Concept
The Authentication Requirement
Real, demonstrative, and experimental evidence
The Authentication Requirement
Before an exhibit can prove anything, it must be what its proponent says it is, and Rule 901(a) enforces that rule: the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.1 The claim differs from exhibit to exhibit. This gun is the one used in the crime; this email came from the defendant; this letter is the one the parties signed. The proof that ties the exhibit to its claim, called the foundation, differs accordingly, but the standard for judging that proof does not.
Authentication is a conditional relevance problem. A gun is relevant to show that the defendant killed the victim only on the condition that it is the gun used in the crime, and a contract is relevant to show that the agreement existed only on the condition that it is the document the parties signed.2 An email that the government claims the defendant sent works the same way: if another person wrote it, it is irrelevant and inadmissible.3 Rule 104(b) already states the rule for relevance that depends on a fact. The proponent must introduce proof sufficient to support a finding that the fact exists, and the court may admit the evidence on the condition that the proof be introduced later.4 Authentication applies that rule to writings and objects, and Rule 901 adopts the same sufficiency standard.5 Only a small group of documents viewed as self-authenticating escapes the requirement.6
The sufficiency standard is not a heavy one.7 The proponent need not convince the judge that the item is genuine. A prima facie showing is enough: evidence that, viewed in the light most favorable to the proponent, would permit a reasonable juror to find it more probably true than not that the item is what the proponent claims.8 The judge neither weighs credibility nor decides whether the conditional fact is true. In Huddleston v. United States, where the conditional fact was that certain televisions were stolen, the court explained that the trial judge simply examines all the evidence and decides whether the jury could reasonably find that fact.9 The common mistake is to treat the authentication ruling as a contest the proponent must win, so that any doubt the judge feels becomes a ground for exclusion. A doubt justifies exclusion only when no reasonable juror could resolve it in the proponent's favor.
The judge screens; the jury decides. If the proponent offers no proof, or too little to support a finding, the exhibit is excluded. If the proponent offers enough, the exhibit comes in and the jury makes the ultimate decision on authenticity.10 The screen earns its keep because a writing handed to the jury without any contextual information would be confusing and perhaps misleading, and even a jury that could spot an unsupported exhibit would waste time receiving it.11 Admission leaves the contest open. The opponent may rebut, for instance with testimony that a document is a forgery, and try to persuade the jury that the item is not what it purports to be.12 A jury that agrees ignores the item, whether it concludes that a Facebook posting was made by a hacker or that Alena Leitner never made the call, because an item is probative only if it is what the proponent says it is.13
The judge takes the decision away from the jury only in extreme cases. One extreme is exclusion: the foundation is too thin for a reasonable person to find the item authentic, or the counterproof is so compelling that a reasonable person could only find it not authentic. The other is an instruction that the item is what its proponent claims, which is seldom given and might be improper against the accused in a criminal case.14 Between the extremes, the order of proof is largely within the judge's discretion. Evidence admitted on a promise to connect it up is excluded on a motion to strike if the connection is never made.15
A witness's testimony can carry the foundation even when the witness cannot specify identifying features of the item. In an assault prosecution, a witness named Papse testified about the ax the government offered as the weapon. On that testimony a reasonable juror could find that the ax was the weapon allegedly used in the assault. Papse's ability or inability to specify identifying features, and the evidence that the ax's condition had changed, went to the weight of the exhibit rather than its admissibility. The jury remained free to reject the government's claim, but the requirements of Rule 901(a) had been met.16
Circumstantial evidence can also supply the link. In a suit over an injury from a light bulb that came apart, a court found the bulb sufficiently authenticated from the surrounding facts. Access to the area where the injury occurred, and where the bulb was found, was limited. Mr. Riley stated that Rexnord would not keep a broken bulb unless there was a reason to do so. The plaintiff said he had installed a G.E. bulb in the same socket two weeks before the accident. Together those facts let a jury reasonably conclude that the bulb in question was the one that came apart and injured the plaintiff.17 The proponent does not have to rule out possibilities inconsistent with authenticity, and evidence sufficient to authenticate can be direct or circumstantial.18
The standard also marks what a proponent may not assume. For a document that is not self-authenticating, the law does not presume genuineness.19 A signature on the document is not, standing alone, enough, and neither is the fact that an email purports to come from someone.20 Evidence law is more circumspect than everyday life because it operates in a milieu of conflict, often before a lay jury.21 A party may have fabricated a writing to generate a claim, and a writing may be mistakenly attributed to someone who fortuitously shares the true author's name; the requirement protects against both.22 The added proof can be modest. Testimony from the signer, from a witness to the signing, or from anyone with minimal acquaintance with the signature will do, as will circumstantial evidence such as peculiar penmanship or peculiar knowledge shown by the writer, a proven handwriting sample displayed to the jurors for comparison, proper business custody, or a stipulation or admission.23
Authentication is not limited to objects and writings. Rule 901(b) also covers voice identification and telephone calls, because the identity of a person in a conversation is usually critical to its relevance.24 Suppose a caller identifies herself as Alena Leitner. The call is authenticated if the person who received it recognized the voice as Leitner's, if the caller revealed information likely to be known by Leitner, if Leitner frequently stutters and so did the caller, or if the caller acted after the call as Leitner would.25 The same logic governs online posts: a Facebook post attributed to the defendant is clearly relevant, but only if the defendant actually made it.26
Authentication is a bigger hurdle in criminal trials than in civil litigation, and fewer authentication questions there are resolved by stipulation.27 Clearing the hurdle does not finish the job. Before a document is admissible to prove its contents, five matters must be resolved: relevance, authentication, the best evidence rule, hearsay, and the balance of probative value against unfair prejudice.28 Even an authentic, relevant exhibit may be excluded if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, misleading the jury, undue delay, wasting time, or needlessly presenting cumulative evidence.29