Concept
State Court Approaches
Reliability and relevancy
State Court Approaches
The Supreme Court's decisions in Daubert and Kumho Tire bind only federal courts, and they do not compel a state to abandon the Frye general acceptance test.1 The earlier sections of this chapter describe federal practice, where Rule 702 requires that expert testimony be the product of reliable principles and methods and that the opinion reflect a reliable application of those principles and methods to the facts of the case.2 A state judge asks whatever question the state's own law prescribes, so the first step in any expert-evidence problem is to identify the court that is hearing the case.
The states fall into three groups. Most state trial courts apply some variation of the Daubert test.3 Others keep Frye. One list of Frye states names California, Illinois, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania, and Washington, and a Washington appellate court has held a Frye hearing on an instrument meant to assess the risk that sex offenders will reoffend (In re Detention of Pettis, 352 P.3d 841 (Wash. Ct. App. 2015)).4 California's decision in People v. Leahy, which subjected the horizontal gaze nystagmus test to a Frye hearing, shows the same approach at work.5 A third group applies a special state standard of reliability that may be informed by Daubert without simply adopting it.6
The sources count these groups differently. One says most states have jettisoned Frye in favor of Daubert.7 Another says almost half the states follow Daubert, while 14 states, including California and New York, do not, and most of those follow their own versions of the Frye rule.8 Because the tallies disagree, an answer should rely on the standard the facts identify and should not recite a head count.
The choice matters because the two tests give the trial judge different jobs. Under Frye, it was enough to poll the scientific community and ask whether the methodology is generally accepted. Under Daubert, the judge must decide whether the methodology is actually reliable, and general acceptance becomes one factor among several.9 The other factors are testing, peer review and publication, error rate, and standards governing use, so a technique a little short of general acceptance may still qualify.10 The judge's responsibility grows heavier under this approach. She may have to hold a hearing outside the jury's presence to weigh the data and arguments, and her decision stands on appeal unless she abused her discretion.11
The proponent of expert scientific testimony bears the burden of showing that it qualifies. Where other supporting evidence is unavailable, one source allows the proponent to carry that burden through its own experts. They must explain precisely how they reached their conclusions and point to an objective source, such as a learned treatise, a professional association's policy statement, or a published article in a reputable scientific journal. That source must show they followed the scientific method as practiced by at least a recognized minority of scientists in their field.12
A second variable is separate from the choice between Frye and Daubert: whether a state amended its own counterpart to Rule 702. Only about half the states followed the federal Advisory Committee's lead by revising their counterparts, and the rest keep the original version, which requires only that the expert be qualified and the testimony helpful.13 The wording of a state's rule therefore cannot be assumed to settle its judicial standard. The Uniform Rules of Evidence, a recommended set of rules for states that generally conform to the Federal Rules, took a hybrid route in 1999. They departed from Rule 702 and use Frye to decide admissibility at the outset, but they let the losing side challenge the decision on reliability. Generally accepted testimony is excluded if the opponent shows it is unreliable, and testimony that lacks general acceptance comes in if it is shown to be reliable.14
The outcomes differ because Frye makes acceptance the entire test, while a Daubert-style inquiry treats it as one input among several.15 An exam problem set in a state court therefore turns on the standard that state applies. If the stem names the standard, apply it. If it names a state known for retaining Frye, such as California or New York, ask whether the technique is generally accepted. If it names neither, say which standard you are applying and note that a state court may apply a different one.