Concept
Survival After Marriage Ends
Marital communications
Survival After Marriage Ends
A confidential communication made during a marriage stays privileged after the marriage ends. The privilege protects the content of what spouses said to each other in confidence while married,1 so protection attaches when the words are spoken and does not depend on the spouses' status at trial. In Pereira v. United States the petitioners conceded that the divorce had removed any bar of incompetency, so the former wife was a competent witness against her ex-husband. They argued instead that divorce does not terminate the privilege for confidential marital communications, and the court called that a correct statement of the rule.2 Divorce decides who may be called to the stand. It does not reopen what was said in confidence.
The two marital privileges part ways when the marriage ends. A spouse's incompetency to testify for the other, and each spouse's privilege against adverse testimony, both terminate when the marriage ends by death or divorce; the privilege for confidential communications does not.3 That permanence accounts for a large share of the attempts to invoke the communications privilege, because while the marriage lasts one of the other, more embracive marital privileges frequently applies.4 Set side by side, the confidences privilege has a duration of “forever” and the testimonial privilege lasts only “during marriage.”5 The confidences privilege protects the interval of the marriage, so it blocks post-dissolution testimony describing private communications from that interval, while the testimonial privilege applies only if the spouses are married when the testimony is sought.6
Each privilege follows from its own purpose. The testimonial privilege aims to prevent the strain that testimony puts on a marriage, so the spouses must be married when the testimony is given, whether or not they were married when the events happened. The confidences privilege aims to encourage marital communication in the population generally, so the speakers must have been married when they spoke, though not necessarily when the testimony is sought.7 An encouragement that lapsed with the marriage would encourage little. The privilege's chief sponsor, Greenleaf, concluded that encouraging confidences required not merely temporary but permanent secrecy, American courts accepted that need for permanent protection, and about half the statutes codifying the privilege say expressly that it continues after death or divorce.8 The lawyer-client privilege shows the same logic at work. Federal decisions have long recognized it to encourage clients to make full disclosure,9 because a client who knew that damaging information could more readily be obtained from the lawyer than from himself would be reluctant to confide.10
Divorce leaves both former spouses able to use the privilege. One statement of the rule says that the marital communications privilege permits either spouse, or an ex-spouse, to assert it to bar testimony about confidential communications between the spouses during their marriage.11 The speaker can therefore object even when the person on the stand is a competent former spouse who is willing to testify.
Death produces the same split. One court explained that the privilege it was discussing ends when the marital relationship ends through the death of a spouse, because that privilege's policy of protecting family harmony cannot be served once the relationship has ended.12 Family harmony is the concern of the testimonial privilege. The confidences privilege continues after death as it does after divorce.13
The privilege protects the interval of the marriage, so a court must find a marriage during that interval. The spouses must have been married when they communicated, and that is a question of state law: states vary widely on common-law marriage, so people living together in identical arrangements may be married in one state and unmarried in another.14 The marriage must also have been viable. Courts do not assess the quality of a marital relationship, but they look for objective evidence that a marriage was not viable, and a confidence spoken during a viable marriage keeps its privileged status no matter what happens to the relationship afterward.15 Words spoken before the wedding fall outside the interval. Much of the former wife's testimony in Pereira concerned matters before the marriage, along with statements made in front of third persons, acts that were not communications, trips taken with third parties, and her own acts, and the court found any residue that might have been meant as confidential too slight to matter.16
The two privileges thus run in opposite directions on the same calendar. A later marriage can supply the status the testimonial privilege needs but cannot rescue earlier words under the confidences privilege, and a later divorce ends the testimonial privilege while leaving the confidences privilege intact.17
Survival does not alter any other element of the privilege. In Pereira the privilege outlived the divorce and still could not bar the former wife's testimony, because the communications involved were not confidential.18 Marital communications are presumed confidential, and the burden falls on the government to overcome that presumption,19 but proof of facts showing that the spouses did not intend privacy overcomes it.20 Statements made voluntarily in front of children old enough to comprehend them, or of other family members within the family circle, are not privileged.21 The privilege also does not extend to noncommunicative acts. Under that rule, and under the rule that a privileged communication loses its protection in a third party's hands, one court concluded that the privilege would not apply to a wife's testimony about her husband's beating their child to death.22
A question that mentions a divorce or a death before trial therefore asks three things in order: whether the spouses were validly and viably married when the words were spoken, whether the statement was a communication rather than an act, and whether it was confidential. If all three answers are yes, the later divorce or death changes nothing.
The permanence rule has critics. Some argue that spousal confidences, protected when spoken, should lose protection if the couple later divorces.23 Others would make the surviving privilege qualified, so that it yields in a case like Shenton v. Tyler. American courts have nonetheless accepted permanent protection, and about half the statutes that codify the privilege say expressly that it continues after death or divorce.24