Concept
Relevance of Exhibits
Real, demonstrative, and experimental evidence
Relevance of Exhibits
A pistol taken from a bedroom floor and a diagram of a burglarized apartment face the same first test as a witness’s answer on the stand. Rule 401 defines relevance in two parts.1 The evidence must have any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence,2 and that fact must be of consequence in determining the action.3 The first part asks what the exhibit does to the probabilities in the case. The second asks whether the fact it bears on matters to the lawsuit at all.
Rule 401 sets no separate standard for tangible items, and the other rules that govern exhibits work alongside it. Rule 901(a) requires the proponent to produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is, which matters because a pistol offered as the robbery weapon helps the jury only if it is that weapon.4 Rule 403 lets the court exclude relevant evidence when its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger such as unfair prejudice, confusion, misleading the jury, delay, waste of time, or cumulative evidence.5 Neither rule replaces the definition. This unit takes the tendency requirement first, then the consequence requirement, and then Rule 402, which sets the default for evidence that passes both.
Tendency to Prove a Fact
Rule 401(a) sets a low bar: evidence is relevant if it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence.6 The judge compares two versions of the case, one in which the jury has seen the exhibit and one in which it has not. If the exhibit moves the probability of some fact in either direction, the exhibit is relevant, however small the movement. The bar sits low because a trial is built from many small pieces of proof, and a rule that demanded each piece establish its fact alone would exclude the pieces from which cases are assembled.
Take an armed-robbery prosecution in which the state offers testimony that the defendant owned a handgun before the robbery. Ownership alone does not prove guilt, and innocent explanations abound. Even so, a person with a gun is somewhat more likely to commit an armed robbery than a person without one, so the testimony makes guilt a little more probable than it would be otherwise. That probative relationship is all relevance requires. The state need not show that guilt is more probable than not, let alone beyond a reasonable doubt.7
Evidence that an accused tried to escape works the same way. The question is whether the probability that he committed the murder for which he is on trial rises to some degree because he attempted to escape. If it does, the evidence is relevant, and the jury weighs it with the other circumstantial evidence, such as fingerprints and bloodstains, in deciding whether guilt is established beyond a reasonable doubt.8 Relevance is therefore a question about one item. Sufficiency asks whether all the relevant evidence, considered as a whole, is enough to convict, and the jury answers that.
Probative value measures something else: how much an item shifts the probability. Relevance is a yes-or-no proposition, and an item is either relevant or irrelevant regardless of how much it helps, while probative value runs along a scale.9 Rules 401 and 402 ask only the yes-or-no question. Degree matters at Rule 403, which lets the court exclude relevant evidence whose probative value is substantially outweighed by a countervailing danger.10 Because the relevance requirement is so undemanding, the Federal Rules are often said to favor admissibility,11 and the price of admitting marginal evidence is paid at the balancing stage, where the judge can set a weak exhibit against what it risks.
Every relevance ruling traces a path from the exhibit to a fact, and the path is an inference that rests on an assumption about how people behave or how the physical world works. Suppose a parrot named Polly has disappeared, and the owner offers evidence that the gate to the yard was found open. The open gate supports the inference that a person opened it, which in turn makes it more probable that someone took Polly. The inference assumes that gates are usually opened by people rather than passing trucks. A truck might jiggle a latch loose, but experience says otherwise as a rule, and so long as the assumption underlying an inference is reasonable, the logic essential to relevance is established.12 Because evidence is relevant or not depending on which fact it is offered to prove, begin every analysis by naming that fact.13
Judges test the assumption against ordinary experience. In a suit over an injury in an office-building lobby, evidence of dim lighting is relevant, because dim lighting tends to point toward a hazardous condition and might show that lobby users could not see a step or a loose tile.14 Evidence that the walls had been painted pink and were repainted yellow shortly before the injury also concerns the lobby, but it could not influence a decision about the owner’s efforts to keep the lobby safe, and a court would keep it out as irrelevant.15
Evidence on both sides of a dispute can clear the threshold even when each side’s chain of inferences has several links. In Knapp v. State, a defendant charged with murdering a sheriff claimed self-defense and said he had heard a rumor about the sheriff. The prosecution introduced medical testimony that the man the sheriff was rumored to have killed had in fact died of an illness caused by alcoholism, not a beating. The court held that the medical testimony was logically relevant. It justified an inference that Knapp had not heard the rumor he claimed to have heard, which made it less probable that he had reason to fear the sheriff, which made it less probable that he acted in self-defense and more probable that he was guilty of murder.16
An object has no tendency of its own; it takes one from the facts that tie it to the case. Sometimes evidence is relevant only if certain other facts are also put in evidence. If those facts are not yet in, the judge may rule conditionally on counsel’s representation that the evidence will be “connected up” later, and if counsel defaults, the evidence may be stricken or a mistrial declared, depending on the degree and remediable nature of the prejudice.17
An officer’s testimony that she found that revolver beside the body, or an examiner’s match of the fatal bullet to it, would supply the missing link and make the same object relevant.
Read literally, Rule 401 is breathtaking in its inclusiveness. Any tendency, however tiny, to advance or decrease the apparent probability of a fact at issue will do, so that nearly anything even remotely arguable counts as relevant.18 For that reason, the best objection to an exhibit is rarely that it is irrelevant, and you should consider the other alternatives carefully.19 When you conclude on an essay that an exhibit is relevant, write out the inference and the assumption behind it even if relevance seems obvious. The reasoning is what shows that the exhibit changes the probability, and it is easy to forget.20
Fact of Consequence
Rule 401(b) adds the second condition: the fact the evidence addresses must be “of consequence in determining the action.”24 The tendency requirement asks whether an exhibit moves a probability. This requirement asks whether the proposition that moves has anything to do with how the case comes out. Logic cannot answer that question; the substantive law does. What is in issue is determined mainly by the pleadings, read in light of the rules of pleading and controlled by the substantive law. In a suit for workers’ compensation, evidence of contributory negligence is immaterial whether pleaded or not, since a worker’s negligence does not affect the right to compensation. In an action to enjoin a statute prohibiting “partial-birth abortions” as void for vagueness, expert testimony about a fetus’s capacity to sense pain is immaterial, since it bears only on the state’s interest in enacting the law and not on the claim of vagueness.25
Older cases and many lawyers call a proposition of this kind material. Rule 401(b) replaced that word with “fact is of consequence” because “material” had proved ambiguous.26
The lobby suit shows the requirement at work. Evidence that the building exceeds maximum height regulations stays out of a suit over injuries in the lobby, because compliance with height rules has nothing to do with the owner’s liability for the lobby’s condition. The evidence is immaterial, since it involves none of the legal issues in the case.27 In a dispute over a zoning violation, the same height would be relevant.28
A homicide prosecution supplies a clean contrast on a single charge. In Knapp, two facts determined the action. If Knapp deliberately killed the sheriff without justification, he was guilty of murder, but if he reasonably believed he had to kill or be seriously injured, he was not.29 Evidence on self-defense is evidence of a fact of consequence, because substantive criminal law recognizes self-defense. Evidence that the deceased asked to be killed is different. Homicide law does not accept the victim’s consent as a defense, so the proposition that evidence supports cannot affect the outcome, and the testimony is not relevant in the rules’ sense even if it would shape an ordinary person’s intuitive judgment of the defendant’s culpability.30
The substantive law reaches beyond the elements themselves, so facts of consequence fall into three groups:31
- Facts that are direct evidence of an element of a claim or defense, such as the killing and the absence of justification in a murder prosecution.
- Intermediate facts from whose establishment an element may be inferred, such as the attempted escape described above, which is circumstantial evidence of an element.
- Facts bearing circumstantially on how much weight to give other evidence, including demonstrative evidence and the credibility of witnesses, among them demeanor, impeachment, rehabilitation, and background information.
The third group exists because a jury cannot decide the elements without deciding whom and what to believe. The parties may question the credibility of witnesses and, within limits, produce evidence assailing and supporting it. A fact showing that a witness is biased is not an element and does not establish one, yet it changes how much weight the testimony on the elements deserves. Models, maps, diagrams, charts, photographs, videotapes, and computer animations can likewise be material as aids to the understanding of other material evidence.32
Background facts come in under the same definition. Rule 401 makes clear that evidence that is essentially background in nature and offered as an aid to understanding may be admitted, including biographical information about a witness, charts, photographs, views of real estate, and murder weapons connected solely to the crime.33 Even a detail that may not move the probability of any consequential fact, such as which street the lobby opens onto and whether a revolving door or a ramp leads in, is usually admitted. It aids the jury’s understanding of the relevant evidence and supplies what jurors expect in the telling of any story.34
The federal definition does not ask whether anyone disputes the fact. California’s does: Evidence Code § 210 reaches only a “disputed fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action,” so evidence tending to show a defendant’s negligence would be irrelevant there once negligence is conceded.35 The Supreme Court examined whether a party may reject an opponent’s stipulation and then offer evidence of facts that are not really in dispute in Old Chief v. United States. In its discussion of relevance, the Court quoted the Advisory Committee’s note: “The fact to which the evidence is directed need not be in dispute. While situations will arise which call for the exclusion of evidence offered to prove a point conceded by the opponent, the ruling should be made on the basis of such considerations as waste of time and undue prejudice (see Rule 403), rather than under any general requirement that evidence is admissible only if directed to matters in dispute.”36 The stipulation question itself returns under Rule 403, below.
The federal rule routes conceded points through Rule 403 for two reasons. First, a fundamental tenet of the adversary system is that a party may prove its case in the way it wants, and that tenet sits uneasily with a rule that would let the opponent concede facts out of the trial.37 Second, the Advisory Committee wanted the ruling made on considerations such as waste of time and undue prejudice, not under a general requirement that evidence be directed to matters in dispute.38 A concession shrinks what the evidence adds, and Rule 403’s weighing test can take that shrinkage into account case by case, while an all-or-nothing relevance test cannot.39
An objection that evidence is “irrelevant” can therefore rest on either part of Rule 401. The evidence may fail to make the fact it is offered to prove more or less probable, or the fact may not be one of consequence in the litigation.40 A written answer should say which part fails, because the first turns on logic and experience, while the second turns on the elements and defenses of the claim being tried.
General Admissibility Rule
Once an exhibit clears Rule 401, Rule 402 supplies the default answer. Relevant evidence is admissible unless the United States Constitution, a federal statute, the Federal Rules of Evidence, or other rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise, and irrelevant evidence is not admissible.43 The rule restates two axioms of the common law: a system that aims at the truth lets the parties place before the fact-finder everything that bears on the issues, and it turns away evidence that lacks probative value.44 Together, Rules 401 and 402 set the broad principle that evidence making any fact at issue more or less probable comes in unless the Rules provide otherwise, and Rule 403 and the specific rules that follow supply the limits.45
The rule starts from admission because every exclusion costs the fact-finder part of the picture. Unless some distinct ground for refusing to hear evidence exists, the evidence should be received.46 The party who wants relevant evidence out must therefore point to one of the sources Rule 402 names. Rule 403 confirms the design. It permits exclusion only when probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusion, or wastefulness, which tips the scales toward admission, though the trial judge keeps considerable discretion in applying the test.47
The rules that can override the presumption protect different things, and knowing which one a fact pattern invokes helps you choose the right objection. The rules on witness competency, hearsay, authentication, and the original writing protect the jury from testimony that may not be worthy of belief. The privilege rules give up highly relevant evidence to protect relationships that society values. Rule 403 is a general exclusionary rule that applies broadly to almost all proffered evidence.48 Rules 404 through 412 address particular types of evidence that have generated problems, and they generally limit the purpose for which the evidence may be introduced rather than flatly prohibiting it.49
For exhibits, the consequence is simple but easy to overlook. Relevance gets an item to the door; it does not carry the item in front of the jury. The proponent must still satisfy the authentication requirement, and the exhibit must still survive Rule 403, which the rest of this chapter takes up.