Concept
Photographs and Recordings
Real, demonstrative, and experimental evidence
Photographs and Recordings
A photograph, a film, or a sound recording seems to hand the jury the event itself rather than a witness's account of it. The exhibit must still be tied to something, and Rule 901(a) states the tie: the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.1 For these exhibits the claim is a connection to a particular scene, person, or occurrence, such as a picture said to show one intersection or a tape said to capture one conversation. The foundation supplies the minimum assurance that the connection exists.2 What the proponent must show depends on how the exhibit was made. If a person perceived the scene, that person can say whether the exhibit matches it. If no person did, the proponent must show that the machine can be trusted. This unit follows that line from still photographs to recordings, then to images that have been posed, enhanced, or animated, and last to the hurdles that remain after authentication.
Still Photographs
A still photograph is authenticated by testimony from any person with personal knowledge, at a time relevant to the issues, of what the photograph depicts. The testimony must support a finding that the photograph is a fair and accurate representation of the subject at that time.3 The photographer is not required. The reason lies in what a photograph claims, which is that the picture matches the scene. Anyone who knew the scene can test that claim. The person who pressed the shutter may know no more about the scene than any other observer and may be impossible to find.
Time alone does not weaken the foundation. A lapse between the taking of the photograph and the moment of consequence in the lawsuit is irrelevant if conditions have not changed. Changed conditions also do not bar a photograph if, once the changes are explained, the trier of fact can understand the picture as a correct and helpful representation.4 A limit remains, because the nature of a photograph makes it hard to separate illustration from assertion. A change that no explanation can cure may leave the picture so confusing or misleading that Rule 403 requires exclusion.5
The two photographs differ in one respect, the fit between the picture and the scene at the relevant time. A witness who knew the original layout could bridge the gap by identifying the median as the only change, and the jury could then discount the picture for that difference. Without such a witness, the proponent has offered an image whose accuracy nobody can vouch for, and the foundation fails at its first step.
Recordings and Silent Witnesses
A film or videotape may be authenticated by the photographer or by any witness who was present when it was made and who therefore perceived the events filmed.7 Proponents often add proof that the operator was experienced, that the equipment worked, that the film or tape was not tampered with, and, for motion pictures, that the film was developed in the usual and customary manner.8 Where tampering is a live concern, chain-of-custody witnesses let the opponent explore the opportunities for it, and superimposed time and date markings on the tape can supply internal evidence.9 An objection that a video is distorted, unduly prejudicial, or edited and therefore misleading is resolved under Rule 403, not by the authentication rule.10
An eyewitness foundation treats the recording as an illustration of what the witness perceived. A second theory, the silent witness, treats a photograph or recording as substantive evidence in its own right.11 The traditional foundation for a recording as an illustrative aid may not be adequate when the recording is offered on that second theory.12 Where the fiction of an illustrative purpose is unavailable, as with x-rays and the automatic photograph of a bank robbery, or where the contents are clearly what the proponent seeks to prove, the photograph is admitted as substantive evidence.13
Sound recordings reach the jury through one of two foundations, depending on whether anyone heard the sounds as they were made. A witness who overheard the conversation can authenticate the recording by testifying that it accurately reproduces what was said. If no witness overheard the crucial information being recorded, the proponent must use the silent-witness process, which means testimony about the accuracy of the recording system and the absence of tampering, often through chain of custody.14 Under either foundation, sound recordings are independent substantive evidence of messages, conversations, or other sounds, and it would blink reality to treat them as merely illustrative.15
The silent-witness foundation is an application of the process-or-system method of Rule 901(b)(9), which calls for evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result.16 A standard illustration is a computer-generated distance measurement taken from a digital photograph, authenticated by showing that the computer calculated the real distance according to the correct scale.17 The reason follows from the missing observer. When no person perceived the event, the machine is the only witness, so the foundation must show that the machine can be trusted. Output generated entirely by a machine is not a declarant's statement, a point the court made about a chromatograph printout in United States v. Washington, although the proponent must still authenticate the output.
A transcript of a recording follows the demonstrative pattern. It must itself be authenticated as an accurate rendition of the authenticated recording. It is usually treated as an aid to the jury's understanding of the recording, so it is not admitted as evidence of the recording's contents and is not taken into the jury room during deliberation.18
Posed, Enhanced, and Animated Images
Enlarged and color photographs are permitted within the court's discretion, and so are slow-motion and computer-enhanced versions.20 The danger in each is distortion. Digital presentations may present facts in a distorted or inaccurate manner, and federal courts address that concern under Rule 403.21
Posed photographs and reconstructions carry a greater risk, because nobody perceived the posed event as it happened. Posed stills, films, and videotapes that reconstruct an event are sometimes admitted and sometimes regarded with disfavor, since the trier of fact may be misled into giving them disproportionate emphasis.22 Vivid footage invites jurors to confuse art with reality. Its impressions are hard to limit by instruction or, if the film is later held inadmissible, to expunge. A preliminary viewing in chambers and a prior hearing on admissibility can largely eliminate that difficulty.23
Computer animations follow the same pattern. An animation is admissible if a foundation of sufficient similarity is presented, subject to Rule 403.24 A re-creation animation is described as illustrative of an opinion the testifying expert has already reached. A simulation helped generate the opinion and is therefore substantive evidence.25 That difference matters because a simulation is the work product of many out-of-court actors whose knowledge and beliefs affect its reliability. They include the sources of its factual basis, the sources of its scientific and technical formulae and assumptions, and the people who designed, tested, selected, and operated the program. Those sources can be tested through witnesses in court or through the rules on expert opinion, Rules 702 and 703.26 A simulation also raises additional concerns about similarity and about the reliability of the explanatory theory it uses.27
Authentic but Still Excludable
Authentication answers one question, whether the exhibit is what the proponent claims it is, and a photograph or recording can pass that test and still be kept out. Rule 402 makes relevant evidence admissible unless the Constitution, a federal statute, the Federal Rules of Evidence, or other rules prescribed by the Supreme Court provide otherwise, and the hearsay rule is among those Rules.29 A photograph, motion picture, videotape, or animation is ordinarily not hearsay. If the image depicts a person making an oral or written assertion, or performing nonverbal conduct intended as an assertion, the depiction is hearsay when offered to prove the truth of what was asserted.30 A videotape of an accident scene showing where the cars came to rest raises no hearsay issue. A videotape of the same scene that captures one driver saying the other ran a red light is hearsay when offered to prove that the other driver ran the light.31 The camera's accuracy says nothing about whether the speaker told the truth. Recorded messages and conversations raise the same problem, since they are frequently hearsay when offered for their truth, and authentication is no guarantee of admissibility.32
Rule 403 is a separate check on an exhibit that has cleared authentication and the hearsay rule. The court may exclude relevant evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger such as unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, misleading the jury, undue delay, or wasting time.33 The immediacy of a photograph gives it convincing power and creates a potential that the jury will overvalue it.34 Even so, a properly authenticated and highly probative photograph is unlikely to be excluded on unfair prejudice alone. Exclusion becomes more likely when its probative value is slight or the fact it proves is unimportant or undisputed.35 A frequent error is to treat a successful foundation as the end of the analysis, when relevance, hearsay, and Rule 403 each remain to be run. The balancing test and the treatment of gruesome exhibits are developed later in this chapter.