Concept
The Basic Prohibition
Compromise offers and negotiations
Settlement Evidence Under Rule 408
The Basic Prohibition
Rule 408(a) forbids one kind of use for settlement evidence: no party may offer it to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim.1 Validity asks whether the defendant owes anything at all; amount asks how much. Behind those two words lie two inferences the rule will not let a factfinder draw: that a party who offered money must think the claim is good, and that a party who asked for or accepted less must think it is weak. Every later question under the rule, including what counts as a permitted purpose, is measured against those inferences.
The prohibition runs against every party, not only the one who paid. Rule 408 is not a privilege that protects only the paying party; it blocks any party from using a settlement, even when the person who paid has left the case.2 One suit shows both directions at work.
Public policy explains why the bar must bind both sides. The system would grind to a halt if every filed case were tried, yet lawyers could not risk negotiating if what they said or did in trying to settle were later provable once the attempt failed.3 A bar that shielded only the offeror would defeat that purpose, because the receiving side could keep the concession and replay it for the jury, and an offeror who foresaw as much would never make it. The text reaches both ends of the transaction for the same reason. It covers furnishing, promising, or offering valuable consideration to compromise a claim, and it covers accepting, promising to accept, or offering to accept it.4
The same logic keeps a settling party's departure from reopening the evidence.
Phil is no longer a party, but that fact does not matter. The bar is not Phil's personal shield; it forbids any party, Oscar included, to use the settlement to prove the validity or amount of the claim.5
The bar is narrower than its force suggests, because it reaches only the two inferences about validity and amount. Subdivision (b) allows the court to admit compromise evidence for another purpose, such as proving a witness's bias or prejudice, negating a contention of undue delay, or proving an effort to obstruct a criminal investigation or prosecution.6 In each of those uses the evidence says nothing about whether the underlying claim is good or what it is worth. That difference is the yardstick for every proposed exception.
The rest of this chapter follows the rule's own text:
- Subdivision (a)(1) excludes offers, payments, and acceptances made to compromise the claim.7
- Subdivision (a)(2) extends the protection to conduct and statements made during compromise negotiations about the claim, with a carve-out for certain criminal cases involving claims by a public office exercising regulatory, investigative, or enforcement authority.8
- The opening clause of subdivision (a) also bars use of this evidence to impeach by a prior inconsistent statement or a contradiction.9
- Subdivision (b) lists the other purposes for which the court may admit it.10