Concept
Working Through an Exhibit
Real, demonstrative, and experimental evidence
Working Through an Exhibit
An exhibit reaches the jury only after it clears several tests, each drawn from a different rule. Rule 401 asks whether the item has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the item, and whether that fact is of consequence in determining the action.1 Rule 901(a) asks whether the proponent has produced evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is.2 Rule 403 asks, of an exhibit that has passed both, whether its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger such as unfair prejudice, confusing the issues, or misleading the jury.3 Rule 402 connects the three: relevant evidence is admissible unless the Constitution, a federal statute, the Rules, or other Supreme Court rules provide otherwise, so the hearsay rule and Rule 403 can each exclude an exhibit that is relevant and genuine.4 This section runs one exhibit through all of them in order.
Keeping the tests apart matters because an exhibit can fail one and pass the rest. Relevance asks whether the exhibit bears on the case, authentication asks whether it is what its proponent says it is, and Rule 403 asks whether it is worth what it costs the trial. Showing that an exhibit is powerful therefore does nothing against an objection that it is unauthenticated, and showing that it is genuine does nothing against a Rule 403 objection. For physical items the first two questions often travel together. A gun offered at a murder trial helps resolve the case only if it is in fact the gun used in the crime, which the Rules treat as a matter of conditional relevancy: the jury decides whether the gun is what the prosecution claims, and the judge ensures that a reasonable juror could so conclude.5
Step one does the most work, because the claim an exhibit makes fixes what the later steps demand. A pistol offered as the robber's pistol can make the robbery more probable only if it is the robber's pistol, so its identity must be supported before it proves anything. A diagram of the lobby needs only a witness who can say that it matches the room.
Step three asks only whether the foundation is sufficient. The judge screens the evidence and the jury decides. Only in extreme cases does the judge take the decision over: when the foundation could not enable a reasonable person to find the item authentic, or when the counterproof is so cogent and compelling that a reasonable person could only find it not authentic.6 A judge's private doubt does not decide the objection. Suppose the judge personally believes a letter is less than twenty years old but recognizes that the opposite finding would be supportable on the proponent's evidence. That belief is no valid reason to rule the letter unauthenticated, because the proponent need only introduce evidence adequate to support a finding, and the correct ruling is that the letter is authenticated.7
Objections to physical exhibits often land on step three, and the court then holds what amounts to a mini-hearing. Lieutenant Goldbloom testifies that he found a gun on the bedroom floor about five feet from the victim's body, and the defense objects that the gun is not authenticated. The court does not ask whether the gun is certainly the murder weapon. It asks whether a reasonable juror could conclude from his testimony that it is the gun used in the crime.8 A different objection, that the gun's effect on the jury outweighs its worth, would belong to step five, and a reply aimed at one objection leaves the other standing.
The same object can fail one theory and succeed on another, so a failure at step three should send you back to step one. Suppose a plaintiff offers a screwdriver as the one that injured him, and his evidence cannot support a finding that it is that screwdriver. It is not properly authenticated and is excluded as real evidence. But if it helps his case, he can describe it as very similar to the one that hurt him, and it can then be admitted for the limited purpose of illustrating his testimony.9 The exhibit has been reclassified as an aid, and its claim has shrunk from being the tool to resembling it.
Shocking exhibits invite the laziest exam answer, which calls the photograph inadmissible and stops there. That label names no rule and skips the steps. Ask instead which step the facts actually fail.
Both exhibits are authentic, relevant, and untouched by any other rule, and the weighing at the end separates them. The slingshot has high probative value and little danger. The photograph has slight value, since the point it shows is conceded, and a large danger, since the horror comes from the autopsy and not from the crime. Rule 403 permits exclusion only when probative value is substantially outweighed, so a close call would go to admission, and the photograph fails because the imbalance is large.10 Relevance survives the concession because Rule 401(b) requires a fact of consequence and does not require a disputed one, so the concession matters at step five, where it shrinks what the photograph adds.11 An answer that calls the photograph irrelevant is therefore wrong at step two, an answer that calls it unauthenticated is wrong at step three, and only the Rule 403 objection fits.
Step four exists because genuineness settles one question and no more. A letter from a bystander that a witness authenticates as genuine still meets a hearsay objection when it is offered to prove what it asserts, because the letter's authenticity says nothing about whether its author told the truth. Rule 402 explains why: relevant evidence is admissible unless the Rules provide otherwise, and the hearsay rule is one of the Rules that can do so.12 The exhibit must clear every remaining rule on its own terms, and a ruling on authentication binds none of them.
Step five has a remedy short of exclusion. Summaries and similar aids laden with conclusions are helpful, but they risk undue influence on the jury. Courts have resolved that tension by instructing the jury explicitly that such a summary is not itself evidence and may not be relied on as substantive proof.13
Marking and introducing carry the court's rulings into the record. Exhibits must be marked, even one used solely to refresh a witness's recollection, but an exhibit that is merely marked cannot be relied upon by the jury in reaching a verdict. To serve that role, it must be introduced into evidence.14