Concept
Analyzing a Character Problem
Admissibility of character
Analyzing a Character Problem
Every character problem begins with Rule 404(a)(1): evidence of a person's character or character trait is not admissible to prove that on a particular occasion the person acted in accordance with the character or trait.1 The rule shuts one door and leaves the others open, so the first job on an exam stem is to find the use the proponent has in mind. A stem that merely mentions a trait has not yet raised the rule. The exceptions that relax the bar are narrow and defined, and the earlier sections taught each of them along with the settings the bar never reaches. The task here is to put those lessons in an order you can run under time pressure, because each question narrows the field for the next and a wrong turn early produces a wrong exception later.
The first two questions come first because the bar targets an inference, not a subject. The forbidden chain has a middle link, a conclusion about the sort of person someone is, and that link carries the jury to a conclusion about what the person did.9 Evidence that reaches its point without that link raises none of those concerns. A trait the law makes an element, an act offered for another purpose, a habit, and a witness's character each follow their own rules and need no Rule 404(a)(2) exception. A student who runs such evidence through the criminal exceptions analyzes a rule that does not apply. The logic also cuts the other way: when the only route from the evidence to the verdict is the bad-type conclusion, a respectable label such as intent or identity does not change the answer.
Questions three and four govern propensity offers, and they decide most of them. The propensity inference has many shortcomings, yet the law has grown to tolerate it in many instances,10 and in a criminal case that tolerance takes a defined shape: the defendant may offer evidence of a pertinent trait, and the prosecution answers only if that evidence is admitted.11 A civil party who offers an earlier lapse, or a reputation for carelessness, to prove conduct on the day in question has no exception to invoke. The homicide case is the one place where the prosecution need not wait for character evidence from the defense. The text of subparagraph (C) requires only evidence that the victim was the first aggressor, and it permits the prosecution to respond with the victim's trait of peacefulness.12
Question five is where students most often confuse the triggers, because each exception has its own. Under subparagraph (A), once the defendant's evidence of the defendant's own pertinent trait is admitted, the prosecution may offer evidence to rebut it.13 Under subparagraph (B), once the defendant's evidence of the alleged victim's pertinent trait is admitted, the prosecution may both rebut it and offer evidence of the defendant's same trait, and the second response is available even though the defendant said nothing about himself.14 Under subparagraph (C), the charge must be homicide, and the response is limited to the victim's peacefulness.15 A defendant's testimony that he knew of the victim's violent reputation, offered to explain why he feared the victim, does not ask the jury to infer the victim's conduct from the victim's trait. It never reaches the propensity step, so subparagraph (B) is not involved and none of its responses is triggered.
The last two questions do not decide whether an exception applies. They decide how the evidence may come in and whether a separate rule overrides the earlier answer. The permitted form of proof differs from setting to setting. Where a person's character is an ultimate issue, every method is permitted, and when a witness gives reputation or opinion testimony, the opposing party may question that witness about specific acts the subject is believed to have committed.16 The sexual-misconduct rules can then change the result. Rule 412 specifically prohibits proof about the character of an alleged victim of a sex crime, and subparagraph (B) is expressly subject to it, so a defendant's pertinent-trait offer about such a victim must clear Rule 412 first.17 Rules 413 through 415 supply separate rules for a civil or criminal defendant accused of sexual assault or child molestation.18
Both of those stems ended early, which is the usual fate of a failing offer: the analysis stops at the first question the proponent cannot answer. A passing offer, like the one in the David and Goliath stem, must answer every question in turn, and each answer fixes the question that follows. When a stem seems to offer several kinds of character evidence, take the items one at a time, because a single trial can contain a propensity offer that fails, a habit offer that succeeds, and a witness-character offer that follows its own rules.