Concept
Claiming and Waiving
Spousal immunity
Claiming and Waiving
Trammel v. United States gave the privilege against adverse spousal testimony to the witness-spouse alone, who "may be neither compelled to testify nor foreclosed from testifying."1 In the federal system and most states, that sole holder can claim the privilege or waive it as she wishes.2 So when the prosecution calls a spouse to the stand, the witness-spouse decides whether to speak. The defendant cannot stop a willing spouse, except by objecting to a confidential marital communication, which is a different privilege.3
The facts of Trammel show how complete that choice is. The petitioner's wife chose to testify against him. She did so after a grant of immunity and assurances of lenient treatment, and the Court held that this did not make her testimony involuntary, so the lower courts correctly rejected his claim of privilege.4 This section follows the privilege into the courtroom: when the witness-spouse must claim it, what a late claim costs, when it does not apply at all, and where jurisdictions split on procedure.
The Claim Comes Before the Oath
The witness-spouse should claim the privilege before being sworn. When the adverse testimonial privilege applies, it keeps the witness-spouse off the stand,5 so the claim is a single decision made at the threshold: take the stand or do not. A privilege not claimed then may be treated as waived, and the waiver is clear once the spouse begins to testify.6 A rule that allowed a later claim would let the witness answer the safe questions and stop where the answers turn damaging, and the jury would hear an account the witness had edited. The early deadline prevents that.
Carla spoke before the oath, when the choice is hers to make. Jamal spoke only after he had given his answers. Exam writers often treat this privilege as an objection that can be raised question by question, but that description fits a different doctrine.
Two Privileges, Two Timings
The question-by-question objection belongs to the confidential marital communications privilege. A witness-spouse relying on it takes the stand and objects when a particular question calls for a private communication between the spouses, so the privilege is claimed selectively during the testimony.7 The adverse testimonial privilege works differently, because when it applies it keeps the witness-spouse off the stand altogether.8 That difference in procedural reach is the point. The testimonial privilege can keep a spouse completely off the stand, while the communications privilege merely bars the spouse, once on the stand, from disclosing certain communications between the spouses.9
The two privileges also have different holders. The communications privilege is held by, at a minimum, the communicating spouse, and the adverse testimonial privilege is held by the witness-spouse.10
For the defendant, the split decides what can be blocked. He can keep his spouse from testifying to a confidential communication made during the marriage, but he cannot prevent her from testifying to acts that are not communicative. She could not testify that he told her in confidence that he robbed a bank, but if she is willing, she may describe what she saw him do.11
Favorable Testimony Is Not Protected
The privilege has no application when a spouse is called to give favorable testimony. A spouse who testifies in the party's favor on direct is cross-examined like any other witness, and any question within the scope of the direct that calls for adverse testimony is permitted.12 The privilege protects against adverse testimony, so a party who calls the spouse to help cannot shield the spouse from questions about the ground the direct opened.
Procedure in the Courtroom
Several procedural questions remain, and authority divides on each.13 The holder must first be identified, and jurisdictions disagree about who it is. The federal system and most states choose the witness-spouse; State Law Variations, below, takes up the others. Three further disagreements recur:
- Whether it is error for the prosecution to call the spouse to the stand, which forces the accused spouse or the witness-spouse to object in the jury's presence.
- Whether the exercise of the privilege may be commented on. Most courts preclude comment, which reinforces the privilege.
- Whether the trial judge must inform the witness-spouse that the privilege is available. Some jurisdictions require it and others do not.
The first two disagreements share a concern: what the jury sees of the privilege at work. Calling the spouse forces an objection in front of the jurors, and most courts bar comment on the exercise of the privilege.14 The third follows from the timing rule above. A spouse who does not know the privilege exists can lose it by failing to claim it before the oath. Jurisdictions that require the trial judge to advise the witness-spouse close that gap, and the others leave the burden on the witness-spouse.