Concept
Liability Insurance Only
Insurance coverage
Liability Insurance Only
Rule 411 covers one kind of insurance. It bars evidence that a person was or was not "insured against liability," and those three words set its boundary.1 Liability insurance pays for harm the insured does to other people, such as the policy that responds when a driver injures a pedestrian or a customer sues a store. Fire, life, health, and disability policies run the other way. They compensate the policyholder, or the policyholder's beneficiaries, for the policyholder's own loss. The rule is limited to insurance for liability and does not include these other forms of coverage.2
Two conditions must both be met before Rule 411 excludes evidence. The policy must be liability insurance, and the proponent must offer it to prove negligence or other wrongful conduct. Rule 411 and comparable state rules forbid that use, but they do not require exclusion when the evidence is offered for another purpose.3 A driver's liability policy offered to show that he drove carelessly meets both conditions, and the bar applies.4 The next sections take up why courts exclude this evidence and which other purposes they allow.
A fire policy fails the first condition. Suppose a defendant bought a fire policy shortly before his building burned under suspicious circumstances. The policy is first-party coverage, so it is not insurance against liability and Rule 411 does not reach it.5 The policy gave him a financial reason to want the fire, which makes it relevant to motive. The topic of insurance is the same as in the driver's case, but the kind of policy and the inference drawn from it are different.
Taking a policy outside Rule 411 does not make the evidence admissible, and students who treat the fire-insurance example as a rule of admission lose points. The ordinary rules still apply. The evidence must make a fact of consequence more or less probable, and the court may exclude it if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger such as unfair prejudice or confusion of the issues.6
Two questions sort any insurance problem on an exam. What kind of policy is it, and what inference does the proponent want the jury to draw from it? If the policy is liability coverage and the inference runs to fault, Rule 411 excludes the evidence. If the policy is of another kind, relevance and Rule 403 decide the matter, and a motive theory will often carry the evidence past both.