Concept
Rule 410 Versus Rules 408–409
Plea negotiations
Rule 410 Versus Rules 408–409
Rule 410 shields plea negotiations the way Rule 408 shields civil compromise talks and Rule 409 shields payments of medical expenses, and exam questions like to test where the three part ways. Rule 410 bars the listed plea evidence in a civil or criminal case, but only against the defendant who made the plea or took part in the plea discussions.1 All three rules keep the protected conduct from being used to prove liability, and each protects something the law wants people to do. Rule 409, for example, encourages good Samaritans to pay an injured person's medical expenses.2 Statements made in connection with plea bargaining receive the same protection against use to show liability that Rule 408 gives compromise statements.3 The differences fall at four points: who must be across the table, which uses of the evidence are barred, whether related statements are protected, and how many exceptions the rule allows.
The criminal setting explains why Rule 410 is built more tightly than its civil cousins. Public policy favors disposing of criminal charges through bargaining, and without protection defendants would be less willing to bargain. Using a defendant's words against him would also be unfair, because essentially nothing a prosecutor says is ever offered in evidence at a criminal trial, so the risk runs in one direction only.4 Civil negotiators could once protect themselves by speaking indirectly ('let us assume for the sake of discussion'), but that device does not work in plea bargaining. The prosecutor wants to know exactly what the defendant believes to be true, and the defendant is expected to allocute, telling the judge why he is in fact guilty of the charge to which he pleads.5 Words are the whole currency of a plea negotiation, and each of the comparisons below follows from the firmer protection that fact requires.
The first difference is who stands on the other side. Rule 410(a)(4) reaches only a statement made during plea discussions with an attorney for the prosecuting authority, and only if the discussions did not result in a guilty plea or resulted in a later-withdrawn one.6 Rule 410 applies only where a prosecutor has been involved. Civil compromises and payments of medical expenses carry no similar limit on the identity of those involved.7 The prosecutor requirement also keeps a defendant who spoke to detectives or other investigators from recasting those statements as plea bargaining after the fact.8 A statement that falls outside Rule 410 for this reason is simply one that this rule does not exclude. Thus a suspect who offers a detective a guilty plea raises the question whether the listener was a prosecutor, while a civil party's offer to settle raises no comparable question about who received it.
The second difference is what the proponent may do with the evidence. Rule 408 forbids two forms of impeachment, by prior inconsistent statement and by contradiction, and leaves other forms such as bias or prejudice available. Settlement negotiations may also come in to show that a witness tried to obstruct a criminal investigation, as by buying someone off, and to prove lack of undue delay.9 Rule 410 is stricter. Evidence of the pleas may not be admitted to show bias or for any purpose other than showing criminal liability for the charged offense, which makes Rule 410 more restrictive than the parallel provisions for compromises and medical payments.10 Statements made during plea bargaining are admissible only to complete partial disclosures the defendant has made and in certain perjury prosecutions, so a bias theory does not open that door either.11
The wider protection follows from the candor reasoning above. A civil negotiator can hedge, so a few permitted collateral uses cost little candor. A defendant bargaining over a plea cannot hedge, and any doubt that a statement might return at trial restores the fear the rule exists to remove. One trap runs the other way. Rule 410 protects the defendant who made the plea, so a cooperating witness's own plea may still be used by the defense to show bias. The reason is that the plea is not offered against its maker, not that bias is a permitted purpose under Rule 410.12
The third difference concerns the statements that accompany an offer. Rule 408 reaches the compromise and the statements made in negotiating it, and Rule 410 does the same for plea bargaining, so neither may be used to show liability for the charged offense.13 Rule 409 is much narrower. Only the payment or offer to pay is excluded, and conversations about why the party paid, including a statement of fault, are admissible.14 The narrowness fits what Rule 409 is trying to encourage, which is the act of paying, and that act can be shielded without shielding the explanation given for it. A plea negotiation, by contrast, consists of words, and the defendant must be candid about what happened, so protecting the bargaining means protecting the statements.15
The fourth difference is how many routes around the exclusion each rule leaves open. Rule 408 permits an open-ended range of other purposes, such as bias, obstruction, and undue delay, so a proponent of settlement evidence has many ways to reach admission.16 Rule 410(b) allows two: plea-bargaining statements may be admitted to complete partial disclosures the defendant has made and in certain perjury prosecutions.17 The short list suits the narrow design. A defendant who cannot hedge needs a short, predictable list of events that can reopen the door, and completeness and perjury both turn on the defendant's own conduct. One practical qualification keeps the comparison honest. Many law enforcement officials refuse to negotiate unless the individual waives his rights under the rule, and the Supreme Court has upheld the effect of such waivers, so the narrow exceptions describe only the default rule.18