Concept
Burden and Standard of Proof
Reliability and relevancy
Burden and Standard of Proof
Rule 702 answers who must prove admissibility, to whom, and how convincingly in one opening clause: a qualified expert may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise only “if the proponent demonstrates to the court that it is more likely than not” that the listed conditions are met.1 That clause makes three assignments. The burden falls on the proponent, the side offering the expert. The audience is the court, so the judge and not the jury must be persuaded. The measure is more likely than not, the ordinary preponderance standard. Each assignment is taken in turn below, followed by how a judge resolves a contested showing in practice.
The Proponent's Burden
The side that offers an expert must prove the testimony deserves to be heard, and the opponent need not prove that it does not. The allocation follows from the gatekeeping role: the judge must determine whether the expert's methodology is actually reliable, and the proponent must prove that reliability by a preponderance of the evidence.2 Daubert said so explicitly. The trial court must find that the expert used a methodology that is more likely than not reliable, and that the expert more likely than not applied it reliably.3
The standard governs every condition that follows the rule's lead-in. Those conditions include sufficient facts or data, testimony that is the product of reliable principles and methods, and an opinion that reflects a reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case.4 The terms themselves (sufficient, reliable, reliably) are unquantified, and the rule does not say how sufficient or how reliable or how either is to be measured. That leaves much to the judgment of the court.5 The preponderance standard therefore tells the judge how sure to be about a finding, and it does not define what the finding must contain.
A preponderance also falls short of perfection. The proponent need not show that the work was flawless or that the conclusion is right. Contrary evidence and careful instruction on the burden of proof remain the traditional means of attacking shaky but admissible evidence.6
The pair shows that the burden attaches to each opinion and to each fact on which that opinion depends. A court may admit part of an expert's testimony and refuse the rest, because the question is whether the proponent has shown it more likely than not that this particular opinion rests on a sound basis.
Preliminary Question for the Judge
Because the showing is made “to the court,” each Rule 702 condition is a preliminary question of admissibility. The judge decides it under Rule 104(a), and the jury does not decide it under Rule 104(b). The conditions read as specifications of admissibility, which are for judges to apply under Rule 104(a).8 The judge's resolution is also hard to disturb, since it is sustained on appeal unless she abused her discretion.9
The two subsections apply very different screens. Rule 104(b) asks only whether there is evidence sufficient to support a finding that a fact exists, and the jury then resolves the fact. Rule 104(a) asks the judge to find the fact herself, and Rule 702 sets the level of that finding at a preponderance. A Rule 104(b) approach would send to the jury any opinion whose assumed facts had some support. The jurors would then decide whether the basis was sufficient and the method reliably applied, which are the questions gatekeeping assigns to the judge first. The judge must decide whether the methodology is actually reliable before the jury hears the opinion.10
This point once divided courts. Lawyers asked whether proper performance of protocols goes to admissibility or only to the weight of the evidence, as a number of earlier cases had treated it.11 Decisions made before the amendment split on related questions.12 If the rule adds requirements, they apply, because the Federal Rules have statutory force and came later.13 The lead-in now requires the proponent to demonstrate each condition to the court by a preponderance,14 so a court cannot pass sufficiency of basis or reliable application to the jury as mere weight before making that finding itself.
A finding that a requirement is met does not end the dispute. It moves what remains to the jury. The same issues often bear on weight, so the jury can take another look at them, and the opponent may keep attacking the admitted testimony with contrary evidence and instruction on the burden of proof.15
A typical exam stem has the opponent complaining that the expert assumed a pressure reading the records do not clearly support, and asks whether the complaint goes to weight or to admissibility. The answer turns on the judge's finding. If the reading is essential to the opinion and the proponent has not shown it more likely than not to be accurate, the opinion is excluded. If the judge finds the reading more likely than not accurate, the remaining quarrel about it goes to weight. The usual error is to apply the Rule 104(b) test, whether there is evidence sufficient to support a finding, in place of the judge's own preponderance finding.
Daubert Hearings in Practice
The usual vehicle for the judge's decision is the Daubert hearing, a proceeding outside the jury's presence, usually before trial, in which the judge considers data and arguments for and against admissibility.17 It begins when an attorney objects that the testimony rests on unreliable scientific principles or techniques and asks for a hearing. Under Frye the only issue was general acceptance. Under Daubert the judge considers all the evidence that sheds light on reliability, including whether the principle underlying the testimony has been tested by the scientific method.18 At the hearing the proponent must show that the expert's reasoning or methodology and its application to the facts are valid, which is the burden described above in procedural form.19 In most cases the expert's qualifications are not challenged, so the contest usually concerns the basis and method of the opinion.20
One opinion describes the sequence in more detail. A proponent who offers the testimony and makes an initial showing that it derives from a reliable method has made a prima facie case of admissibility. The opponent may answer with evidence, including expert testimony, that the method was unsound or that the expert failed to follow an otherwise sound protocol. When that answer raises a material dispute about admissibility, the court must hold an in limine hearing to consider the conflicting evidence and make findings about the soundness and reliability of the methodology.21 The opponent's contrary evidence is what turns an objection into a dispute the judge must resolve, and the burden of persuasion stays with the proponent. If the experts on each side reach completely different conclusions, the judge may also invoke Rule 706 and select a court-appointed expert.22
The duty to hold a hearing is triggered by a material dispute, and courts are less settled about the form the hearing takes. The nature of a Rule 104(a) in limine hearing, when it may be referred to a magistrate for fact-finding, and how often the court appoints independent experts to aid it are open questions in many courts, and decisions are mixed.23 Where the written record already resolves the dispute, whether to take live testimony is normally for the trial judge, and an extensive pretrial record of expert reports, depositions, supporting literature, and briefs may make a live hearing unnecessary.24 That discretion has limits. The Tenth Circuit in Hoffman suggested that declining a hearing may be an abuse of discretion when admissibility turns on factual issues and will determine the outcome of summary judgment. What a court may not do is skip the reliability determination itself. In United States v. Charley, the Tenth Circuit held it error, though harmless, to permit an unconditional opinion without making one.
Two mistakes recur on exams. One treats a live hearing as always required before an expert may testify, when a full pretrial record can supply what live testimony would. The other treats the hearing as optional in every setting, which ignores that a material dispute about reliability must be resolved by the judge with findings, and that refusing live testimony on a disputed fact that decides the case invites reversal. A sound answer asks whether the opponent has raised a real dispute, whether the written record resolves it, and which side must prove that Rule 702 is satisfied.