Concept
Proof on Direct Examination
Methods of proving character
Proof on Direct Examination
Rule 404 decides whether a party may use character evidence at all; the first sentence of Rule 405(a) decides how the party must prove it. When evidence of a person's character or character trait is admissible, it may be proved by testimony about the person's reputation or by testimony in the form of an opinion.1 The rule names two forms for circumstantial use of character, and its silence about a third is what gives the sentence its force. Reputation and opinion testimony take little time to present, while proof by specific instances is usually time-consuming and distracting, and for that reason is normally rejected.2
An attorney who wants to offer propensity evidence can run two checks before calling the witness: whether the trait is specific enough to be legally pertinent, and whether the proof takes a legally proper form, meaning opinion, reputation, or specific instances.3 Rule 404 governs the first check. This unit covers the second, beginning with reputation, then opinion, and ending with the exclusion of specific acts. Two further pieces of Rule 405 fall outside it. The rule's second sentence lets the court allow cross-examination of a character witness about relevant specific instances,4 and subdivision (b) allows specific instances when character is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense.5 Later sections of this chapter take up both.
Reputation Testimony
A reputation witness tells the jury what a group of people says about a person's trait, such as honesty or peacefulness. Rule 405(a) permits that testimony whenever the trait is admissible,6 and before the Federal Rules it was the only form a party could use to prove character as circumstantial evidence of conduct on a particular occasion.7 The witness reports the group's view and offers no view of her own. A personal judgment is a different form, opinion, which the next section covers.
Because the witness repeats what other people say, reputation testimony raises a hearsay problem, and the law answers it with an exception: Rule 803(21) admits reputation among associates or in the community when it is used to establish character.8 That exception deals only with hearsay. Rule 405 still decides which forms of character proof are allowed, and the witness must still know enough to give the testimony.
The proponent therefore begins with a foundation. The reputation witness must be familiar with the subject's reputation in a setting, such as the subject's community or work environment, that is communal enough for a reputation to develop, and the lawyer must elicit that familiarity before the witness describes the reputation itself.9 Courts normally look for a witness and a subject who lived or did business in reasonable proximity for a substantial period in the fairly recent past, and for a reputation that is the one held in that community and is relatively current.10 Once that showing appears, weaknesses in how much the witness was exposed to go to weight, which the jury evaluates, and not to admissibility, which the judge decides.11
The group need not be a residential neighborhood. The reputation may be the one in the neighborhood where the person lives or among any group of his associates, so long as the witness establishes familiarity with it.12 A coworker who sees the person every day can report what the office thinks of him. See United States v. Parker (workplace reputation). Membership in the group is what the foundation tests. United States v. Perry (2d Cir.) excluded testimony by a private investigator hired by the defendant's wife.13 An investigator engaged for the case stands outside the community whose view the testimony is supposed to report, while a coworker stands inside it.
The reputation must also concern the pertinent trait. A general reputation for being law abiding will not do unless the nature of the offense leaves no more specific trait available: honesty is the pertinent trait when the charge is larceny or theft, while being law abiding is permitted when the charge is narcotics possession.14
A good reputation seldom generates conversation, so a witness who has heard no discussion of the trait is not barred from testifying to it.15 The silence has value only if the witness was placed to hear talk had there been any. A bookkeeper who has spent six years among a firm's staff and never heard a word against a colleague's honesty speaks for the group; a guest who met the same staff once at a holiday party speaks only for her own ignorance.
Timing is the last condition. The testimony must relate to reputation at the time of the act in question rather than at trial.16 Circumstantial character proof asks how the person was disposed when the charged events occurred, and talk that began after the charge became public tends to reflect the accusation. The Third Circuit accordingly answered no when asked whether a prosecutor may ask a character witness about the defendant's reputation after the crime was committed. See United States v. Curtis.17
Opinion Testimony
Opinion is the second form Rule 405(a) allows: when evidence of character is admissible, it may be proved by testimony in the form of an opinion.19 The opinion witness reports no one else's view. She gives a personal judgment, formed from her own dealings with the person, that he is honest, peaceable, or law abiding. A reputation witness says the defendant is known as honest; an opinion witness says that, after years beside him, she finds him honest. The two answers sound alike and rest on different foundations, so a witness who answers a reputation question with a personal impression has switched forms without announcing it.
Opinion marks a departure from older practice. The common law tradition allowed only reputation when character was offered as circumstantial evidence of conduct on a particular occasion,20 and Wigmore objected that the rules of evidence had excluded the person who knows as much as humanly can be known about another's character while admitting the “second-hand, irresponsible product of multiplied guesses and gossip which we term ‘reputation.’”21 The Advisory Committee accepted the point: in recognizing opinion, the rule departs from usual contemporary practice in favor of that of an earlier day.22 The change was controversial. The House Judiciary Committee initially rejected the proposal, and after debate the Advisory Committee language was restored by floor amendment.23
The Advisory Committee suspected that reputation evidence survived because it is largely opinion in disguise.24 If that is right, a reputation-only rule invites witnesses to present a private view as community consensus. Opinion lets the witness say what she thinks, and it lets the cross-examiner explore the bases of that opinion.25
Because an opinion is worth only what the witness's acquaintance makes it worth, the foundation asks about the acquaintance. The opinion witness must be sufficiently acquainted with the subject to form a well-founded opinion.26 Courts usually express the requirement as substantial recent contact or a relationship that furnishes a reasonable basis for a current opinion, with “recent” measured against the act the propensity is offered to prove.27 Once that threshold is met, remaining weaknesses go to weight.28
Because the two forms rest on different sources, they can point in different directions. One federal opinion explains that under the rule, which changed prior law, a defendant whose community reputation is bad may still produce opinion evidence, based on personal observation and close association, that his character is good.29 A friend's opinion depends on what the friend has seen, so the neighbors' view neither supplies nor defeats the foundation. At the ordinary end of the range, a coworker who has worked beside a theft defendant daily for five years may testify that in her judgment he is an honest person, since honesty is the pertinent trait for theft and five years of daily contact supplies the basis.30
Whether an expert such as a psychiatrist may give the opinion is less settled. The Advisory Committee's Note says that where a pertinent character trait is involved, the opinion of a psychiatrist based on examination is permissible under Rule 405(a).31 The Note adds that no effective dividing line exists between character and mental capacity, which has traditionally been provable by opinion.32 One court reads the rule as now allowing expert testimony on traits of character that may be substantively relevant.33 Courts nonetheless divide in application. United States v. MacDonald (4th Cir. 1982) excluded psychiatric testimony that the defendant's “personality configuration” was inconsistent with “outrageous and senseless murders,” while in United States v. Staggs (7th Cir. 1977), a trial for armed threats against an official, the court found error in excluding a psychologist's testimony that the defendant was “more likely to hurt himself than to direct his aggression toward others,” and reversed.34 On an exam, treat expert character opinion as an open question: the rule's text does not forbid it, but results vary.
A witness who speaks for herself invites questions about what she has seen. On cross-examination the opposing party may explore the bases of an opinion,35 and under the second sentence of Rule 405(a) may ask the opinion witness whether she knows of relevant specific instances, where a reputation witness would be asked whether she has heard of them.36 A later section takes up how far that inquiry may go.
Specific Acts Excluded
Specific acts of conduct stay out of direct examination whenever character is offered circumstantially. Rule 405(a) does not say so in terms; the exclusion follows from a list that names reputation and opinion and stops there.38 The Advisory Committee explained why. Of the three methods of proving character, specific instances are the most convincing, and they also have the greatest capacity to arouse prejudice, to confuse, to surprise, and to consume time. The rule therefore confines them to cases in which character is in issue in the strict sense, and when character is used circumstantially, proof may be only by reputation and opinion.39
The restriction binds a defendant's own favorable evidence. A defendant may offer reputation or opinion evidence of a pertinent trait inconsistent with the charged crime under Rule 404(a)(2)(A), but not specific instances.40 A burglary defendant who puts honesty in play may call one witness to describe his reputation among his neighbors and another to give an opinion after five years of acquaintance. A third witness who says he coached youth soccer for years, never missed a practice, and handled the league's dues without an accounting problem is proving honesty through events. The trait is a permissible subject, and the form is the defect.41
The bar yields only when character itself is the fact to be decided. When a person's character or character trait is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense, it may also be proved by relevant specific instances of the person's conduct.42 If a defendant in a defamation action pleads that the statement calling the plaintiff a thief was true, the plaintiff's honesty is the fact in dispute, and the defense may use reputation, opinion, or specific instances, because a fact that important should be provable in any probative way.43 The burglary defendant's honesty, by contrast, is only circumstantial evidence that no burglary occurred, so the same trait calls for narrower proof.
The two checks from the start of this unit give a sequence for ruling on any answer offered on direct examination.
The bar produces an asymmetry that the law tolerates. A defendant must prove character by reputation or opinion rather than by specific past conduct, but the prosecutor may bring in the defendant's past conduct by asking the defendant's character witnesses about it.45 In Michelson v. United States the Supreme Court called these rules “archaic, paradoxical, and full of compromises and compensations by which an irrational advantage to one side is offset by a poorly reasoned counter-privilege to the other.”46