Concept
Methods in Criminal Cases
Methods of proving character
Methods in Criminal Cases
Rule 404(a)(2) decides whose character a criminal jury may hear about, and Rule 405 decides how the jury hears about it. This unit takes up the second question and assumes the first has an answer: the accused has offered a pertinent trait of his own or of the alleged victim, or the prosecution is responding to such an offer. Rule 405(a) then supplies the forms of proof. When evidence of a person's character or character trait is admissible, it may be proved by testimony about the person's reputation or by testimony in the form of an opinion, and on cross-examination of the character witness the court may allow an inquiry into relevant specific instances of the person's conduct.1
One form rule governs every setting in a criminal case: the accused offers his own trait, the accused offers the victim's trait, or the prosecution rebuts. On direct examination the character witness gives reputation or opinion. Specific instances reach the jury only when the opponent asks about them on cross-examination. Rule 405(b), which adds proof by specific instances, applies when character is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense,2 and the ordinary criminal case is not one of those. There character serves circumstantially, as a basis for inferring conduct, and circumstantial use limits proof to reputation and opinion.3
The limit exists because reputation and opinion take little time to present, while proof by specific instances is usually time-consuming and distracting.4 That reason applies equally to the accused and the victim, so the forms never change. What changes from one setting to the next is the pertinent trait, who may raise it first, and what the opponent may do in response. The accused's character comes first below, and the victim's follows.
The Defendant's Character
A criminal defendant may offer evidence of his pertinent trait, and if the evidence is admitted, the prosecutor may offer evidence to rebut it.5 He may do so whether or not he testifies. Testifying exposes him to impeachment of his character for truthfulness under Rules 607, 608, and 609, but that exposure does not put his character in issue.6
The defendant's option rests on a propensity inference: a person of good character probably did not commit this crime. That inference is analytically identical to the one the rules ordinarily prohibit. The rules tolerate it here because the defendant controls whether it is used, which reflects the system's interest in giving defendants ample opportunity to protect themselves from conviction.7 The same control explains why the prosecution cannot go first. By longstanding tradition, the unfair prejudice of portraying the accused as a 'bad man' is felt to outweigh any probative value the evidence might have in the case in chief.8 Courts sometimes call the defendant's option the 'mercy rule.'9
The trait must be pertinent, meaning that it would make the charged conduct less likely. A trait that is not inconsistent with the crime charged has no probative value to show that the accused did not commit it.10 Rule 404(a)(2)(A) therefore admits the defendant's traits that are inconsistent with commission of the charged crime.11 In a prosecution for aggravated assault, for example, the defendant may not offer his honesty, because honesty is not a 'pertinent' trait where the charge is violence.12 Courts also want the trait matched to the offense. Reputation or opinion that the defendant is law abiding is too general unless no more specific trait is available, so honesty fits a larceny or theft charge, and being law abiding is allowed for narcotics possession.13
Form and pertinence are separate tests, and the assault witness passes one while failing the other. Once the trait is pertinent, the defendant must prove it by reputation or opinion, not by specific instances of past conduct.14 A reputation witness may speak to the defendant's reputation in his neighborhood or among any group of his associates, but must first establish familiarity with it. Opinion may come from a psychiatrist whose view rests on examination or testimony, and it may come from the defendant himself.15 What no witness may do is tell a story. Evidence of a specific prior instance in which the defendant acted in conformity with the trait is impermissible under Rule 405(a), whoever offers it.16
Offering his own good character does not put the defendant's character in issue in the sense Rule 405(b) uses. That subdivision applies when character is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense.17 An accused who offers his good name is using it circumstantially, to support an inference about what he did, and circumstantial use confines proof to reputation and opinion.18 The offer opens the door to the limited response described next and no further.
Once the defense evidence is in, the prosecution has two responses. It may cross-examine the defense character witnesses rigorously, and it may call its own character witnesses who offer a different view of the trait. If the defense witnesses described a peaceful, nonviolent man, the prosecution's witnesses may describe a violent and bellicose one.19 Rebuttal witnesses face the same limits as the defense witnesses: character evidence offered in the form of reputation or opinion may be rebutted by other witnesses only in the form of reputation or opinion.20 The rebuttal also stays on the trait the defendant raised, because the prosecution answers with evidence of the same trait.21
Cross-examination is the one route by which specific acts reach the jury. The prosecutor may ask the defendant's character witnesses whether they have heard or know about specific past actions by the defendant.22 Each question tests the witness. A witness unfamiliar with a relevant act may have a weak basis for her testimony, and a witness who knows of the act and still praises the defendant reveals her standard of 'goodness' and 'badness.' The cross-examiner needs a good-faith basis for the inquiry, and the court may require counsel to disclose that basis outside the jury's presence before the questioning begins.23 The limits on cross-examination of character witnesses, covered above, govern every question.
The resulting pattern troubled the Supreme Court. In Michelson it called these rules "archaic, paradoxical, and full of compromises and compensations by which an irrational advantage to one side is offset by a poorly reasoned counter-privilege to the other."24 The paradox is concrete: the defendant may not prove his good acts, yet the prosecutor may ask about his bad ones. The pattern is easier to hold once you see that the defendant opened the door and the prosecutor's access runs through his witnesses.
One body of law sits outside this pattern. Rules 413 and 414 create exceptions that govern the character of an accused charged with sexual assault or child molestation, and the rules above are subject to them.25 A later section of this chapter takes them up.
The Victim's Character
Rule 405(a) speaks of a person's character, so the same two forms govern the alleged victim. The gate is Rule 404(a)(2)(B): subject to the limitations in Rule 412, a defendant may offer evidence of an alleged victim's pertinent trait, and if the evidence is admitted, the prosecutor may offer evidence to rebut it and may offer evidence of the defendant's same trait.28
The classic use is a homicide defense. The defendant may show, by reputation or opinion testimony, that the deceased was a violent and dangerous person, with the suggested inference that the deceased was more probably the aggressor. The evidence is admissible through another witness whether or not the defendant knew of the reputation.29 The victim's trait is circumstantial evidence, so the forms are the ones that govern the defendant's own character. Evidence of specific acts is not admissible to show the victim's character, and proof must be by reputation or opinion.30
Defendants sometimes argue that self-defense puts the victim's character in issue, so that Rule 405(b) opens the door to the victim's specific acts. State v. Hutchinson shows why the argument fails. The defendant there was tried for murder and claimed self-defense, and the court allowed him only opinion or reputation evidence on the victim's character.31 Rule 405(b) applies when character is an essential element of a charge, claim, or defense,32 and in a self-defense case the victim's trait is circumstantial evidence on who was the aggressor.33
Evidence about the victim's trait opens three doors for the prosecution, and each has its own trigger. The first is ordinary rebuttal. When the defense offers the victim's pertinent trait, the prosecution may offer evidence to rebut it,34 typically witnesses who portray the victim as nonviolent and peaceable.35 Those witnesses use the same forms as the defense witnesses, reputation or opinion,36 and under the second sentence of Rule 405(a) the court may allow cross-examination of a character witness about relevant specific instances of the person's conduct.37
The second door lets the prosecution turn to the defendant. When the accused's evidence of the victim's trait is admitted under Rule 404(a)(2)(B), the prosecution may offer evidence of the accused's same trait,38 because a defendant may not attack the victim's character and stay shielded from equally relevant evidence about the same trait in himself.39 The victim-trait evidence is the trigger, so the defendant need not have offered anything about his own character. Rule 405 still controls the form, and the prosecution's proof about the defendant is reputation or opinion.40 The door does not swing the other way. A defendant who offers evidence of his own character alone permits rebuttal about himself, but not character evidence about the victim, because he has not opened the door to the victim's character.41
The third door opens only in homicide prosecutions. If the defendant offers evidence that the victim was the first aggressor, whether or not the evidence uses opinion or reputation testimony, Rule 404(a)(2)(C) lets the prosecution offer reputation or opinion testimony that the victim was peaceable. The jury then has evidence about both the defendant and the victim for an informed assessment of who was the first aggressor.42
The victim's violent history has a second use that does not depend on the propensity inference. A defendant who claims he reasonably feared the victim may show what he knew about the victim's violence, because his knowledge of that trait is a factor in deciding whether he reasonably apprehended bodily harm.43 In United States v. Burks, the victim's violent acts were admissible, if the defendant knew of them, on the question whether he reasonably feared imminent great bodily injury, and the case invites the question whether Rules 404 and 405 even apply to that use.44 An act the defendant never heard about could not have shaped his fear, so only the acts he knew of matter. The victim's threats against the defendant follow similar logic. In Torres v. State, threats to harm the defendant were not excludable as character evidence, because they shed direct light on the victim's intent and so on the affray in issue.45
Rule 404(a)(2)(B) is expressly subject to Rule 412, so evidence otherwise admissible under Rule 404(a)(2) may nevertheless be excluded in a criminal case involving sexual misconduct.46 A later section takes up Rule 412.