Concept
The Gatekeeping Duty
Reliability and relevancy
The Gatekeeping Duty
Rule 702 allows a witness qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education to testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise only if the proponent demonstrates to the court that it is more likely than not that the rule's further conditions are met.1 Because the proponent makes that showing to the court, the judge decides whether it succeeds. The Federal Rules of Evidence make that decision one of the judge's "gatekeeper" duties: determining whether particular expert testimony is reliable and will assist the trier of fact.2 The 2000 amendment rewrote the rule to capture more accurately the approach of Daubert and Kumho Tire, so the gatekeeper's questions now appear in the rule's own text.3
Expert testimony helps a jury and can also mislead it. Experts deal with esoteric and complex matters, so jurors may be unable to evaluate their testimony critically. Where professional witnesses' opinions can be bought in virtually every field of science and technology, unquestioning deference may seriously jeopardize accurate fact-finding. Rule 702 reduces that danger by limiting what experts may say.4
Credentials do not answer the danger. The rules give experts wide latitude in their testimony, which is why standards of reliability are needed: it is not enough that a witness has credentials and qualifies as an expert, or that the adversary process can test what the witness says.5 The Daubert plaintiffs illustrate the point. They offered eight experts, each with impressive credentials, who concluded that Bendectin can cause birth defects. Those conclusions rested on test-tube and live-animal studies, on pharmacological studies of Bendectin's chemical structure, and on reanalysis of previously published epidemiological studies.6 The résumés qualified the witnesses. Whether those foundations supported the conclusions was a separate question, and the gatekeeper has to answer it.
The five findings fall into two groups, relevancy and reliability. Helpfulness is the relevancy condition: the testimony must be relevant to the task at hand, meaning that it logically advances a material aspect of the proponent's case, a requirement Daubert called "fit."12 Sufficient facts or data, reliable principles and methods, and reliable application are the three new requirements in the amended rule. Daubert and Kumho Tire supply ways to show that those requirements are satisfied. Their factors are strongly advised, but other ways exist if they do not flout those decisions, which are flexible by their own terms. Purportedly scientific experts must meet a somewhat higher standard than other experts.13 The sections that follow take the conditions in turn, beginning with reliable methods, and a later section addresses the proponent's burden.
Frye let a judge stay out of scientific disputes. She could exclude proof only because other scientists did not accept it, and she could tell the expert that the verdict of other scientists, not her own opinion, counted.14 Gatekeeping asks more. Under Frye the judge's task was relatively simple: decide whether the method was generally accepted in the scientific community. Under Daubert, one federal court explained, the judge must engage in a two-part analysis. The first part asks whether the testimony reflects scientific knowledge derived by the scientific method and amounts to good science, and the second asks whether it is relevant to the task at hand.15 The expert's own word cannot satisfy the first part. A bald assurance of validity is not enough, and the proponent must show sound science through some objective, independent validation of the expert's methodology.16
The opinions in these cases dispute how far the job extends, not whether it exists. Even the separate opinion in Daubert that would have decided far less accepted that Rule 702 gives the judge some gatekeeping responsibility, while denying that the rule makes judges amateur scientists.17 Justice Breyer, concurring in Joiner, added that a judge's comparative lack of expertise cannot excuse the gatekeeper duties, and that when law and science intersect the judge must exercise them with special care.18
Judges do not work alone. They can hold a Daubert hearing outside the jury's presence to consider data and arguments for and against admissibility. When each side's partisan experts reach completely different conclusions, they can invoke Rule 706 and select a court-appointed expert.19 The responsibility remains heavy, because an appellate court sustains the ruling unless the judge abused discretion.20 Rule 702 is also not the judge's only screen. Testimony that passes it remains subject to Rule 403, under which the judge asks whether its probative value is substantially outweighed by risks of prejudice, confusion, or waste of time.21
An exam question will often pair an impressive résumé with a doubtful opinion. The résumé answers only the first finding. Move on to the other four.
The first chemist's opinion satisfies every finding: her specialty qualifies her, the cause of the peeling is a fact in issue, she tested the actual material, her method is sound, and she applied it to this wall. The psychic fails the methods finding. Whatever his credentials, his bald assurance of validity is not enough, and no objective, independent validation exists.22 In the third case the method stays sound but its application does not. An opinion built on another building's bricks does not reflect a reliable application of the method to the facts of this case, and the final finding keeps it out.