in when the proponent has a different use for them. Rule 404(b)(2) provides that evidence of other acts may be admissible for another purpose, such as proving motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake, or lack of accident.25 Proof of a trait can also be the very point of the case. A defendant who pleads truth against a claim of defamation, as in the "usurious cheat" example above, offers reputation, opinion, and specific events to show that the plaintiff really is dishonest.26
On any character problem, the first question is what the evidence is offered to prove. If the answer is that the person is the sort who would do such a thing and therefore probably did it this time, Rule 404(a)(1) controls.28