Concept
Purpose and Scope of Rule 410
Plea negotiations
Plea Negotiations Under Rule 410
Purpose and Scope of Rule 410
A defendant who talks to a prosecutor about a deal, or who pleads and then takes the plea back, should not meet those words again in the government's case. Rule 410(a) makes that promise in one sentence: in a civil or criminal case, evidence of the covered pleas and plea statements is not admissible against the defendant who made the plea or participated in the plea discussions.1 The covered evidence includes a guilty plea later withdrawn, a nolo contendere plea (a plea of 'no contest'), statements made at the hearing on those pleas, and statements made while bargaining with an attorney for the prosecuting authority.2 Each category has its own conditions, and the sections that follow take them one at a time. Two phrases in the opening sentence settle most scope questions: the exclusion operates in civil as well as criminal cases, and it operates only against the defendant who made the plea or took part in the talks.
The rule exists to protect plea bargaining. Effective administration of the criminal law in many places would hardly be possible if a large proportion of charges were not disposed of by compromise, and excluding offers to plead is meant to promote that compromise.3 The reasons parallel those for excluding statements made in civil settlement negotiations under Rule 408: public policy favors compromise as a way of disposing of criminal charges, and without protection defendants would be less willing to bargain.4 Fairness points the same way. Essentially nothing a prosecutor says during bargaining is ever offered in evidence at a criminal trial, so letting the government use what the defendant or his lawyer says would put all of the risk on one side.5
Because the aim is to free the bargaining defendant to speak, Rule 410(a) is built around the person against whom the evidence is offered, not around the proponent's theory of relevance. If the government offers the evidence against the defendant who made the plea or took part in the talks, it is out, unless an exception applies or the defendant has waived the protection. Impeachment shows how far the bar reaches. The current federal text does not mention impeachment, but the original version of Rule 410 allowed voluntary and reliable statements made in court and on the record to be used for impeachment, and Congress deleted that language in 1975.6 The Second Circuit treated that history as unusually clear evidence that Congress meant to preclude impeachment use of statements made in plea negotiations, and other federal courts have agreed; state provisions that are silent are usually read the same way.7 That result fits the rule's purpose. A defendant who knows his bargaining words can come back to confront him on the witness stand has less reason to speak freely, and without protection defendants would be less willing to bargain.8 The common exam error is to reason that impeachment is a limited purpose that slips past the exclusion. For the testifying defendant, it does not.
The rule protects what lawyers say as well. A guilty plea is an admission under the party-admission exclusion from hearsay, and so is a plea-bargaining statement, whether it comes from the defendant personally or from his speaking agent, the lawyer.9 A rule limited to the defendant's own words would let the government prove the same admission through counsel, so the protection reaches what the defendant 'or his lawyer' says during bargaining.10
The protection also follows the defendant out of the case in which the plea was entered. To ensure that the consequences of a nolo plea stop at that case, statements made during the hearing cannot be used against the defendant in any later case, whether or not the plea was later withdrawn.11
The rule's purpose also marks its limit. Limiting the exclusion to use against the accused is consistent with that purpose, since use for or against other persons will not impair the effectiveness of withdrawing pleas or the freedom of discussion the rule is meant to foster.12 A plea or plea statement may therefore be used against someone other than the protected defendant, for example to impeach a nonparty witness. A stem in which the defense cross-examines a cooperating prosecution witness about her own earlier plea tests exactly this point.
The text bars use only against the defendant who made the plea or took part in the talks, so it does not, by its own terms, stop that defendant from offering evidence of them himself.13
The rest of this chapter follows the order of the rule itself: first the covered pleas and plea hearings, then statements made in discussions with a prosecutor, then the two exceptions for perjury prosecutions and for fairness and completeness,14 and then waiver, which is how a defendant can agree to give up the protection.15 The chapter closes by comparing Rule 410 with Rules 408 and 409, because exam questions often turn on the differences among the three.